Great drinks, food, and service. Clean and well run. What more can you ask! Thank you. We'll be back.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Joann Perry
Forest Hill restaurant the food price cannot be absolutely delicious. Everything on the menu is phenomenal large portions great service great place for family and friends to dine.Parking: Front row handicap parkingKid-friendliness: Kid friendly with a great menu
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Fresh Broil Haddock French Fries
Lourdes Roa
Such a gem in North Greece! Love this place. The food is so good, and the service is great. The atmosphere is like a family gathering where it gets loud at times with everyone talking, but thats not so bad. Its better than having loud music to contend with.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Cate Eisenschmidt
Excellent in every way. Staff is amazing, wonderful service, incredible food and very nice vibe. I look forward to many visits .
stacy avangelista
We have been coming here for awhile. Hilton has a LOT of restaurants all with wood fired pizzas, bar food etc. Forest Hill is beyond. Amazing diverse menu, EXCELLENT proportions, NOT the usual mundane. Jaime the server can handle the whole dining room blind folded, and Doug the bartender will make you feel like your on Cheers. Complete with an actual FULL pour on a glass of wine. We LOVE it here and are always full and satisfied. Only downfall, no reservations on Fridays so get there early!!!!
First time there. Food was excellent, service was great. Good size menu. Barmaid was very professional and personal. Portions are good size, prices reasonable. Will be stopping in there again for sure. Very impressive.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Chester Rinaudo
Excellent food, servicePrice is right, and the portions....
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
Schulz
Server asked us to leave immediately. after dinner
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 1
Amie M. Triano
called and made reservations as per message on their answering machine for 2. message said if you don't hear back consider your res confirmed
showed up at 5 for dinner and we were told they don't have our reservation ; explained we called to reserve and didn't hear back = confirmation
finally said they would "squeeze us in"
we were seated and given menus and asked if we were ready to order. we said we just sat down and were not ready
we were told we didnt have a reservation and they had to "flip the table ". my guest said we were not going to be rushed through dinner and we did have reservation. waitress said "well i don't know what to tell you and walked away"
she came back aplogized and said she was misinformed and we did have reservations.
at the end of dinner we asked to speak to owner
waitress said thst was not a good idea since mike Sheedy was not a nice person and she didnt want to make the situation worse
we said we didnt care go get him. again we were told he was not a nice guy and she didn't want to bring him out.
waitress then turned to a regular couple behind us and asked them if they thought bringing mike out was a good idea since he wasnt a nice guy. they didnt reply.
again... go get him
waited another 10 minutes and were told hes not coming out.
if you arent a nice guy Mike Sheedy then dont own a restaurant if you can't deal with customers.
also your waitresses bad mouthing you is not a good look.
we had reservations and were treated like we were a burden because you screwed up
you dont make the customer feel like you are doing them a favor by seating them on your error. horrible practices and if your system for reservations doesn't work change it. won't be back and wont recommend and making sure everyone knows Mike Sheedy is "not a nice guy"
Forest hill was a go to place. Tonight ? No way. Most disgusting food I've ever had there. Stuffed chicken breast was something from the frozen food section of Wegmans. Grilled swordfish again frozen thawed and Grilled, passed off as fresh...meal was the worst...go to the Dakota if you want a great dinner. Forest hill has gone downhill in a fast way. Potatoe and salad were the only good things about the meal...
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 1
Service: 4
Deb
Excellent! First time at establishment, honestly never heard of. It's a hidden gem. The food was SO good. The blue cheese dressing was delicious, thick chunky, and pair perfectly with salad. Fried calamari was really good. The broiled seafood platter was cooked perfectly and included haddock, stuffed shrimp, scallops, and clams casino. The stuffing on the shrimp was so unique and yummy. Others in party enjoyed their dishes too. The restaurant is pretty small and filled up fast. Will definitely be back, so good!!
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Broiled Seafood
Wen D.
Delicious food, large portions, great value, friendly service! Forest Hill checks all of the boxes for a wonderful dining experience! Personal favorites are the shrimp with crabmeat stuffing, chicken parm, chicken French, broiled seafood platter, fish fry(Fri). The restaurant is small, but a modern decor. There is a separate bar area, and a deck where you can enjoy a cocktail if you have to wait for your table. I highly recommend dinner here!
