The New Sullivans

501 Cayuga Dr, Niagara Falls
(716) 205-8288

Recent Reviews

Raymond Blum

Great service..fast good food...friendly staff...only 4 of 5... pricey.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 5

Kimberly Hickey

French fries were awful tasted like old grease hot dogs were over cooked so disappointed I loved going

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Nicolas Saldarriaga

My girlfriend and I came to try this place out since the reviews seemed pretty good and it was honestly a disappointment. We paid for a combo and got a tiny water cup size of coke which was pretty ridiculous for the price. Food was equivalent to that of a cafeteria at a private school. Better than public school lunch I guess

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 2

Service: 3

Julie K

The hot dog was fine but the wait to get it was absurd. It was lunchtime on Saturday and there were 2 couples ahead of me waiting. I recommend having a few dogs already on the grill at that time of day.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 4

Service: 2

Recommended dishes: Chili Cheese

Dawn Tierney

Food was delicious and priced fairly, service was great and very polite... cheesy bacon fries and a cheese burger ?

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Kim

Very disappointed, ordered Mexican Sundays, the dishes were so shallow that there was hardly any hot fudge on it and the Spanish peanuts tasted stale or something. They were definitely not regular Spanish peanuts. If they're going to use such a shallow dish they should at least put some of the fudge also on the ice cream instead of just at the bottom. Such it's not like the old Sullivan Sundays ???

Food: 1

Service: 4

Adam Taylor

Great little place.

Steve R

Old school grilled and sliced foot long. Fresh roll and mustard. NY knows...Parking: Right in front

Jackie Jackie

Quiet little hidden gem by the water... My favorite lunch spot whether in mood for food or ice cream

Paige Turners

Just went and got 2 hot dogs and Mac salad and potato salad!!! Best hot dogs around. Great service! Good salads! Better than Ted’s omg and so fairly priced!!! Definitely going there again!!! Awesome!!!

Lee F

good food,lemon ice (sorbet) is to die for.nice waterfront location with outdoor seating.

M M

I enjoyed a hotdog here and staff were friendly. Outdoor seating was simple yet it was covered from the blazing sun.

Phillip Hassell

They went above and beyond when they had no reason to. My wife needed to eat before taking her meds and we showed up 20 minutes before they opened. Staff there understood what we needed and as they could have sent us anywhere else for food that was open at the time, they did not. They took my order and promptly made it. My wife loved the delicious food she got and I could not be any happier with the service we received. I did not get any names or I would be praising them personally. However I'm sure they know whom they are. Thank you girls so much. We will be returning tomorrow night for dinner with the family. You have created life long customers out of us.

miranda cunningham

Great location but the food is less than mediocre. Buns were hard, cheese sauce for the fries was cold, and the chocolate milk was warm. Also, the prices on their site are incorrect, they have gone way up. My family will not go back.

Alexandria Hassell

So I must say ABOVE AND BEYOND!!!! I needed to take my meds and I have not been home in 7 yrs seen that they were open for the season and stopped . We were 20 min early to them opening and the staff took my order. Not saying that this should be habit but it was amazing that the staff was generous enoungh and severed me and gave me my taste of home and I took my meds and I was on my way . Thank you so very much to reminding me of why Sullivan's yall are so very important to our community not only your AMAZING FOOD BUT THE STAFF so I tip my hat to yall with the up most respect and politeness they have in a world full of anger . So thank you lady's yall truly made my day .

Load More