3.5 if i could do halfsies fiancée & i usually just get wings n pizza from here which is above average. if u like crispy wings ask for them xtra crispy! small pizza is fairly large, the 2 of us cant finish it in one sitting also would not recommend the garbage plate... i guess theres a reason that ppl havent posted a pic of it on google reviews or yelp....... if u order from here make sure to check out their website bcos they always have coupons nd deals. they used to have a free order of fried dough for orders above $20 but that deal is $1 now its a small pizza place so not much room to sit & eat inside...maybe just one table with 2 chairs- idr we never eat there. conveniently, hermas is right nxt door & u can grab some drinks & a fresh crunchy green stalk of celery, yum
Michele Alessi
Thank you for waiting,when I almost forgot to pick up my meal , eggplant Parm hit the spot !!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Sue SmithHartman AndChris Hartman
it is against the law to not post that you charge a fee to use a credit card. I called to ask a manager about this and they said it's posted on their online ordering. what sense does that make,? first time last time.
Mike VanDerWoude
Absolutely the best! I drive from Webster for their food. Thank goodness the outlet Bridge is open. Love this place.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
fegero
We just moved into the area and picked the closest pizza shop. Awesome pizza, wings and breaded shrooms. I can't wait to try out other items on their menu.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Tom Stenglein
Everything is great, this is the best all around pizza shop! No matter what you order, it's done well. Nobody can be the absolute best at every single thing, but I have never been disappointed with anything I've ordered from them. Good people, great service.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Deanna Tootle
Well I think it’s safe to say…don’t order from Cordello's Pizzeria! We usually LOVE their food and pay our fare share there….trust me….to have strands of hair in my food 2 weeks ago and now the most burnt, inedible, not a spud left in that thing of French fries…not just 1 plate….but 3’s worth! When called I spoke to the “owner” Greg i was told I guess I have to take my chances when I call and order from there and there is nothing they can do…..after I have just ordered $80 worth of food.
Take my chances when ordering from your establishment…..what!???
Yeah that’s not where I want my food from EVER again!
Take my chances this guy says….pshhhhh the absolute nerve….
I’m not even being dramatic like these things snap crackle and pop….my dogs wouldn’t even evaaaaaa
This is why I’m done and I apologize for cheating on Tony’s Birdland….nothing compares
Janet R.
Pizza was pretty good and reasonably priced. Something was missing tho. A tastier sauce!
Kathe Militello
Never had a problem. We have had delivery and take out. Food excellent. We have always been treated well.
We ordered a 12 inch steak pizza and 6 piece chicken wings for delivery. The food tastes great and is better than the usual pizza place we order from. The chicken wings were a little dry though. The business has a website but it only shows the menu, you can’t order online. All orders have to be done over the phone. There’s a $3.99 charge of you use credit card to make a payment. Delivery takes 45 minutes.
very kind every time I call the delivery person always respectful the food fresh and hot …
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza Slice
T Oz
We ordered 2 sheets and 100 wings for my sons 2nd birthday party... Everyone at the party kept asking where we got the pizza they loved it so much! Thanks!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Robin Terris
Excellent food! Customer service is phenomenal. Yesterday, I placed an order to be delivered. Got the wrong order by mistake. Cordello's call me and let me know and that they would deliver my order immediately which they did, very timely. They apologized and also gave me my food for free. Excellent food and great customer service! Can't beat that!!
3.5 if i could do halfsies fiancée & i usually just get wings n pizza from here which is above average. if u like crispy wings ask for them xtra crispy! small pizza is fairly large, the 2 of us cant finish it in one sitting also would not recommend the garbage plate... i guess theres a reason that ppl havent posted a pic of it on google reviews or yelp....... if u order from here make sure to check out their website bcos they always have coupons nd deals. they used to have a free order of fried dough for orders above $20 but that deal is $1 now its a small pizza place so not much room to sit & eat inside...maybe just one table with 2 chairs- idr we never eat there. conveniently, hermas is right nxt door & u can grab some drinks & a fresh crunchy green stalk of celery, yum
Thank you for waiting,when I almost forgot to pick up my meal , eggplant Parm hit the spot !!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
it is against the law to not post that you charge a fee to use a credit card. I called to ask a manager about this and they said it's posted on their online ordering. what sense does that make,? first time last time.
Absolutely the best! I drive from Webster for their food. Thank goodness the outlet Bridge is open. Love this place.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
We just moved into the area and picked the closest pizza shop. Awesome pizza, wings and breaded shrooms. I can't wait to try out other items on their menu.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Everything is great, this is the best all around pizza shop! No matter what you order, it's done well. Nobody can be the absolute best at every single thing, but I have never been disappointed with anything I've ordered from them. Good people, great service.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Well I think it’s safe to say…don’t order from Cordello's Pizzeria! We usually LOVE their food and pay our fare share there….trust me….to have strands of hair in my food 2 weeks ago and now the most burnt, inedible, not a spud left in that thing of French fries…not just 1 plate….but 3’s worth! When called I spoke to the “owner” Greg i was told I guess I have to take my chances when I call and order from there and there is nothing they can do…..after I have just ordered $80 worth of food. Take my chances when ordering from your establishment…..what!??? Yeah that’s not where I want my food from EVER again! Take my chances this guy says….pshhhhh the absolute nerve…. I’m not even being dramatic like these things snap crackle and pop….my dogs wouldn’t even evaaaaaa This is why I’m done and I apologize for cheating on Tony’s Birdland….nothing compares
Pizza was pretty good and reasonably priced. Something was missing tho. A tastier sauce!
Never had a problem. We have had delivery and take out. Food excellent. We have always been treated well.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Eggplant Parmesan, Chicken Parmesan
We ordered a 12 inch steak pizza and 6 piece chicken wings for delivery. The food tastes great and is better than the usual pizza place we order from. The chicken wings were a little dry though. The business has a website but it only shows the menu, you can’t order online. All orders have to be done over the phone. There’s a $3.99 charge of you use credit card to make a payment. Delivery takes 45 minutes.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
Best steak and cheese Sub in Irondequoit.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
very kind every time I call the delivery person always respectful the food fresh and hot …
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza Slice
We ordered 2 sheets and 100 wings for my sons 2nd birthday party... Everyone at the party kept asking where we got the pizza they loved it so much! Thanks!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Excellent food! Customer service is phenomenal. Yesterday, I placed an order to be delivered. Got the wrong order by mistake. Cordello's call me and let me know and that they would deliver my order immediately which they did, very timely. They apologized and also gave me my food for free. Excellent food and great customer service! Can't beat that!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Onion Rings, Fish Fry, Cheeseburger, Cold Sub, Boneless Wings, Crispy Chicken Salad, Chicken Parmesan, Homemade Cheesecake, Steak Plate, Mac Salad
Food has decreased in quality for the past few years ! And their customer service is nothing to brag about ! If I could I would give it 0 Stars !