The waitress seemed like she was more concerned about her friends and all the people hanging out The pizza was absolutely terrible and the summer it was a good place in the pizza smells so good but I don't know it went downhill I'll stick to the taco place next door from now on unless that changes too there's too many people hanging out in there grown people it's more of a hangout than a pizza
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 3
Service: 3
Marta Woolbert
Great food and
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Ric Gee
The salad and the sliders were delicious!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Meatball Sliders
Stephen Mascia
Great pizza and service.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Eddie Anglero
Was visiting from out of town and met up with my family, a party of 10. They were very busy but the staff and management were VERY accommodating. They pivoted to alternate seating for us and still made us feel welcome on an obviously very unexpected evening. The food was excellent and the service was spectacular. I will be sure to visit again next time I am in town!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizza Pizza
IC I3
The pizza was horrible mess. Greasy. Undercooked. I don’t understand why people think this is the best pizza in the area.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Brian G.
Just popped in for a dessert post-tacos. Ice cream looks great but we settled for a giant cookie and brownie. A great takeaway.
Clara O.
Took my family and friends and had the best service. They accommodated us so well on busy night. And the food was amazing.
Yajaira R.
We stopped by here because we were in the area. We ordered a pepperoni and margarita pizza and it was delicious! The garlic knots were a little dry, but edible. The booths were comfy to sit in and the staff were friendly.
Dana H.
You can't go wrong with anything on the menu. Pizza by the slice, fresh pies (the Eggplant Pie rocks), sandwiches (Meatball Parm is a standout), or salads. Everything is great. The only negative is its small size (fortunately there's a lot of outdoor seating in warmer weather) and their reduced hours since Covid. But the food and staff are great.
Came here a few times for pizza and it's solid. Their sandwiches and salads are great. Good portions, a bit pricey but worth it
Reggie Miller
Tried pizza several of times with take out orders. Including at former places of employment where management would order a bunch of pizzas for it's workforce. Pepperoni and veggie pizza was my favorite and had the most flavors outside of the cheese pizza. Have not dined in at restaurant but have passed it numerous times coming in and out of Newburgh.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 3
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza, Garlic Knots
Linda L.
Pizza shop is my go too pizza place. Everyone in there is respectful and polite. The female manager knows all of her customers by name and it makes you feel good that when you walk in there you feel like family. There is a short bald gentleman that's always in there. I thought he was the owner until I found out he is only a manager at the taco location. He is rude and always screaming at the employees. The owners should see that he is definitely not an asset to their business. I will always go to pizza shop. They have my loyalty. Thank you pizza shop for the pleasant experience.
Daniella J.
Excellent service & delicious pizza, every single time I visit Pizza Shop!! The manager Ashley is so sweet, professional & always a pleasure. I recommend Pizza Shop to everyone!!!
S L
Nice view. Many pizza optionsThey messed up our order. Forgot about it and left it in the oven for too long tillIt was burnt. Two parties who ordered after us were served first and we checked twice with them before they finally realised that the pizzas were still at the back of the oven. There was still some foil stuck to the base of the pizza too
The waitress seemed like she was more concerned about her friends and all the people hanging out The pizza was absolutely terrible and the summer it was a good place in the pizza smells so good but I don't know it went downhill I'll stick to the taco place next door from now on unless that changes too there's too many people hanging out in there grown people it's more of a hangout than a pizza
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 3
Service: 3
Great food and
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
The salad and the sliders were delicious!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Meatball Sliders
Great pizza and service.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Was visiting from out of town and met up with my family, a party of 10. They were very busy but the staff and management were VERY accommodating. They pivoted to alternate seating for us and still made us feel welcome on an obviously very unexpected evening. The food was excellent and the service was spectacular. I will be sure to visit again next time I am in town!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizza Pizza
The pizza was horrible mess. Greasy. Undercooked. I don’t understand why people think this is the best pizza in the area.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Just popped in for a dessert post-tacos. Ice cream looks great but we settled for a giant cookie and brownie. A great takeaway.
Took my family and friends and had the best service. They accommodated us so well on busy night. And the food was amazing.
We stopped by here because we were in the area. We ordered a pepperoni and margarita pizza and it was delicious! The garlic knots were a little dry, but edible. The booths were comfy to sit in and the staff were friendly.
You can't go wrong with anything on the menu. Pizza by the slice, fresh pies (the Eggplant Pie rocks), sandwiches (Meatball Parm is a standout), or salads. Everything is great. The only negative is its small size (fortunately there's a lot of outdoor seating in warmer weather) and their reduced hours since Covid. But the food and staff are great.
Restaurantji Recommends
Came here a few times for pizza and it's solid. Their sandwiches and salads are great. Good portions, a bit pricey but worth it
Tried pizza several of times with take out orders. Including at former places of employment where management would order a bunch of pizzas for it's workforce. Pepperoni and veggie pizza was my favorite and had the most flavors outside of the cheese pizza. Have not dined in at restaurant but have passed it numerous times coming in and out of Newburgh.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 3
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza, Garlic Knots
Pizza shop is my go too pizza place. Everyone in there is respectful and polite. The female manager knows all of her customers by name and it makes you feel good that when you walk in there you feel like family. There is a short bald gentleman that's always in there. I thought he was the owner until I found out he is only a manager at the taco location. He is rude and always screaming at the employees. The owners should see that he is definitely not an asset to their business. I will always go to pizza shop. They have my loyalty. Thank you pizza shop for the pleasant experience.
Excellent service & delicious pizza, every single time I visit Pizza Shop!! The manager Ashley is so sweet, professional & always a pleasure. I recommend Pizza Shop to everyone!!!
Nice view. Many pizza optionsThey messed up our order. Forgot about it and left it in the oven for too long tillIt was burnt. Two parties who ordered after us were served first and we checked twice with them before they finally realised that the pizzas were still at the back of the oven. There was still some foil stuck to the base of the pizza too