2.8 rating? Yikes... Guess this what happens when you name your restaurant in the middle of Queens after our arch nemesis borough? Brooklyn Wild Catch and it smell funny in here, just like Sunset Park Brooklyn so I guess the name makes sense lol
GARY TUNSTALL
Shrimp and grits were meh. Smelled like weed was smoking in there. Won't be back.
Robby Singh
Missing items
Brenda’s Daughter Catering
I placed an order on DoorDash my order was confirmed. I saw where they were preparing my order and the dasher was headed to the store. The next thing I know my order is canceled. I called doordash and they said the dasher got to the store and it was closed. I said closed it said 24hrs and I got a confirmed order email and it showed they were working on it. The absolute worst I tried to support.
Shamorra B.
Brooklyn wild catch what the hell is this??? I took a chance despite all the reviews complaining about food errors because the food does look good and taste good as well but this is unacceptable. I ordered an 8 pcs shrimp and fries. Delivery was very fast I will say but never in my life have I ever ordered shrimp and received shrimp this small. Sure if I ordered a boil bag or something it wouldn't be that much of an issue. But fried shrimp this tiny?? After eating my midget shrimp dinner, I still had to order more food smh.
Tee Hilaire
Great food ! But horrible service smh hours to get one plate of food. Only serve seafood at the moment . The whole store reeks of marijuana, they’re smoking right in front of you too!! The young guys in there are TOO GHETTO! Store has potential jusy the worlds aren’t doing their jobs I would love to see this black owned shop prosper !! Get new workers who actually want to work
mel G
Great food.
Kristopher B.
Besides the missing shrimp the empty tartar sauce the empty hot sauce the food is pretty good
Eric H.
Food was mad late. Like almost two hrs late, I live like a mile from the spot. Not sure why? It's j*** chicken, fried fish and shrimp, that should be ready quick. Portions super skimpy, maybe it's different when you eat at the spot, and whoever answered the phone is some type of bobo. Be more gracious with the portions, especially the j**** Barely got any meat on them, and pieces were small. Got 3 pieces instead of 5. The sauce was sprinkled on the side. And not sure what's going with the delivery service but you guys need new staff taking orders too. I don't think they know how to communicate or perhaps they just don't care. There's so many places in Brooklyn that make jerk- with plentiful portions you can't even finish the meal, and a proper serving of sauce is to be expected, there's no room for slack. There's a lot of competition. You guys need to amp up your game if you want to survive!
Daniel Grady
Store smelled of marijuana. Walking thru the store seemed too have noticed a couple of “expired” products still up. Asked for a sandwich and got offered shrimp? Immediate turnoff was being offered spoiled bread for my sandwich.
Great People! Great Seafood! If your in the area, do yourself a favor and stop by. The food is undeniably good!
Olga Marchese
This place is great! Convenient pricing, considerable portions and the employees are regularly welcoming.
Marie J.
The only reason I'm even giving one star is because I don't have the option for zero star. This place is horrible. The food is greasy, not cook well and when he offered to re deliver the food the other was still wrong and not well prepared. Strongly advise that no one eats from this place. Even the Uber driver complained.
Dalia B.
I usually don't write reviews, but due to the amazing service I received at Brooklyn Wild Catch, I felt compelled to. I ordered a grilled salmon with chips, and I was blown away. The food was amazing! The grilled salmon was to die for! It was perfectly seasoned and moist! 5/5! The chips fried perfectly and crispy, just how I like it! I've lived in this neighborhood for years, and I'm glad to have a seafood establishment as good as this around. A+++++
2.8 rating? Yikes... Guess this what happens when you name your restaurant in the middle of Queens after our arch nemesis borough? Brooklyn Wild Catch and it smell funny in here, just like Sunset Park Brooklyn so I guess the name makes sense lol
Shrimp and grits were meh. Smelled like weed was smoking in there. Won't be back.
Missing items
I placed an order on DoorDash my order was confirmed. I saw where they were preparing my order and the dasher was headed to the store. The next thing I know my order is canceled. I called doordash and they said the dasher got to the store and it was closed. I said closed it said 24hrs and I got a confirmed order email and it showed they were working on it. The absolute worst I tried to support.
Brooklyn wild catch what the hell is this??? I took a chance despite all the reviews complaining about food errors because the food does look good and taste good as well but this is unacceptable. I ordered an 8 pcs shrimp and fries. Delivery was very fast I will say but never in my life have I ever ordered shrimp and received shrimp this small. Sure if I ordered a boil bag or something it wouldn't be that much of an issue. But fried shrimp this tiny?? After eating my midget shrimp dinner, I still had to order more food smh.
Great food ! But horrible service smh hours to get one plate of food. Only serve seafood at the moment . The whole store reeks of marijuana, they’re smoking right in front of you too!! The young guys in there are TOO GHETTO! Store has potential jusy the worlds aren’t doing their jobs I would love to see this black owned shop prosper !! Get new workers who actually want to work
Great food.
Besides the missing shrimp the empty tartar sauce the empty hot sauce the food is pretty good
Food was mad late. Like almost two hrs late, I live like a mile from the spot. Not sure why? It's j*** chicken, fried fish and shrimp, that should be ready quick. Portions super skimpy, maybe it's different when you eat at the spot, and whoever answered the phone is some type of bobo. Be more gracious with the portions, especially the j**** Barely got any meat on them, and pieces were small. Got 3 pieces instead of 5. The sauce was sprinkled on the side. And not sure what's going with the delivery service but you guys need new staff taking orders too. I don't think they know how to communicate or perhaps they just don't care. There's so many places in Brooklyn that make jerk- with plentiful portions you can't even finish the meal, and a proper serving of sauce is to be expected, there's no room for slack. There's a lot of competition. You guys need to amp up your game if you want to survive!
Store smelled of marijuana. Walking thru the store seemed too have noticed a couple of “expired” products still up. Asked for a sandwich and got offered shrimp? Immediate turnoff was being offered spoiled bread for my sandwich.
Restaurantji Recommends
Great Seafood!
Great People! Great Seafood! If your in the area, do yourself a favor and stop by. The food is undeniably good!
This place is great! Convenient pricing, considerable portions and the employees are regularly welcoming.
The only reason I'm even giving one star is because I don't have the option for zero star. This place is horrible. The food is greasy, not cook well and when he offered to re deliver the food the other was still wrong and not well prepared. Strongly advise that no one eats from this place. Even the Uber driver complained.
I usually don't write reviews, but due to the amazing service I received at Brooklyn Wild Catch, I felt compelled to. I ordered a grilled salmon with chips, and I was blown away. The food was amazing! The grilled salmon was to die for! It was perfectly seasoned and moist! 5/5! The chips fried perfectly and crispy, just how I like it! I've lived in this neighborhood for years, and I'm glad to have a seafood establishment as good as this around. A+++++