This is by far one of the best pizzas I have ever had. I am always trying to find something comparable to Bronx pizza and this place is it. Tried it by the slice while sitting in and took a pie to go. Each time the slices did not bend when making the initial fold. The sauce is delicious and the crust is perfectly crispy. When doing take out the second time we ordered garlic not. They were again perfectly crispy on the outside and a doughy master piece on the inside. 10/10 barstool sports needs to come in and rate it. That’s how good it is.
Food: 5
Service: 5
Mitch
Decent slice, but "Best in Orange & Rockland Counties" is a big stretch
Thomas
I recently visited this pizza shop and had an amazing experience! Firstly, the staff were incredibly friendly and accommodating. When I asked if they had any plant-based options, they were more than happy to make me a freshly made pie before closing time. It was so kind of them!Not only were the staff great, but the food was also top-notch. I couldn't resist ordering their garlic knots, and let me tell you, they were absolutely delicious. The perfect combination of softness and flavor. To wash it all down, I tried their passion fruit raspado, and it was seriously a treat for my taste buds!What impressed me the most was the efficiency of the service. Despite being a bit busy, they managed to serve our food quickly without compromising on quality. Everything was served hot and fresh!I highly recommend Mister Pizza for anyone looking for a great dining experience. I can't wait to go back and try more of their menu. Keep up the excellent work!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Willfred Cruz
Best Service, they remodeled bit, + the staff was nice and spoke español (spanish) one of the staff was enjoying the Womens World Cup Soccer Match with me, Food was amazing perfect amount of sauce and cooking
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Bob S.
We were in the mail and stopped for something quickKind of a disappointment. Almost $5. for a small bland slice. See the photo. There's a cozy dining area next to the ordering counter. That was the high point of the meal. It looks clean.
Wilma H.
As walking around the Newburgh Mall, after looking at the casino here, we stop for a slice, unfortunately it was not to my taste. It was slightly burnt but not that I couldn't eat it, but the flavor was not good. As if the flour wasn't cooked properly. More than half I couldn't eat. The place is neat and it a quiet place
Nicollette Cherelle
Asked if they could personalize a slice for me because I don't eat bacon and they were very rude and dismissive. Previously they were accommodating but this time was the complete opposite. Very inconsistent with their customer service and its ashame because they have good pizza.
Anthony Rivera
I went there for lunch today and ordered they're special (2 Slices and a drink) I paid and waited for my food and the two people in the back started making jokes about me and laughing in Spanish and the worst part about it is I could understand what they were saying when I finally got my the pizza was extremely greasy and soggy very disappointed that the people who work here act that way I don't recommend anyone comes here.
Batista DeHate
I went there for lunch today and ordered they're special (2 Slices and a drink) I paid and waited for my food and the two people in the back started making jokes about me and laughing in Spanish and the worst part about it is I could understand what they were saying when I finally got my the pizza was extremely greasy and soggy very disappointed that the people who work here act that way I don't recommend anyone comes here.
Not really an eye-catcher if anyone isn't a regular at this mall. A pizza place with an ordering counter in the hallway and within a few feet to the left, and inside with some tables. Pretty cool to see something like that in this establishment. There are a lot of topping choices to pick along with snacks and drinks. I ordered simply a slice with pepperoni and chicken ranch, all pretty good. Can't wait to explore the menu more on our next visit. Service was great and there were no issues. I see Mister Pizza being a success with many years to come.
William G.
This is one of my favorite pizza spots in the area. The crust is consistent and has a nice snap to it. Just a all around great slice of pizza. Highly recommended
Yarden Sussman
they do not answer the phones and half of the menu they refuse to make. the older workers there are not friendly or helpful and i feel so bad for the young girl that works there…. Why put something on the menu if you refuse to make it? I will never support this business again and I gave multiple chances and overlooked so much unprofessional behavior but highly suggest you support another local pizza business before this one
Stephanie Davis
If I could leave no stars, then I would. We decided to give this place a try since they claimed to be “the best pizza in Orange County”. Well, it is by far the worst. For one, it is the saltiest pizza I’ve ever eaten. Our pizza was literally an oval with the most deformed slices ever. It was cold and did NOT taste fresh by any means. The calamari is also very cold and not fresh at all. We will NEVER be ordering again.
