Restaurants in Penn Yan

“This is a MUST stop along your brewery trail. AJ has figured out something special about brewing. Not another place in FLX where every tap is something I would order again. Can’t wait to go back!”

“We went on Sunday afternoon for a Son Henry show and liked this place. The people who work there are great, the venue is an old restored barn that's still shabby enough to respect its roots, the music was very good. Great relaxed vibe among the crowd. Nice view of Keuka Lake. Our party enjoyed the house beer and cider offerings a lot. Food menu is limited but okay, except that there are zero veggies or gluten free options, hence the four instead of five stars.”

“Visiting from Texas…this was a wonderful, quaint cafe down the road from our stay! Enjoyed our meal and the market!”

“There is only one pizza place on this corner. It is Cam’s New York Pizzeria… just FYI as Google currently has it on their map as 2 different places.The pizza was EXCELLENT! I had the 2 pepperoni slice lunch special.I am new in town, and the staff were very friendly and helpful.I’ll definitely be back!!”

“Food was amazing and prices are great. My wife and I stumbled upon this place while in Penn Yan. We. Love an hour away and would gladly make the drive to go here for dinner again.”

“This was the friendliest place we have come across in the region. The bartender, the sister and daughter of the two brewers, was knowledgeable about all the brews. Our two pups were more than welcome. The food was an excellent treat. I can't speak highly enough of the pepper bacon jam. The beer spanned a nice range and had an excellent taste. Our party of 4 sampled each pour and none disappointed.”

“Lots of seating, fast service and good food”

“Best flat bread I have ever had! Loved it Rose! The wait staff was friendly and efficient also. Will definitely be back and recommend to all my friends.”

“The server was nice but could not operate the wood burner appropriately, so the place was filled with smoke. The beer was delicious, though. We did a flight. The only terrible one was the gluten-free option. The Amber was a super well-balanced, perfect mid-strength beer. We scored a growler of that to take back to our little lakeside cabin. 1 extra star for them trying their best to fix the smokiness.”

“Great smoke ribs brisket and beans are a gas made trip down from Syracuse worth the haul”

“Had the fish fry last night. Best fish fry in the area. More than I could finish. Had the rest for lunch. Will be back for more.”

“This vineyard is really special. It is truly family-run and operated, and the family is lovely, hospitality is clearly in their DNA. We took a tour, which was led by the owner, started with glasses of sparkling wine, and included him pouring us a glass directly out of the barrel - see picture for evidence! :) We had a charcuterie board with our wine tasting which was amazing, as were the wines! The views are beautiful, it’s right on the lake. The indoor space is also cozy and thoughtfully designed. You would be missing out not to stop by this vineyard while you’re in Finger Lakes.”

“Cute little local restaurant that supports our veterans.. felt like a home cooked meal! Please come check it out!”

“Great meal! Cozy atmosphere!”

“Finally made it to Valhalla and we loved the wings and onion rings. Our group tried 4 varieties; mild, hot, BBQ and garlic parm. Each style was crispy and very delicious and we were attended to by a very nice server. Can't wait to go back and try the rest of the menu.”

“I go to Blue Heron about twice a week. My family loves the olive ciabatta bread, the warm, soft pretzels and especially the almond croissants - unbelievably delicious with just the right sweetness. Today I brought home a chocolate babka for the first time....heavenly. Best bakery anywhere!”

“Wow! Quite amazing! Cortadoliscious. Here for the eclipse and the baristas are slammed. Maintaining their composure and made me the the best cortado I can remember having.”

“In the area for the weekend and saw Spotted Duck on Google maps so we decided to stop. We did the 4 flavor flight and every flavor was absolutely amazing!! We wanted to lick the little flight jars!! You can’t go wrong with anything you choose here!!”

“Fabulously rich Hershey’s ice cream. All the standard flavors plus wild concoctions like Banana Peanut Butter Moose tracks which is as yellow as you would hope it to be. Of course they have soft serve, sundaes and all the toppings and dips.”

“Beautiful large home perfect for quilting and sleeping. Gorgeous view of the lake.”

“The food is amazing. Ultra thin chicken and sausage pizza is excellent. The lasagna is generous and has spinach in the layers which is a great addition. The lemon mascarpone cake was light and flavorful. The tiramisu was perfect. The staff is friendly and attentive.”

“Good home style fried chicken and ice cream”

“We dined at the 18th last night, me for the first time, and enjoyed a perfect assortment of delicious foods (and the best Cosmo I’ve ever had). The waitress was super friendly but also very professional and capable. We highly recommend this golden nugget found in the heart of the Finger Lakes.”

“I sang the whole night Friday night for basically an audition but I was having so much fun everybody was pleased and I don't cost as much as a full band, those days are behind me, this place treated me awesome, and I definitely want to play there again, only this time I'm going to have to try some of the food because everybody says it's awesome, I I saw somebody's Pizza and it made me gain five pounds just by looking at it but anyway I want to perform at the tavern I can bring you business on top of the business you already have so much fun honestly I didn't even take a break and I usually take at least one break two breaks sometimes when you're in your element you just don't want to leave them with minimal you want to leave them with all you have and then some”

“Great Bills backer Bar! Looked them up for the Bills game in London. Camping at the Keuka Lake State park.”

“Fabulous food & coffee & great atmosphere”

“Tried to order for delivery like we do every Friday night. Tonight we called 89 times with a busy signal every time. Really good food if someone would answer phone.”

“Recently went on a overnight stay at Seneca lake with my boyfriend and we stopped here on our way to the camp site. It was a Wednesday so we were the only ones in there but this place was very cool. The live bees and I love a good mason jar flight. The wine slushes were good. Would recommend if driving by.”

“Great Cider and delicious donuts.”

“Dry Rose 2022 was (is) a great wine for sharing over a friendly brunch with friends. No matter how particular and fussy some people are about what they consider to be "good" wine or proper pairings (not that they are all that expert!), everyone enjoyed and filled their glass for a second time (and a couple for a third!). Good thing I had bottles in reserve! A very friendly and enjoyable wine that complemented without competing with brunch. A good choice.”

“best wings in town. great service”

“My wife and I order Chinese every so often. China King is the best around in my opinion. We've never been disappointed. Sesame Chicken, cheese wontons(crab ragoon), egg rolls...yummy.”

“I took my daughter out to dinner tonight at the Keuka Restaurant, we had DAWN as our server and she was fantastic! Very sweet and attentive, she took great care of us. We love going to the Keuka for dinner, the pulled pork nachos are to die for and the food is consistently great quality with enormous portions! Highly recommend!”

“I've had nothing but good experiences with Mark's. Even when mistakes have been made with my order, the staff always goes above and beyond to correct them. Everyone is always friendly. Great customer service!”

“Great lunch and staff. Will be back.”

“Great place. Been back a few times. Good food. Atmosphere and the Penn yan boat history is great!! Be there or be square. We drive from Geneva!”