Youngest Brother Italian Restaurant

310 Robinson Ave, Newburgh
(845) 565-3110

Recent Reviews

GG

I like their pizza they got a 24in pizza cant complaim has good flavorParking: In front of establishment

Eunice D

The only reason I gave this place one star is because you can't say no star. As my friends and I were leaving, I noticed a bug on the wall. No big deal until I realized it was a cockroach. That did it for us. We shook out our jackets outside, checked ourselves, and will not be going back.

Diana Golan

After waiting for almost 2 HOURS for my order—- I received a BOILED chicken filet— not a breaded cutlet—swimming in soupy sauce. ABSOLUTELY UNACCEPTABLE! Tastes like GARBAGE!

Christopher Gosein

The pizza was nasty soon as I picked my slice up everything fell off and the bread broke all the toppings fell all over me mind u the slice wasn’t even hot. They took a old cheese slice and pilled toppings on it then put it back in the oven ? I was surprised b.c I sat at the bar before and ordered regular food & it was good

Darren G.

I came by to order a personal pizza, and an app, settled on a buffalo chicken personal pizza and fried ravioli. Got my food pretty fast since it was very slow there. I do enjoy that personal pan pizza was more a flatbread then a dough, which was nice. I was the pizza was more just plain cheese pizza with buffalo chicken diced on top. It was still good, just way more buffalo sauce then would like, chicken was very good though, tender and juicy. Fried ravioli was crispy and tender, and the sauce for dip was good, but the breading could be bit more seasoned. overall middle of the road for me.

Tony Kaufmann

Food was really good will eat here again for sure.

R Feliciano

Best Take-out Italian Restaurant in Orange County. Every single thing on the menu is delicious. Always fresh, flavorful, and reasonably priced. The staff are warm and friendly. Try the bruschetta, it’s incredible. I love this place!

Aaliyah Figueroa

HORRIBLE CUSTOMER SERVICE!!!!!!! They MADE my FETTUCCINE pasta with angle hair and did not inform me they also did not cut my chicken up they left the whole chicken breast in there .. the employees we giving me a attitude because THEY messed up my order also I said no broccoli in my pasta and they put broccoli and peas . And they are not trying to give me my money back . They told me they close at 11 I got there at 10 and they were closed … will never be ordering from there again .

Junior V.

I ordered the stuffed shells for takeout from this restaurant. It was very bland and below average. The platter looked good but tasted like something from a can of Chef Boyardee. The bread rolls that came with the meal were burnt and tasted like burnt toast.Looks can be deceiving as the photos I've posted show. Looking Good and tasting good are totally different. I was fooled. However if you're looking for Good Italian cuisine, skip this place and go elsewhere. If you want something that taste like beefaroni this place is for you.

Cheryl Morse

Has been years that we have stopped here. It's under new management. Food was good we enjoyed it with beer and wine. Chicken Parm and Chicken Youngest Brother. Rolls were very good too. Waitress Darlene was excellent.

Luisa Mejia Torriente

I ordered pasta carbonara and it was so fatty, I couldn’t Even eat it because it had so much oil, I guess from the bacon but it was so bad. I hope they can change this.

Will

The delivery guys have always been very professional and courteous. My first couple experiences were fine and the pizza is delicious, but upon taking out a slice of this pizza I just ordered, I saw a black hair that I pulled out. I totally understand that mistakes happen sometimes, but it was still unpleasant. The restaurant was kind enough to refund my order, so I would probably still recommend them to friends and family.

Jennifer K “Jenni” Matos

Exceptional service…the best steak for sure! My husband & I were pleasantly surprised! The quality, portion and price amazing! For $27 a sure steal… other places you would pay $40 at least! Had to do a repeat for lunch today… I woke up wanting it for breakfadt??

Jess Ortega

Best baked ziti I’ve ever had. Only $14 for a giant portion.

Michael Maneely

Dinner with mom at Youngest Brother Restaurant. Waitress was very pleasant. Food was awesome. Nice, fresh bread right from the oven. Salad was great (except the olives... I don't like olives). I couldn't decide what to get between the baked ziti, manicotti or stuffed shells so I let the waitress surprise me. The stuffed shells were absolutely DELICIOUS. Only complaint is I'm stuffed (which doesn't happen too often) Even though I'm stuffed... there's ALWAYS room for a delicious slice of tiramisu ??? DEFINITELY a place I will come back to

Load More

Youngest Brother Italian Restaurant

310 Robinson Ave, Newburgh, NY 12550
(845) 565-3110