Pomodoro Pizza Cafe

3 Maggiacomo Ln, Pleasant Valley
(845) 723-4008

Recent Reviews

Taylor Scott

There was a hair in my food when i returned the worker was very disrespectful and barely offered any solution for me and could hardly process a refund for me extremely disrespectful i would not recommend.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Lars Hollsnd

Do not go to this place there was a hair in my food and the person that helped me was extremely disrespectful to us and barely even wanted to give us a refund. Super disrespectful and would not recommend

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

janet bacon

I stopped by to try a regular slice of pizza for take out. I was exceptionally pleased and will return for a large pie and more. Eccellente!

Food: 5

xavier ortega

Great places to take the family !! Great service and great food !

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Joesette T

Went for pizza. Table service was great. Restaurant is very very clean and atmosphere is nice as well. Young girl, who is our waitress, was extremely personable and attentive. We decided to give this place a try for our pizza because our favorite place has gone downhill considerably. Not disappointed at all will definitely be back. The pizza was very tasty and Hardy. I would just mention that if you like a firm crust, ask them to cook it a little longer. Otherwise perfect. New owner is very nice.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

shannon faye

my new fav pizza spot in PV! super friendly people, consistently amazing pizza (i get their regular cheese slices) and they are the best around! my co workers and i order from them quite often! 100% recommend!

Food: 5

Service: 5

J Gold

Great place to eat. LOVE the salads and it's rare that I say that. I would highly recommend Pomodoro

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Steven M. Franzken

The pizza is truly unique with an original sauce and quality cheeses.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Mitchell West

Pizza was not bad... but the Chicken Parm wrap was awful... just a small portion of chicken with very little cheese and a splash or sauce... when my wife has something negative to say about a sandwich it is time to give a review... she never has anything bad to say anywhere we eat...

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 2

Service: 4

valerie hovasapian

Excellent pizza (my husband enjoyed it, I try and limit my pizza intake), also have had the chicken parm (again excellent), and my favorite thing is their Stracciatella soup (they call it "Italian Soup" on their menu) - it's delicious and healthy with tons of spinach! The people are very nice as well (I did take out, but the atmosphere looked nice, it's a spacious place and bigger than most pizzerias.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Veggie Primavera Pasta, The Italiana

Arianna Milanese

Ordered for the first time here last weekend and their pastas are amazing!!!! We had three different pastas because we couldn’t decide. Tonight we picked up pizza and the pizza is great. My kids are picky with BBQ chicken on their pizza and all of them ate their food. Service both times were very quick. Thanks guys! Will be back!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Pasta Carbonara, Calamari Fra Diavolo Pasta

John W.

Pizza is always decent, so are the sandwiches and rolls. Last night ordered cheesecake, came to me freezer burnt and frozen. Pretty dissatisfied especially for a super thin slice of cheesecake that cost me over $6 a slice. Idk POMO, I might find a different spot for my pizza and desserts Why would you even charge that much for that thin of a slice and why would you send me FROZEN, FREEZERBURNT cake. Bad business!

Lisa R.

We have been ordering from them since they opened and have been enjoying the pizza! But last two times the pizza was not good! Delivered through slice and at $28 for an extra cheese large pizza was a LOT if pizza was slamming but that has not been the case! Last night pizza was on time actually earlier than expected but pizza was cold, over cooked and not extra cheese! It was so over cooked that you couldn't eat the pizza three inches from the crust! Bottom was tough and over done too! The pizza before that was ok but i paid for extra cheese sausage.. no extra cheese and lucky to find 2 slices of sausage on a piece. Don't know what has happened to Pomodoros but something has to change back!

Erin Elizabeth

We ordered a pizza to go tonight, I don't know how the kitchen staff weren't mortified to serve the sad excuse for "pizza" we got. Undercooked, WET, skimpy on cheese. The pizza literally flopped over when my partner went to take a bite, and all the toppings just slid off. It was so wet and floppy that, even with him holding the end up, it still slid through his fingers onto the plate. I put mine in the oven, where all the wet toppings slid off, and it still wasn't cooked enough. It's taking all of my strength not to get in my car with the pizza (that we each ate less than one slice of) and return it and demand a refund. Now it's Friday night, we've spent our take out budget on this SLOP, and we're still hungry. Disgusting, don't waste your money.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 1

Service: 3

Emilee Davis

Ordered a chicken Alfredo pasta. First bite of the chicken had a bone. Sauce was a little bland. Bread was very good though. Service and atmosphere was on point.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 2

Service: 5

Load More