Food is good but they are all in on shrinkflation, ordered takeout, the Sicilian pizza slices were a little bigger than a playing card. Spaghetti order in the takeout dish was what I consider a small portion. And the total bill was not cheap... I'll give it another chance but if the same I'll be movin on...
Mike Jovic
Terrible, terrible, terrible.I ordered ham and mushrooms pizza, pick-up. Came home and found ham is still uncooked. Call to ask why and the answer was, that's how we make it. If i wanted a raw ham i would order it on the side.Goodbye Charlie, you will not see my money again.Complete waste of money.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
mike power
Above average pizza and food. Friendly staff.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Bill Albert
Great Grandma pizza.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 5
Service: 5
Jay Beater
Just got a pie for my guys and we all agreed it was the best pizza
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Marisa L.
been here at least a dozen times and everything i've ordered has been so good--from reg pizza to the cauliflower crust and mozzarella sticks--takeout is always hot and done quick! great addition to OB.
Susan K
4.5 stars really. We really enjoyed our pizza. The regular and vodka were delicious. Grandma's crust is thin andhas a perfect xhew and crunch. Mmmm. Vegan pizza, dense w vegetables. Vegan cheese ok, could be better, but passable. A number of vegan/vegetarian options available. Would return and recommend to friends.Vegetarian options: A number of vegetarian/vegan options available clearly listed.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Margherita Pizza, Pizzetta
Gary Miller
Very good pizza! Had a mushroom and onion pie and it was awesome. Also on another occasion, had 2 regular slices and they were very good.
BMW8#1 !
No matter what pizza you get, it’s always dry, there’s barely any sauce & it’s black on the bottom like the oven needs to be cleaned. The pizza’s so dry you can choke on it & it’s so black you can taste the char! Same thing w the pasta dishes, there’s a spot of sauce so you choke on pasta!I also had a grilled chicken w avocado hero & 1 thought it was ok to put a piece of raw garlic on it!If it wasn’t for the customer service, I would give 1 star bc it’s been 3 yrs of awful pizza, etc
Food: 1
Service: 3
Jennifer L
I don’t live in the area but whenever I visit, this is a really solid pizza spot. Long Island is certainly full of great options but I found it to be very consistently good and the guys that work there are so nice. This will always be my go-to whenever I’m in town. I love a good grandma slice and you can’t find it like this anywhere else. I wish I could post a picture, but I never remember to take it before I inhale it lol.
Placed a large order for the office and they forgot to put some food in the bag. I ordered a shrimp francese and they put a side of paste and it came with red sauce. I did assume if would be in the same plate with the same sauce. The worker told me he never assumes and was a little rude. They also didn't put a fork and he said we didn't ask I guess I should not have assume also. This place is close by but next time I rather go further. Not going back.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 1
andrea cornachio
Umberto's is our go to a never disappoints! Everything is made from quality ingredients and has a home cooked, authentic taste. My fav is the cauliflower margarita pizza:) Such a lovely addition to Oyster Bay.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Charlene ward
1st time I ordered spaghetti and meatballs which was horrible no sauce meatballs were dying for sauce. Ok 2nd time I tried a grandma pazzo slice was supposed to have sausage black olives & red pepper. Burt little dabs of burnt cheese no sausage no black olives and burnt on the back. It’s a shame because I was the first person to buy slices of pizza at Ninos when he and his brother Tony opened up. Many many years ago. Ninos food was the best. Every slice brought tonight is burnt. Turn your oven down or something I’m 70 yrs old come on this is horrible the chicken slices on the grill chicken hero is dry and burnt. Very disappointed
Jennifer Roper
Nice to see that Ninos was replaced with another pizzeria. However, the flavor on the regular slice and sausage roll was underwhelming. I tried them on a previous occasion and our entire pie was burnt. It was inedible.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 1
Service: 5
Dave M.
I'd only has slices there, they were good, but no Ninos. Then I got chicken piccata the other night and it was great! Just a little pricey...
Food is good but they are all in on shrinkflation, ordered takeout, the Sicilian pizza slices were a little bigger than a playing card. Spaghetti order in the takeout dish was what I consider a small portion. And the total bill was not cheap... I'll give it another chance but if the same I'll be movin on...
Terrible, terrible, terrible.I ordered ham and mushrooms pizza, pick-up. Came home and found ham is still uncooked. Call to ask why and the answer was, that's how we make it. If i wanted a raw ham i would order it on the side.Goodbye Charlie, you will not see my money again.Complete waste of money.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Above average pizza and food. Friendly staff.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Great Grandma pizza.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 5
Service: 5
Just got a pie for my guys and we all agreed it was the best pizza
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
been here at least a dozen times and everything i've ordered has been so good--from reg pizza to the cauliflower crust and mozzarella sticks--takeout is always hot and done quick! great addition to OB.
4.5 stars really. We really enjoyed our pizza. The regular and vodka were delicious. Grandma's crust is thin andhas a perfect xhew and crunch. Mmmm. Vegan pizza, dense w vegetables. Vegan cheese ok, could be better, but passable. A number of vegan/vegetarian options available. Would return and recommend to friends.Vegetarian options: A number of vegetarian/vegan options available clearly listed.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Margherita Pizza, Pizzetta
Very good pizza! Had a mushroom and onion pie and it was awesome. Also on another occasion, had 2 regular slices and they were very good.
No matter what pizza you get, it’s always dry, there’s barely any sauce & it’s black on the bottom like the oven needs to be cleaned. The pizza’s so dry you can choke on it & it’s so black you can taste the char! Same thing w the pasta dishes, there’s a spot of sauce so you choke on pasta!I also had a grilled chicken w avocado hero & 1 thought it was ok to put a piece of raw garlic on it!If it wasn’t for the customer service, I would give 1 star bc it’s been 3 yrs of awful pizza, etc
Food: 1
Service: 3
I don’t live in the area but whenever I visit, this is a really solid pizza spot. Long Island is certainly full of great options but I found it to be very consistently good and the guys that work there are so nice. This will always be my go-to whenever I’m in town. I love a good grandma slice and you can’t find it like this anywhere else. I wish I could post a picture, but I never remember to take it before I inhale it lol.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
Placed a large order for the office and they forgot to put some food in the bag. I ordered a shrimp francese and they put a side of paste and it came with red sauce. I did assume if would be in the same plate with the same sauce. The worker told me he never assumes and was a little rude. They also didn't put a fork and he said we didn't ask I guess I should not have assume also. This place is close by but next time I rather go further. Not going back.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 1
Umberto's is our go to a never disappoints! Everything is made from quality ingredients and has a home cooked, authentic taste. My fav is the cauliflower margarita pizza:) Such a lovely addition to Oyster Bay.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
1st time I ordered spaghetti and meatballs which was horrible no sauce meatballs were dying for sauce. Ok 2nd time I tried a grandma pazzo slice was supposed to have sausage black olives & red pepper. Burt little dabs of burnt cheese no sausage no black olives and burnt on the back. It’s a shame because I was the first person to buy slices of pizza at Ninos when he and his brother Tony opened up. Many many years ago. Ninos food was the best. Every slice brought tonight is burnt. Turn your oven down or something I’m 70 yrs old come on this is horrible the chicken slices on the grill chicken hero is dry and burnt. Very disappointed
Nice to see that Ninos was replaced with another pizzeria. However, the flavor on the regular slice and sausage roll was underwhelming. I tried them on a previous occasion and our entire pie was burnt. It was inedible.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 1
Service: 5
I'd only has slices there, they were good, but no Ninos. Then I got chicken piccata the other night and it was great! Just a little pricey...