This is the best place in Pawling. The service is excellent. The catering is amazing. Sandwiches are delicious. Prices are reasonable. What a gem!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Julie LeBeau
Steak margarita sandwich was a big hit! So were the chicken Parm and swedish meatballs. Definitely ordering from Vinny's for future parties.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Cristy Bnett
Foods amazing! Great prices, really nice staff! Highly recommend. Won’t be disappointed
Jonathan Moorehead
Great hometown place in Pawling. Homemade sauce!
Jason B.
Amazing all over! Vinny is the quintessential Italian deli owner. He serves his customers always with a smile, making everyone who comes in feel like they are visiting his home. His staff is equally amazing, they dote on the customers as if they also family, Kiersten and Courtney really serve it up! Do not pass this one up, start with the steak margherita and work your way through the menu, you will NOT be disappointed.
David Bertola
I was told that I had to go to Vinny’s and get their famous sandwich “The Steak Margarita” and let me tell you I know why it’s famous!! The owner and staff were super friendly and engaged me as soon as I walked in! Places like this with people and food like this are very rare nowadays! A true gem!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Laurie I.
Hands down best catering deli to date.. we have ordered numerous times and never disappoint... always on point!! The deli sandwiches are GREAT... just delicious!! This is one hard working crew and the proof is in the food!! Just go... trust you'll go back again and again!! Laurie
Kristoffer Jorstad
Their hot sandwiches are blowing my mind. The son in law on a wedge is incredible. Awesome old school Italian deli. The staff is super friendly. The vibe is authentic. The products are niche and high quality. They don’t insist that you tip (though you will want to) and the prices are super affordable. New lunch spot for
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Gloria Graff
Such an amazing spot. Great people who work here, recognized my mom who brought me and knew I was a first time guest. Got the Steak Margarita sandwich and some take home items. The sandwich barely made it to the car before we were digging in. I cant wait to make the take home stuff, its sure to be phenomenal.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Frank B.
First time trying this deli today. It was excellent! I had the steak margarita which was phenomenal. Service was great. I definitely will be going back to try the other sandwiches they have. They also have other fine Italian delicacies which I brought home for later. A true NYC deli but don't have to drive into Manhattan to get great food.
Best sandwiches in NY! Vinny does an amazing job with bringing Italy to Pawling. It’s an awesome little grocery.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Salami, Variety of Salads and Desserts, Baguette
Frankie Lombardo
Love this place, great quality food and super friendly worker'
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Zach K.
I live on Arthur Ave. little Italy. In the Bronx. Best Italian food in the country. This Vinny's sandwich was the best Italian sandwich I've EVER had.
The Oven P.
10 stars possible? I've been here a couple times now, and for some reason haven't had their "famous sandwich." Man if I could go back to those first few times and reorder the Steak Margarita, I absolutely would. It's outrageous. Not too much meat, the perfect amount in fact. No leakage which means a lot to me. The fresh mozz is just perfect Famous for a reason, try it, you'll love it...Cute little italian place, homey smell in there. Staff is awesome. The woman behind the counter met me try the Ghost Pepper Cheddar Cheese, sheeeesh hot af but great taste and short linger. Great olives to choose from. Will be back for more, and my 2XL "Legalize Marinara" tee!Check out The Oven Podcast on YouTube and keep up to date with where we feed ourselves IG @theoven_pod
Derek Miller
great food authentic italian deli. would make Tony Soprano proud
This is the best place in Pawling. The service is excellent. The catering is amazing. Sandwiches are delicious. Prices are reasonable. What a gem!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Steak margarita sandwich was a big hit! So were the chicken Parm and swedish meatballs. Definitely ordering from Vinny's for future parties.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Foods amazing! Great prices, really nice staff! Highly recommend. Won’t be disappointed
Great hometown place in Pawling. Homemade sauce!
Amazing all over! Vinny is the quintessential Italian deli owner. He serves his customers always with a smile, making everyone who comes in feel like they are visiting his home. His staff is equally amazing, they dote on the customers as if they also family, Kiersten and Courtney really serve it up! Do not pass this one up, start with the steak margherita and work your way through the menu, you will NOT be disappointed.
I was told that I had to go to Vinny’s and get their famous sandwich “The Steak Margarita” and let me tell you I know why it’s famous!! The owner and staff were super friendly and engaged me as soon as I walked in! Places like this with people and food like this are very rare nowadays! A true gem!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Hands down best catering deli to date.. we have ordered numerous times and never disappoint... always on point!! The deli sandwiches are GREAT... just delicious!! This is one hard working crew and the proof is in the food!! Just go... trust you'll go back again and again!! Laurie
Their hot sandwiches are blowing my mind. The son in law on a wedge is incredible. Awesome old school Italian deli. The staff is super friendly. The vibe is authentic. The products are niche and high quality. They don’t insist that you tip (though you will want to) and the prices are super affordable. New lunch spot for
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Such an amazing spot. Great people who work here, recognized my mom who brought me and knew I was a first time guest. Got the Steak Margarita sandwich and some take home items. The sandwich barely made it to the car before we were digging in. I cant wait to make the take home stuff, its sure to be phenomenal.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
First time trying this deli today. It was excellent! I had the steak margarita which was phenomenal. Service was great. I definitely will be going back to try the other sandwiches they have. They also have other fine Italian delicacies which I brought home for later. A true NYC deli but don't have to drive into Manhattan to get great food.
Restaurantji Recommends
Best sandwiches in NY! Vinny does an amazing job with bringing Italy to Pawling. It’s an awesome little grocery.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Salami, Variety of Salads and Desserts, Baguette
Love this place, great quality food and super friendly worker'
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I live on Arthur Ave. little Italy. In the Bronx. Best Italian food in the country. This Vinny's sandwich was the best Italian sandwich I've EVER had.
10 stars possible? I've been here a couple times now, and for some reason haven't had their "famous sandwich." Man if I could go back to those first few times and reorder the Steak Margarita, I absolutely would. It's outrageous. Not too much meat, the perfect amount in fact. No leakage which means a lot to me. The fresh mozz is just perfect Famous for a reason, try it, you'll love it...Cute little italian place, homey smell in there. Staff is awesome. The woman behind the counter met me try the Ghost Pepper Cheddar Cheese, sheeeesh hot af but great taste and short linger. Great olives to choose from. Will be back for more, and my 2XL "Legalize Marinara" tee!Check out The Oven Podcast on YouTube and keep up to date with where we feed ourselves IG @theoven_pod
great food authentic italian deli. would make Tony Soprano proud