I stopped in at about 1 pm. on a Thursday to get a slice. While they had an abundant selection, they all seemed as if they were made at 10:30 am. They had one fresh pepperoni and cheese that just came out, but the pepperoni was quite chared. I decided to order a sausage, meatball, and ricotta even though it looked old. As the cook was getting it ready to put in the oven, I asked how much I owed him m, he said it would be over $7 for ONE slice. I kindly said, "For one slice? That's okay, I changed my mind. He replied I don't blame you." While I can't attest to the taste or quality other than the visual aspect, I can say the price was outrageous for a regular large pizza slice.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 1
Service: 3
Juliann Bailey
Thanks guys. The best pizza I have ever had. Go with the thin crust XL for HUGE slices!!
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pie
peter sinopoli
Huge selection.....I need to revise my review...I like to stop here before work, today it's 745pm and the doors are locked and the place is closed. I hate when places advertise that they are open and then u show up and they aren't! I'm not going to stop here anymore because some lazy employees want to leave early. Poor management! And poor work ethic! Despicable!
Kevin C.
Thin. Crust not doughy decent flavors basic inside fair service got the special buy a slice get a slice free
max
This is seriously good pizza. The thing that really impressed me was the quality of the dough used. I ate 2 pieces - one pulled pork bbq and the other buffalo chicken with extra hot sauce. They were so good that I saved the crusts and ate them later.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Linda Schiess
I'm lactose intolerant, but every so often, I can't fight the crave for Brooklyn style pizza! I take the tablets and treat myself!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Deby L.
Ordered a few days before superbowl Sunday. It didn't help. Arrived at scheduled pick up time and nothing was started. One pizza was white garlic with anchovies. They added the anchovies after the pizza was cooked and cut?? The traditional pizza was over cooked and dry. Once the pizzas were done they started the wings. Needless to say the pizzas were cold and hard. I took the anchovies off as they looked like a dollop of Pooh. I tried it and it wasn't edible. The wings were MEH! Won't go back. And won't recommend to anyone!
Matthew G.
A little bit more expensive than competitors but you can taste the difference - worth every penny!
Scott Lawrence
Delicious thin crust pizza! The people were really great too.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Buffalo Chicken
Jessica Santiago
Very good specialty pizzas. The workers are very nice too. The guy working today even offered to cut up my daughter’s pizza.
Garlic pizza lovers: you have to try the black garlic pizza here, it is fantastic.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Nicholas Lombardo
I have been to Joe's Brooklyn Pizza several times for lunch and I have never been disappointed. Their slices are huge, fresh, and delicious. They have a variety of flavors to choose from, and I have tried several. My favorites are the chicken, bacon and pulled pork pizza, and the pepperoni, Italian sausage, and mozzarella pizza. The crust is crispy, chewy, and flavorful, and the toppings are generous and well-balanced. The staff is friendly and efficient, and the prices are reasonable. The restaurant is clean and cozy, and the atmosphere is relaxed and casual. I highly recommend Joe's Brooklyn Pizza to anyone who loves authentic Brooklyn-style pizza. It is One of my favorite stops for pizza in Rochester!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Joe Diggity
The general manager is an older boomer and is an absolute nightmare… why he runs the stores is beyond me. The slices of pizza are very expensive. They hire you for $16/hr. I’ve been working pizzeria for the last 5 years! They had to give me at least $17. They could’ve easily gave more. The general manager is greedy and takes the money for NO REASON idk what he is supposed to be doing in charge? Why did they fail to have some of the most basic ingredients? Sorry boomer I’m contacting the New York State health department! You’ve annoyed me so I will expose the health violations. I’m bored in the hospital so I will waste my time and send in the pictures I took of the rat poop in the back! Shhh don’t worry I have to expose you guys ! Maybe the old boomer manager should’ve took a hike. I hope you enjoy cleaning before the health inspector comes in! I’ve never worked in a disorganized in my life! I cannot wait until they get their head out of their behind!Working here is an absolute nightmare. Paychecks were never correct.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Recommended dishes: Cheese Pizza
Hillary Goldstein
Pizza was cold, bottom was burned, and if I wanted bread sticks I would have ordered them. Where’s the pizza.
