The Original Sepe’s Pizza

1801 Pine Ave, Niagara Falls
(716) 285-7373

Recent Reviews

Erich Carson

Hands down the best pizza in town. I must admit that I was getting very discouraged about ordering pizza because everyone makes it with the crust being too thick and then on top of that under cooked! If I wanted pizza bread that what I would have ordered!

Donald Dee

So far the pizza and subs the best I've had in a long time.. I'm going to go through his whole menu.. it's gotta all be GOOD... Just to bad they did mention concerns about the location.. If he moves I hope it's still kinda close because I'll follow..

Lana Learned

I've called 5 times to place a large order...during the time they are open. No answer. Very frustrating & not good for business.

Shaun Fadale

Love the half sheet/full sheet option. A little bit old school in a time when the neighborhood is trying to hold on to a tradition that will hopefully remain forever. Owner Chris shares the same Italian swagger which is nice for the out of towner looking for some homemade feel. Fried dough is awesome and fresh. Pizza is fresh, nice red succo, and good roni. Wish the Sepe's would've bought Grana's down the street and expanded out, need some more green white and red on Pine! Go buy a pie you'll enjoy it.

Jessica Owens

Delicious food and excellent customer service!I can eat here everyday. BBQ chicken fingers and pizza is my fav!

ImReap

Ordered 2 subs the steak and cheese was literally the worst one I've ever had I said mayo no oil the sub was literally drenched in oil to the point where the bread was soggy .Then the chicken finger sub was over cooked and also didn't have any mayo and the pizza I got was cold. Do not recommend this place at all

Jessica Paige

Pizza was awful- filled the belly but wasn't good. Wings were better but if you eat the wings, then the pizza, it's nasty

Kevin Michael

Pizza tastes amazing, wings are incredible, chicken fingers are godly. This place rocks, great grub. ?

Cliff Cameron

The pizza wasn't good at all. In the top 5 of the worst pizza places I had. No flavor.

Caroline

The pizza was delicious! We had a 1/2 tray of pepperoni and 1/2 tray of meatball. Also ordered hot Buffalo wings! Margie was so friendly and made us feel right at home. Great old school pizza place . Would definitely go back!

A. Matt Kilic

Great costumer service and generous extra free food

adam simpkins

We ordered on their website and they said doordash was responsible for the delivery. Our food sat there for 45 minutes. We ended up picking it up. The lady that works there was so rude. Now to the food. Pizza is not that good. Wings are so so. Taking a chance ordering from this place.

Don Won

The pizza was pretty good, but their Philly Steak and Cheese was amazing. Very friendly folks.

Nikkeya N.

I was so excited when I heard about the return of Sepe's. I have always liked the food here. I have so many old lady stories about getting some late night slices with friends. One day at work we decided to order out and agreed on Sepe's. One of the deciding factors was that they offer cauliflower crust pizza which was necessary for a few people who can't have gluten. We ordered rice bowls, lemon pepper chicken wings, medium chicken wings, a chicken Cesar salad, fried dough and a cauliflower pizza. I don't remember the cost but it was reasonable. This was our second time ordering and have to mention that the delivery guy parked his car, came into the hospital and delivered it right to the unit!! This was certainly not expected but greatly appreciated. He did the same exact thing last time. We were so appreciative. Most days we order food because we're all just too busy to run to the cafeteria before it closes. That extra step of bringing the food through the hospital to our unit was above and beyond. That was amazing!! As for the food, everyone enjoyed it. I LOVED my lemon pepper wings. The flavor was amazing and was so impressed with how crispy they were. The medium was more mild for me but I like things super hot. Everyone said they were definitely medium. I just enjoyed the crispness of them more than anything. The salad was good. Nice fresh lettuce and a nice portion of chicken. The rice bowls looked interesting. Everyone said they were very filling and full of flavor. I want to try one the next time we order. The friend dough was good too. You get such a huge amount it's overwhelming. But it was so so good. We'll definitely keep that menu on the top of our menu pile at work and next time I'll get some to bring home too!!

Mike Carlisto

Ordered a pizza and fingers. Pizza had hot sauce on it and tasted horrible the fingers were great. Never ordering a pizza from here again.

Load More