First time I wanted to return pizza ?
Food: 1
This is by far one of the best pizzas I have ever had. I am always trying to find something comparable to Bronx pizza and this place is it. Tried it by the slice while sitting in and took a pie to go. Each time the slices did not bend when making the initial fold. The sauce is delicious and the crust is perfectly crispy. When doing take out the second time we ordered garlic not. They were again perfectly crispy on the outside and a doughy master piece on the inside. 10/10 barstool sports needs to come in and rate it. That’s how good it is.
Food: 5
Service: 5
Decent slice, but "Best in Orange & Rockland Counties" is a big stretch
I recently visited this pizza shop and had an amazing experience! Firstly, the staff were incredibly friendly and accommodating. When I asked if they had any plant-based options, they were more than happy to make me a freshly made pie before closing time. It was so kind of them!Not only were the staff great, but the food was also top-notch. I couldn't resist ordering their garlic knots, and let me tell you, they were absolutely delicious. The perfect combination of softness and flavor. To wash it all down, I tried their passion fruit raspado, and it was seriously a treat for my taste buds!What impressed me the most was the efficiency of the service. Despite being a bit busy, they managed to serve our food quickly without compromising on quality. Everything was served hot and fresh!I highly recommend Mister Pizza for anyone looking for a great dining experience. I can't wait to go back and try more of their menu. Keep up the excellent work!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Best Service, they remodeled bit, + the staff was nice and spoke español (spanish) one of the staff was enjoying the Womens World Cup Soccer Match with me, Food was amazing perfect amount of sauce and cooking
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
We were in the mail and stopped for something quickKind of a disappointment. Almost $5. for a small bland slice. See the photo. There's a cozy dining area next to the ordering counter. That was the high point of the meal. It looks clean.
As walking around the Newburgh Mall, after looking at the casino here, we stop for a slice, unfortunately it was not to my taste. It was slightly burnt but not that I couldn't eat it, but the flavor was not good. As if the flour wasn't cooked properly. More than half I couldn't eat. The place is neat and it a quiet place
Asked if they could personalize a slice for me because I don't eat bacon and they were very rude and dismissive. Previously they were accommodating but this time was the complete opposite. Very inconsistent with their customer service and its ashame because they have good pizza.
I went there for lunch today and ordered they're special (2 Slices and a drink) I paid and waited for my food and the two people in the back started making jokes about me and laughing in Spanish and the worst part about it is I could understand what they were saying when I finally got my the pizza was extremely greasy and soggy very disappointed that the people who work here act that way I don't recommend anyone comes here.
I went there for lunch today and ordered they're special (2 Slices and a drink) I paid and waited for my food and the two people in the back started making jokes about me and laughing in Spanish and the worst part about it is I could understand what they were saying when I finally got my the pizza was extremely greasy and soggy very disappointed that the people who work here act that way I don't recommend anyone comes here.
Restaurantji Recommends
Good food, decent prices and nice people.
Not really an eye-catcher if anyone isn't a regular at this mall. A pizza place with an ordering counter in the hallway and within a few feet to the left, and inside with some tables. Pretty cool to see something like that in this establishment. There are a lot of topping choices to pick along with snacks and drinks. I ordered simply a slice with pepperoni and chicken ranch, all pretty good. Can't wait to explore the menu more on our next visit. Service was great and there were no issues. I see Mister Pizza being a success with many years to come.
This is one of my favorite pizza spots in the area. The crust is consistent and has a nice snap to it. Just a all around great slice of pizza. Highly recommended
they do not answer the phones and half of the menu they refuse to make. the older workers there are not friendly or helpful and i feel so bad for the young girl that works there…. Why put something on the menu if you refuse to make it? I will never support this business again and I gave multiple chances and overlooked so much unprofessional behavior but highly suggest you support another local pizza business before this one
If I could leave no stars, then I would. We decided to give this place a try since they claimed to be “the best pizza in Orange County”. Well, it is by far the worst. For one, it is the saltiest pizza I’ve ever eaten. Our pizza was literally an oval with the most deformed slices ever. It was cold and did NOT taste fresh by any means. The calamari is also very cold and not fresh at all. We will NEVER be ordering again.