Great Friday fish
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Great drinks, food, and service. Clean and well run. What more can you ask! Thank you. We'll be back.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Forest Hill restaurant the food price cannot be absolutely delicious. Everything on the menu is phenomenal large portions great service great place for family and friends to dine.Parking: Front row handicap parkingKid-friendliness: Kid friendly with a great menu
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Fresh Broil Haddock French Fries
Such a gem in North Greece! Love this place. The food is so good, and the service is great. The atmosphere is like a family gathering where it gets loud at times with everyone talking, but thats not so bad. Its better than having loud music to contend with.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Excellent in every way. Staff is amazing, wonderful service, incredible food and very nice vibe. I look forward to many visits .
We have been coming here for awhile. Hilton has a LOT of restaurants all with wood fired pizzas, bar food etc. Forest Hill is beyond. Amazing diverse menu, EXCELLENT proportions, NOT the usual mundane. Jaime the server can handle the whole dining room blind folded, and Doug the bartender will make you feel like your on Cheers. Complete with an actual FULL pour on a glass of wine. We LOVE it here and are always full and satisfied. Only downfall, no reservations on Fridays so get there early!!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Buffalo Chicken Wings, Giant Fried Clams, Broiled Seafood, Fresh Broil Haddock French Fries
First time there. Food was excellent, service was great. Good size menu. Barmaid was very professional and personal. Portions are good size, prices reasonable. Will be stopping in there again for sure. Very impressive.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Excellent food, servicePrice is right, and the portions....
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
Server asked us to leave immediately. after dinner
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 1
called and made reservations as per message on their answering machine for 2. message said if you don't hear back consider your res confirmed showed up at 5 for dinner and we were told they don't have our reservation ; explained we called to reserve and didn't hear back = confirmation finally said they would "squeeze us in" we were seated and given menus and asked if we were ready to order. we said we just sat down and were not ready we were told we didnt have a reservation and they had to "flip the table ". my guest said we were not going to be rushed through dinner and we did have reservation. waitress said "well i don't know what to tell you and walked away" she came back aplogized and said she was misinformed and we did have reservations. at the end of dinner we asked to speak to owner waitress said thst was not a good idea since mike Sheedy was not a nice person and she didnt want to make the situation worse we said we didnt care go get him. again we were told he was not a nice guy and she didn't want to bring him out. waitress then turned to a regular couple behind us and asked them if they thought bringing mike out was a good idea since he wasnt a nice guy. they didnt reply. again... go get him waited another 10 minutes and were told hes not coming out. if you arent a nice guy Mike Sheedy then dont own a restaurant if you can't deal with customers. also your waitresses bad mouthing you is not a good look. we had reservations and were treated like we were a burden because you screwed up you dont make the customer feel like you are doing them a favor by seating them on your error. horrible practices and if your system for reservations doesn't work change it. won't be back and wont recommend and making sure everyone knows Mike Sheedy is "not a nice guy"
Restaurantji Recommends
Excellent food always and great waitress.
Waitress funny and nice, food was amazing!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Forest hill was a go to place. Tonight ? No way. Most disgusting food I've ever had there. Stuffed chicken breast was something from the frozen food section of Wegmans. Grilled swordfish again frozen thawed and Grilled, passed off as fresh...meal was the worst...go to the Dakota if you want a great dinner. Forest hill has gone downhill in a fast way. Potatoe and salad were the only good things about the meal...
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 1
Service: 4
Excellent! First time at establishment, honestly never heard of. It's a hidden gem. The food was SO good. The blue cheese dressing was delicious, thick chunky, and pair perfectly with salad. Fried calamari was really good. The broiled seafood platter was cooked perfectly and included haddock, stuffed shrimp, scallops, and clams casino. The stuffing on the shrimp was so unique and yummy. Others in party enjoyed their dishes too. The restaurant is pretty small and filled up fast. Will definitely be back, so good!!
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Broiled Seafood
Delicious food, large portions, great value, friendly service! Forest Hill checks all of the boxes for a wonderful dining experience! Personal favorites are the shrimp with crabmeat stuffing, chicken parm, chicken French, broiled seafood platter, fish fry(Fri). The restaurant is small, but a modern decor. There is a separate bar area, and a deck where you can enjoy a cocktail if you have to wait for your table. I highly recommend dinner here!