Prime 16

156 Fifth Ave, Village of Pelham
(914) 576-0700

Recent Reviews

Alex Findlay

Our go to place in lower Westchester for our burger fix. Always tasty no matter what we get, and quick!

Amy A

Great burgers and variety of craft beers. Brioche buns are delicious. Sports Bar meets English Pub vive. Never unpleasantly loud even when they are packed.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Amanda G.

We've ordered from here a few times. I love the fact that it's a family-run business. We've had some issues with our orders, once or twice, but nothing so major that we did not want to come back. I would suggest that if you do order food for pick-up, make sure you check everything. The kitchen seems to get overwhelmed when there are lots of pick-up orders and people dining in. Both times we've stopped by, they place wasn't terribly packed but whe we waited for our food there were plenty of people coming in to pick up orders. Their burgers are good and customizable, which my son loves. He sometimes over does it; simplicity can be a good thing, I've learned. I always love a tater tot side and like that they have them as an option. The menu online was not up to date so when we got there to order, we were told that they don't have the same patty options as is shown on the website. We pivoted and made the best of it. By far, my fave are the goat cheese croquettes...fried cheesy goodness. We'll definitely be back, double-check our orders and enjoy the food. It's good.

Jess L.

I've had mixed experiences at this location for delivery. During my latest experience, I was pretty disappointed by the number of cauliflower in the Buffalo cauliflower bites - about 5 pieces for $8. Also, the bun of my Post Modern was soggy with very scattered ingredients. It was messy and not appealing. Another time, though, my chicken sandwich was pretty solid. The flavoring of most of my dishes has been a little under or a little over what I'd want.

David Parker

Amazing burgers! Great beer menu! Super friendly staff. My family had an awesome dinner!!!

mario barragan

cool place with friendly staff.the burgers are amazing.solid beer selection.

Grant S.

Best quality food we've found since moving up. Often need to reheat slightly because it is so good we don't want to eat it cold.

Troie O.

The food here is amazing. Seriously one of the best food spots in Pelham! Anything off the menu is sure to be a 10/10.

Chris DeGrazio

A place near and dear to my own heart, I've been coming here since they first opened the Pelham location. The beer selection is phenomenal, with great classics and some you've never even heard of. The burgers are great, you can customize one from the ground up or pick from the list of designed burgers. I personally always order the designed as there was clearly a lot of thought that went into them and they are delicious. On top of all that, the atmosphere is very chill, the service is great and there are even vegetarian options available at a burger joint. Great restaurant.

Jamey Cappello

Dine-in AND take-out is always consistently awesome. Great burgers cooked how you like and great people. Appetizers, such as pretzels and wings, great too.

James C.

In-person dining AND takeout always great quality and tasty! Takeout is tough no matter where and they somehow get it right every time with burgers cooked how you like and hot food that is consistently delicious!

Terry Spina

Love the burgers here and the apps. Our server was awesome as well. Great local spot!

Jacqulin B

First of all what restaurant stays open for 5 hours a day just close down for good waste of time

Karen Miller Hudson

Beautiful dinner last night and so delicious! We had a party of 12 and they accommodated us beautifully! Our waitress was very sweet and very attentive. The food was excellent and there was not one of us that were not pleased. This is a great place and we will be returning for sure. We did meet the owner and he was very very nice. We will be returning soon.

Anne J.

The food was amazing!!!! They may need to do delivery and take out so support them! Not from here and always trust Yelp- it is so good! Had the burger- Kahuna burger and the famous fried chicken sandwich- cute outdoor space- it looks way under stated so dont judge if you just drive by- AWESOME food and owner is fantastic!!!!!

Load More