Always a great time at the Casino Cafe!! Amazing views and fun atmosphere!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: California Chicken Club Wrap
Ryan Mancuso
We saw the Warped Tour Band here and it was awesome! Everyone was having a great time. You didn't have to wait for a drink, there were always a bartender at the service windows or inside bar. We will be back.
Atmosphere: 5
Service: 5
Regina Urzo
Don't leave your credit card there!! They will rob you blind!!
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 1
Service: 1
Phil Spampinato
Great Place outstanding views and friendly staff. We had fabulous meal with our favorite people Melanie and Steve.Thanks as always.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Nancy Schatz
BEST PLACE EVER - delicious food - beautiful setting - best servers ❤️❤️
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Sea Scallops, California Chicken Club Wrap, Teriyaki Steak, Brussels Sprouts Hash, Homemade Chips, Caprese Sandwich, Beach Burger, Fries or Onion Rings, Sriracha Shrimp Tacos, Buffalo Wings
markpG3673CU
Kristin Downs and her staff do an amazing job! The service and the atmosphere they create is par to none. The menu is outstanding with an excellent selection of all things from the sea, and great specials. If you’re spending time at Davis Park please visit them and experience a truly great dining experience. -Chef Mark Preston
N S
Just when I thought it couldn't get any better, it did! By far the best menu and best food I have had in my 16 years coming here. The staff goes above and beyond to make your dining experience memorable. Mariano is an amazing chef!! I did not hear one bad word about the food or service in my time here.Looking forward to next season already!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Eileen Saccoccio
Service was great food was incredible. Beautiful views
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Emily K
I went with my family to dinner here last night. I got the Bone-In New York Strip Steak, it was delicious!! I would highly recommend this place for dinner and drinks!! The service was great!
Colin P
We'd planned to eat somewhere on Long Island but our plans fell through so on the spur of the moment we took the ferry from Patchogue to Davis Park and 'walked in' to the Casino Cafe restaurant. We were greeted warmly and given a great window seat, our server arriving a few seconds after we sat down. (Sorry I can't remember his name but he deserves a mention nevertheless. The menu is a little expensive but with everything having to be 'boated in' I can live with that and the choice of food was great - very hard to choose. I settled for the Long Island duck in peach and port (from the specials menu) with side of candied brussel sprouts (not everyone's favourite I know!) and what a joy it was. I think it rated as the best duck I've ever tasted and perfectly cooked (I've asked for the recipe because I can't wait to taste it again). There were no complaints from my three dining companions either and we left very content .....and full! The weather was perfect and the views are great but allow yourselves some time between ferries as this isn't an experience to be rushed. I have a new favourite restaurant - it's just a shame I live 3,500 miles away and it'll be 18 months before we can return. Here's hoping it doesn't change in that time.
We've just spent a week on Fire Island in Davis Park and this restaurant is the only game in town. It was busy and the food was "fine" but for the prices the food should be really good. We can recommend the seafood apps - -oysters raw and shrimp cocktail, the but salads and desserts were just ok. We did not have entrees as the prices were sky high. The view of the ocean is amazing and the very busy staff did try hard.
Val Bedard
The view ? O.K food (fast food type) and yummy drinks. But on the expensive side... like everything else on Fire Island ;)25 minutes walk from Watch Hill camping
Tatyana Fox
This place was great,food was amazing! Service was very good, can't wait to come back !!
Joseph Nohs
Nice place a little more laid back then some of the other fire island spots.
Leah Dalton
Food could better for the price but it’s the only restaurant in town. Bring cash! Restaurant only accepts tips in cash. Bar has very high minimum card amounts.
Always a great time at the Casino Cafe!! Amazing views and fun atmosphere!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: California Chicken Club Wrap
We saw the Warped Tour Band here and it was awesome! Everyone was having a great time. You didn't have to wait for a drink, there were always a bartender at the service windows or inside bar. We will be back.
Atmosphere: 5
Service: 5
Don't leave your credit card there!! They will rob you blind!!
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 1
Service: 1
Great Place outstanding views and friendly staff. We had fabulous meal with our favorite people Melanie and Steve.Thanks as always.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
BEST PLACE EVER - delicious food - beautiful setting - best servers ❤️❤️
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Sea Scallops, California Chicken Club Wrap, Teriyaki Steak, Brussels Sprouts Hash, Homemade Chips, Caprese Sandwich, Beach Burger, Fries or Onion Rings, Sriracha Shrimp Tacos, Buffalo Wings
Kristin Downs and her staff do an amazing job! The service and the atmosphere they create is par to none. The menu is outstanding with an excellent selection of all things from the sea, and great specials. If you’re spending time at Davis Park please visit them and experience a truly great dining experience. -Chef Mark Preston
Just when I thought it couldn't get any better, it did! By far the best menu and best food I have had in my 16 years coming here. The staff goes above and beyond to make your dining experience memorable. Mariano is an amazing chef!! I did not hear one bad word about the food or service in my time here.Looking forward to next season already!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Service was great food was incredible. Beautiful views
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I went with my family to dinner here last night. I got the Bone-In New York Strip Steak, it was delicious!! I would highly recommend this place for dinner and drinks!! The service was great!
We'd planned to eat somewhere on Long Island but our plans fell through so on the spur of the moment we took the ferry from Patchogue to Davis Park and 'walked in' to the Casino Cafe restaurant. We were greeted warmly and given a great window seat, our server arriving a few seconds after we sat down. (Sorry I can't remember his name but he deserves a mention nevertheless. The menu is a little expensive but with everything having to be 'boated in' I can live with that and the choice of food was great - very hard to choose. I settled for the Long Island duck in peach and port (from the specials menu) with side of candied brussel sprouts (not everyone's favourite I know!) and what a joy it was. I think it rated as the best duck I've ever tasted and perfectly cooked (I've asked for the recipe because I can't wait to taste it again). There were no complaints from my three dining companions either and we left very content .....and full! The weather was perfect and the views are great but allow yourselves some time between ferries as this isn't an experience to be rushed. I have a new favourite restaurant - it's just a shame I live 3,500 miles away and it'll be 18 months before we can return. Here's hoping it doesn't change in that time.
Restaurantji Recommends
We've just spent a week on Fire Island in Davis Park and this restaurant is the only game in town. It was busy and the food was "fine" but for the prices the food should be really good. We can recommend the seafood apps - -oysters raw and shrimp cocktail, the but salads and desserts were just ok. We did not have entrees as the prices were sky high. The view of the ocean is amazing and the very busy staff did try hard.
The view ? O.K food (fast food type) and yummy drinks. But on the expensive side... like everything else on Fire Island ;)25 minutes walk from Watch Hill camping
This place was great,food was amazing! Service was very good, can't wait to come back !!
Nice place a little more laid back then some of the other fire island spots.
Food could better for the price but it’s the only restaurant in town. Bring cash! Restaurant only accepts tips in cash. Bar has very high minimum card amounts.