Pizza Mia

50 NY-17K, Newburgh
(845) 561-1400

Recent Reviews

Andrew (A)

So many varieties of vegan pizza, all of them killer.Vegetarian options: Vegan pies available and they are solid!

Food: 5

amber barnes

The staff was amazing. The pizza and galic knots were to die for. We asked for a specialty pizza that we've seen online and they nicely advised its a longer wait but it was worth it. I highly recommend and we live 2 hours away and we will be back! Thank you!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Wild Steve

Social media does this pizza place no proper justice for how awesome it is. Staff was very polite, and accommodating. The specialty pizza we asked for was no issue to be made, the garlic knots were aggressively garlicky, the vodka sauce was delicious, and the pizza was incredibly dense and cheesy. Will absolutely drive from MA here again.

Christopher Myhre

The TV was a little loud, and the pizza was too cheesy. However, they put a perfect amount of basil on it. Great service, walked in to being warmly welcomed. Great 2 cheese slices and medium drink deal for $7.00

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 3

Service: 5

Michelle Mateo

Delicious pizza! Always consistent ! Unlike most places in the area that don't even taste the same anymore. Definitely

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

DIMITRI Kasambalis

Great variety . Better tasting than most.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Tim Sphar

When travelling i'm always up for trying new vegan food, especially pizza - the cheese is the hardest thing to get right. I found this place on Monday night and I went back every night the rest of the week - it was that good. I did the Meat Haters (lol) the Cheesesteak pizza and the garlic cheesesteak pizza. And of course fried dough sprinkled throughout the week. Everything was fantastic. I'm sure their 'regular' menu is just as good, but in case anyone is looking for a good vegan pizza here you go.Vegetarian options: large vegan pizza menu (it says 2022 but it doesn't matter)

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Vegan Pepperoni Pizza, Vegan Cheese

Catherine C.

I'm gonna be honest, I was very worried when I walked in because it looked like all they were offering was the food at the front that sits out. It wasn't even kept hot with lights. They do have a menu that shows more options but its still not the whole menu, I had to pick up a paper one to see all the options. Once I did I got more excited. I ended up ordering spaghetti and meatballs and they were good. Nothing to rave about. I would have liked to try the pizza if only it were fresh. When you walk in you need to place your order, wait at the tables, then pay as you leave. I'm sure if I was local I'd eat there again but probably by ordering a pizza delivery not going in person. I will say the guy that served is was really helpful and nice though. Whereas the girl at the counter was a little subdued, but she did her job good.

Leonard Wennerberg

Just moved into the area and was my 2nd time here today . I like to get to pizza places between 11-12 so you get it nice fresh slice. So I ordered 2 specialty slices and a soda , I told the man don’t heat them cause I thought it was fresh . So I get to my car and open the bag and as soon as I felt the vodka slice it was ice cold like it just came out of the refrigerator!! So I call the store and a women picks up and I explain the issue and she is adamant that it was made fresh and was probably just room temperature!! Im not stupid and it’s a shame they are selling yesterdays food to customers and on top of that they are dishonest about it as well. Not only will I not be back but will make sure all my friends and family are aware how they operate as well.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 1

Service: 1

Jeremy Blitzer

Awesome food! Huge slices!

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Chicken Pizza

Miguel Rosello

Great authentic Italian dishes cooked from the heart! The best pizza and pasta in town!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Nita B.

Employees are always nice and friendly. I absolutely love their penne alla vodka with shrimp.

Alresch J.

Cozy little restaurant in the Target plaza. Was open during a particularly bad snow event and we were greeted cheerfully. Had some thick crust pizza that I've not been familiar with previously and it was delicious. Also had the rice balls which I probably shouldn't have gone for as they have been sitting there for a minute. Rookie move on my part I should have asked and that's probably why it's not a complete five on my rating.

Nicole T.

If I didn't need to give 1 star I wouldn't. Ordered a sausage parm and eggplant sub with a rice ball. Horrible sauce similar to what I'd expect ragu to task like and burnt bread on the subs (more burnt than not). On the eggplant sub it seemed like they didn't have enough eggplant and tried to stretch out what they had for it. The rice ball was just horrible and for $8 that's very sad. I would totally tell others not to waste their money here

Mari Baci

My cousin came to visit from the Caribbean and insisted we go here since she saw the pizza featured on instagram. When she landed the first thing she asked is “When are we going?”. Well, this place definitely didn’t disappoint. It’s very unassuming, it just looks like a regular pizza joint in a strip mall. But the pizza was outstanding and worth the 40 minute drive. They had unique pies like the Chick-Fil-A inspired chicken pizza mia pie and one covered with mozzarella sticks and a garlic knot crust.We dined in and tried a bit of everything, getting a chicken bacon ranch slice, a hot honey pepperoni slice, the aforementioned chicken mia and garlic knot crust slices, as well as 2 plain cheese slices and an arancini (rice ball). All the slices were great. The chicken pizza mia and hot honey were especially good. The arancini was served piping hot with a pool of homemade tasting marinara sauce. The sauce was very wine-y, which I don’t mind and actually like, but it was a surprise since usually pizza places have very basic marinaras. The best part was the price. It was pretty cheap for all that food plus 4 drinks. It only came out to something like $40 dollars.Overall, Pizza Mia is fantastic and worth the special trip. It’s a hole in the wall joint serving up unique and tasty pizza.Kid-friendliness: We had no problem dining with a baby. They had a high chair and everything.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Chicken Bacon Ranch, Garlic Knot Pizza, Selection of Pizza Slices, Cheese Pizza, Chicken Pizza Mia

Load More