Dairy Island

183 S Robinson Ave, Newburgh
(845) 561-2312

Recent Reviews

Art Craig

Very nice and prompt service. Ordered a chicken sandwich. It was great. Would have ordered another one but I was saving g room for ? split. Which was also a treat to my pallet. The only problem is it is a seasonal place. Shame it wasn't open all

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 4

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Banana Split, Double Cheeseburger Boat

Heidi Osborne

I've been going here since i was a kid and im glad the person that bought it and took it over has done a great job the food is delicious and a great price!

Sherrell Council

Not the same, fries where soggy and the food had no seasons..and

ABDALLAH IRAQI

Nice spot for easy meal and ice cream ?they only accept cash

Leah Fieldson

So glad they are up and running before the summer ended! ?

Jakee Titkanich

Been coming from albany to this place since I was a kid i Hurd they are closing the place. They need to keep it up and running

Jen Schupp

Love coming here. Been coming for years. Great food, great people. Just wish they would open in March/April instead of Jun/July.

Denise Portillo

It's you usual dairy spot in town but they only accept cash. The food was ok, I got a cheeseburger that felt like I was eating bread more than anything. Really skimped out on the inside... ice cream is great though.

Peaceful Pear

Great been coming here for years. ??

Dennny S

It's you usual dairy spot in town but they only accept cash. The food was ok, I got a cheeseburger that felt like I was eating bread more than anything. Really skimped out on the inside... ice cream is great though.

Quincy Branch

Great ice cream and food

Brea W

Grew up in Newburgh, always used to love eating at Dairy Isle. Visited recently and the woman working the counter had a very nasty attitude over trying to pay for extra sprinkles. Handed me a melted vanilla cone very rudely. Terrible customer service, will not be returning.

Dean Winchester

Cheap prices, excellent ice cream, friendly, and quick service.

Alex Bauer

As ALWAYS for over 40 yrs they are THE BEST Ice cream ? and food spot around.

Ana. L.

Aaahh, Ice-cream the perfect treat and my favorite treat next to mini muffins. I'm glad this is open during Covid stay at home era. Today my husband and I were in the mood for soft served ice cream (the Mr. Softy truck kind) lol. We usually love to go out of the norm with flavors and textures of ice-cream but today I wanted specifically a plain vanilla ice-cream on a waffle bowl also my husband ordered a classic vanilla and chocolate swirl with chocolate sprinkles on a regular cone (that I also practically finished) I loved it.10 out of 10! They also serve food there. Fried food like fish and chips, burgers, fries and such. ( I Have not tried the food) These are dark times, We could all use a little more happiness eat ice cream and support local business! This way we both win!

Load More