Terrible customer service. Incredibly inconsistent. Some days you will get a great sandwich. Other days they don't give a hoot and just make you want they want.Slice is a terrible 3rd party service.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Larry E.
Johnny's is alright. The pizza is not the best in town. The bang-bang pizza, however, is pretty solid. The crust is lackluster, and the service is pretty good. I find the prices to be a little bit high comparatively. The spot downtown is a more roomy and inviting environment. The location on 17k is cramped.
gabriel russell
Sandwich bread was
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 4
brandon finnegan
I had to get back to work so didn't have time to come back in. I ordered an Italian Combo on a hard roll and grabbed an iced tea. That rang out to over $13. When I opened the box there was one slice of off brand ham, 2 slices of salami, 1 slice of pepperoni and one slice of provolone along with wilted lettuce and tomato on my sandwich. There was no oil and vinegar or Italian dressing on the sandwich; it was dry. When I went to eat the coleslaw that came with the sandwich I had to spit it out as it was literally fermenting. 0 out of 10 as far as food goes. I should have known I wasn't getting fresh food when I got an "Italian Combo" 45 seconds after ordering it.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 1
Service: 3
Vempati Roopeessh
My favourable Buffalo chicken
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Breakfast Sandwich
R D
I didn’t try the pizza but the breakfast sandwich I ordered was excellent! Friendly customer service.
Owen Henry
Great food,great service, and very clean.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Jordan Devita
Bought an Italian sandwich.. keep in mind it was half a sandwich. Cost was 12$On the sandwhich I received 1 piece of cheese, 1 piece of pepperoni & 1 piece of ham. 1 piece of salami & 4 jalapeño peppers. Presentation of the sandwich was nice but HUGE RIP OFF. save your money and go somewhere else. For 12$ you can get a sandwhich 100% better.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Cj V
This spot has tremendous pizza. The quality and service was well worthy of my visit. I’d highly recommend this to anyone looking for a quick bite to eat in the Newburgh area!
kirk toufor
Overpriced, underwhelming ,mediocre food served by rude
First time ordering here, the bread was stale the tuna didn't taste fresh, the lettuce was horrible. The sandwich look like it was thrown together smh. Never again!
Food: 1
Recommended dishes: Bagel
Carlos Luis Bermudez
I bought a ham and cheese hero and an Italian hero ... about $25 !!! The prices on their menu is not what their registers charge. The cashier said that the price on her screen was $1.75 more than the menu I looked at. Then the sandwiches were sooooo terrible .... barely any cold cuts and just a loaf of bread. Tons of lettuce though .... I usually go to Panchitos Deli on Liberty St but they were closed. Best hero's in Newburgh ??
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 1
Service: 2
Ximena Greco
This place is really, really bad, the counter service is horrible, the sandwich to go are not wrapped, and the Panini is not a Panini, it’s just a slice bread pressed on the grill, and not even really well done, never again, don’t waste your time or your money, because it’s not even cheap, prices are stiff! What a waste of my time, waited almost 20 minutes for a sandwich, and she serve people that got here after me!!
Daniel A.
Been going here for upwards of 5 years now. Small place in the middle of a hamlet, smacked between the town of Newburgh and the town of Montgomery. Top 10 in the whole Hudson valley for sure! Pizza is usually phenomenal! The Bang Bang slice out of this word, traditional crust, NY style...delicious. Plenty of toppings, plenty of choices, plenty of slices to go, pies to stay, cooler full of drinks, traditional and no traditional Italian dessert! Prices have been getting a little high, but the economy is driving ingredients up tremendously. 2 specialty slices and a bottle of soda $13.95....not terribly unreasonable. Atmosphere is cool, calm, quiet, and the TV is going usually all the time. Smells like a pizzeria, staff is great. 8/10
Terrible customer service. Incredibly inconsistent. Some days you will get a great sandwich. Other days they don't give a hoot and just make you want they want.Slice is a terrible 3rd party service.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Johnny's is alright. The pizza is not the best in town. The bang-bang pizza, however, is pretty solid. The crust is lackluster, and the service is pretty good. I find the prices to be a little bit high comparatively. The spot downtown is a more roomy and inviting environment. The location on 17k is cramped.
Sandwich bread was
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 4
I had to get back to work so didn't have time to come back in. I ordered an Italian Combo on a hard roll and grabbed an iced tea. That rang out to over $13. When I opened the box there was one slice of off brand ham, 2 slices of salami, 1 slice of pepperoni and one slice of provolone along with wilted lettuce and tomato on my sandwich. There was no oil and vinegar or Italian dressing on the sandwich; it was dry. When I went to eat the coleslaw that came with the sandwich I had to spit it out as it was literally fermenting. 0 out of 10 as far as food goes. I should have known I wasn't getting fresh food when I got an "Italian Combo" 45 seconds after ordering it.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 1
Service: 3
My favourable Buffalo chicken
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Breakfast Sandwich
I didn’t try the pizza but the breakfast sandwich I ordered was excellent! Friendly customer service.
Great food,great service, and very clean.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Bought an Italian sandwich.. keep in mind it was half a sandwich. Cost was 12$On the sandwhich I received 1 piece of cheese, 1 piece of pepperoni & 1 piece of ham. 1 piece of salami & 4 jalapeño peppers. Presentation of the sandwich was nice but HUGE RIP OFF. save your money and go somewhere else. For 12$ you can get a sandwhich 100% better.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
This spot has tremendous pizza. The quality and service was well worthy of my visit. I’d highly recommend this to anyone looking for a quick bite to eat in the Newburgh area!
Overpriced, underwhelming ,mediocre food served by rude
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Restaurantji Recommends
First time ordering here, the bread was stale the tuna didn't taste fresh, the lettuce was horrible. The sandwich look like it was thrown together smh. Never again!
Food: 1
Recommended dishes: Bagel
I bought a ham and cheese hero and an Italian hero ... about $25 !!! The prices on their menu is not what their registers charge. The cashier said that the price on her screen was $1.75 more than the menu I looked at. Then the sandwiches were sooooo terrible .... barely any cold cuts and just a loaf of bread. Tons of lettuce though .... I usually go to Panchitos Deli on Liberty St but they were closed. Best hero's in Newburgh ??
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 1
Service: 2
This place is really, really bad, the counter service is horrible, the sandwich to go are not wrapped, and the Panini is not a Panini, it’s just a slice bread pressed on the grill, and not even really well done, never again, don’t waste your time or your money, because it’s not even cheap, prices are stiff! What a waste of my time, waited almost 20 minutes for a sandwich, and she serve people that got here after me!!
Been going here for upwards of 5 years now. Small place in the middle of a hamlet, smacked between the town of Newburgh and the town of Montgomery. Top 10 in the whole Hudson valley for sure! Pizza is usually phenomenal! The Bang Bang slice out of this word, traditional crust, NY style...delicious. Plenty of toppings, plenty of choices, plenty of slices to go, pies to stay, cooler full of drinks, traditional and no traditional Italian dessert! Prices have been getting a little high, but the economy is driving ingredients up tremendously. 2 specialty slices and a bottle of soda $13.95....not terribly unreasonable. Atmosphere is cool, calm, quiet, and the TV is going usually all the time. Smells like a pizzeria, staff is great. 8/10
Good peoplegood pizzagood pricesyum