I came here because when i moved into the neighborhood they sent a coupon for a free pizza. We loved it! They also have a stamp card , after ordering 10 pizzas you get $5.00 off.
Brett Richner
Our families go to! We love the pizza , burgers and wings ! We are frequent fliers ! Delicious!Dietary restrictions: Love the gluten free pizza
We didn't realize restaurants here don't serve food after 10pm. Luckily, this place was still open and it more than exceeded our expectations. The 2 employees working were nice, informative, and friendly. We ordered the half size white pizza and an order of cheese curds. We were going to eat in, but they had just cleaned and we didn't want to risk them having to clean again. Eat in area is relatively small with 2 booths total, but at least there's an eat in option. Our order didn't take long. It was hot, delicious, and definitely filling. Half size is huge. Will definitely be back.Parking: Restaurant is located in a shopping center with plenty of available parking spots.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cheese Pizza
Corey G.
Great local pizzeria, with great prices and staff. The calzones are especially good to order.
Jon Mcmahon
Very good pizza. It’s thick yet fluffy, and not loaded with a half inch pile of cheese like most of those other gross pizza joints.To that point it’s one of the very best “buffalo” style pizzas. The ingredients are all great, except the pepperoni could be of better quality.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Eric Mullins
Free large cheese pizza.... online menu mentioned on the flyer is so outdated that prices are $10 higher than the in store menu. Underwhelming pizza and average wings at best.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 2
Service: 3
Recommended dishes: Chicken Wings
Zach Holycross
I love pizza shack, it's a very good Sicilian style pizza. The wings and subs are also great, and I enjoy the friendliness of the employees :)Parking: The restaurant is located right off the Niagara Falls Blvd.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza Slice, Taco Salad, Onion Rings, French Fries, Chicken Fingers, Stinger Fries, Sampler, The Hand Grenade Taco Calzone with Chicken Parmesan Sub with Fries, Fried Dough, Supreme Pizza, Beef Taco, Chicken Finger Taco, Boneless Wings, Pizza Fries, Chicken Wings, Cheese Sub, Personal Pepperoni Pizza
Marie Bellet-Jesky
Great pizza & wings! Thanks guys ?
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza Slice
George Nilson
Everything on the menu is great. Especially love the sweet sauce pizza and the chicken sub.
Just had a big order for Mother's Day , pizza ,subs ,calzone, chicken fingers and fries !!! There where 10 subs all of them with add on or substations and everyone of them where delicious and made exactly right !! We get pizza there all the time and it's the best !! First time we had a calzone, it was huge and so good and will definitely order that again !!! Thanks so much for your fast delivery!!
The sweet sauce is awesome! Prices were great too, and super friendly staff. Give them a try!
Aj B.
been looking the a god pizza and sun place since moving to this area about 6 months ago. I came upon the original pizza shack a few weeks ago! so far every single pizza order has been awesome and delicious! I had the super steak tonight and it was out of this world. definitely recommend the original pizza shack in NT! love it!!!
Kiera Beam
Always a wonderful experience! Best Pizza in North Tonawanda!
Trice Gipson
SUPERB SERVICE!!! We are from the islands, recently moved to W. Amherst, difficult to find a tasty pizza around here, The pizza shack caught our eyes in the plaza and will always be out go to from now on!! def worth the extra drive on every tues n Thurs as per hubby???
Kristie Werth
Had a busy day and ordered two tacos for a late dinner - they were awesome! Some of the best restaurant food I’ve had in a while. My husband and I were both really impressed. Will definitely be going back and trying some other things (and will def get a steak and chicken finger taco again!) Thanks, Pizza Shack!!
I came here because when i moved into the neighborhood they sent a coupon for a free pizza. We loved it! They also have a stamp card , after ordering 10 pizzas you get $5.00 off.
Our families go to! We love the pizza , burgers and wings ! We are frequent fliers ! Delicious!Dietary restrictions: Love the gluten free pizza
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza Slice, Boneless Wings
We didn't realize restaurants here don't serve food after 10pm. Luckily, this place was still open and it more than exceeded our expectations. The 2 employees working were nice, informative, and friendly. We ordered the half size white pizza and an order of cheese curds. We were going to eat in, but they had just cleaned and we didn't want to risk them having to clean again. Eat in area is relatively small with 2 booths total, but at least there's an eat in option. Our order didn't take long. It was hot, delicious, and definitely filling. Half size is huge. Will definitely be back.Parking: Restaurant is located in a shopping center with plenty of available parking spots.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cheese Pizza
Great local pizzeria, with great prices and staff. The calzones are especially good to order.
Very good pizza. It’s thick yet fluffy, and not loaded with a half inch pile of cheese like most of those other gross pizza joints.To that point it’s one of the very best “buffalo” style pizzas. The ingredients are all great, except the pepperoni could be of better quality.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Free large cheese pizza.... online menu mentioned on the flyer is so outdated that prices are $10 higher than the in store menu. Underwhelming pizza and average wings at best.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 2
Service: 3
Recommended dishes: Chicken Wings
I love pizza shack, it's a very good Sicilian style pizza. The wings and subs are also great, and I enjoy the friendliness of the employees :)Parking: The restaurant is located right off the Niagara Falls Blvd.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza Slice, Taco Salad, Onion Rings, French Fries, Chicken Fingers, Stinger Fries, Sampler, The Hand Grenade Taco Calzone with Chicken Parmesan Sub with Fries, Fried Dough, Supreme Pizza, Beef Taco, Chicken Finger Taco, Boneless Wings, Pizza Fries, Chicken Wings, Cheese Sub, Personal Pepperoni Pizza
Great pizza & wings! Thanks guys ?
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza Slice
Everything on the menu is great. Especially love the sweet sauce pizza and the chicken sub.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Chicken Fingers, Chicken Wings
Just had a big order for Mother's Day , pizza ,subs ,calzone, chicken fingers and fries !!! There where 10 subs all of them with add on or substations and everyone of them where delicious and made exactly right !! We get pizza there all the time and it's the best !! First time we had a calzone, it was huge and so good and will definitely order that again !!! Thanks so much for your fast delivery!!
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
The sweet sauce is awesome! Prices were great too, and super friendly staff. Give them a try!
been looking the a god pizza and sun place since moving to this area about 6 months ago. I came upon the original pizza shack a few weeks ago! so far every single pizza order has been awesome and delicious! I had the super steak tonight and it was out of this world. definitely recommend the original pizza shack in NT! love it!!!
Always a wonderful experience! Best Pizza in North Tonawanda!
SUPERB SERVICE!!! We are from the islands, recently moved to W. Amherst, difficult to find a tasty pizza around here, The pizza shack caught our eyes in the plaza and will always be out go to from now on!! def worth the extra drive on every tues n Thurs as per hubby???
Had a busy day and ordered two tacos for a late dinner - they were awesome! Some of the best restaurant food I’ve had in a while. My husband and I were both really impressed. Will definitely be going back and trying some other things (and will def get a steak and chicken finger taco again!) Thanks, Pizza Shack!!