Food: 1
Service: 1
Frank Saccone
You're not going here for ambiance. You're there because the pie is fantastic. Maybe it was an off day when I went in, because they hadn't even started my order, despite being told it would be 45 minutes pick up and I showed up after an hour.But, after at least a half hour of waiting, they brought out my pies and garlic knots (get knots... a bunch. 3 won't do. Trust me). The food was just spectacular. I like the one in perinton better because they usually have my food ready when I get there, but if I'm in Henrietta, I'm going their for pie.
I stopped in at about 1 pm. on a Thursday to get a slice. While they had an abundant selection, they all seemed as if they were made at 10:30 am. They had one fresh pepperoni and cheese that just came out, but the pepperoni was quite chared. I decided to order a sausage, meatball, and ricotta even though it looked old. As the cook was getting it ready to put in the oven, I asked how much I owed him m, he said it would be over $7 for ONE slice. I kindly said, "For one slice? That's okay, I changed my mind. He replied I don't blame you." While I can't attest to the taste or quality other than the visual aspect, I can say the price was outrageous for a regular large pizza slice.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 1
Service: 3
Thanks guys. The best pizza I have ever had. Go with the thin crust XL for HUGE slices!!
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pie
Huge selection.....I need to revise my review...I like to stop here before work, today it's 745pm and the doors are locked and the place is closed. I hate when places advertise that they are open and then u show up and they aren't! I'm not going to stop here anymore because some lazy employees want to leave early. Poor management! And poor work ethic! Despicable!
Thin. Crust not doughy decent flavors basic inside fair service got the special buy a slice get a slice free
This is seriously good pizza. The thing that really impressed me was the quality of the dough used. I ate 2 pieces - one pulled pork bbq and the other buffalo chicken with extra hot sauce. They were so good that I saved the crusts and ate them later.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I'm lactose intolerant, but every so often, I can't fight the crave for Brooklyn style pizza! I take the tablets and treat myself!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Ordered a few days before superbowl Sunday. It didn't help. Arrived at scheduled pick up time and nothing was started. One pizza was white garlic with anchovies. They added the anchovies after the pizza was cooked and cut?? The traditional pizza was over cooked and dry. Once the pizzas were done they started the wings. Needless to say the pizzas were cold and hard. I took the anchovies off as they looked like a dollop of Pooh. I tried it and it wasn't edible. The wings were MEH! Won't go back. And won't recommend to anyone!
A little bit more expensive than competitors but you can taste the difference - worth every penny!
Delicious thin crust pizza! The people were really great too.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Buffalo Chicken
Very good specialty pizzas. The workers are very nice too. The guy working today even offered to cut up my daughter’s pizza.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
Garlic pizza lovers: you have to try the black garlic pizza here, it is fantastic.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
I have been to Joe's Brooklyn Pizza several times for lunch and I have never been disappointed. Their slices are huge, fresh, and delicious. They have a variety of flavors to choose from, and I have tried several. My favorites are the chicken, bacon and pulled pork pizza, and the pepperoni, Italian sausage, and mozzarella pizza. The crust is crispy, chewy, and flavorful, and the toppings are generous and well-balanced. The staff is friendly and efficient, and the prices are reasonable. The restaurant is clean and cozy, and the atmosphere is relaxed and casual. I highly recommend Joe's Brooklyn Pizza to anyone who loves authentic Brooklyn-style pizza. It is One of my favorite stops for pizza in Rochester!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The general manager is an older boomer and is an absolute nightmare… why he runs the stores is beyond me. The slices of pizza are very expensive. They hire you for $16/hr. I’ve been working pizzeria for the last 5 years! They had to give me at least $17. They could’ve easily gave more. The general manager is greedy and takes the money for NO REASON idk what he is supposed to be doing in charge? Why did they fail to have some of the most basic ingredients? Sorry boomer I’m contacting the New York State health department! You’ve annoyed me so I will expose the health violations. I’m bored in the hospital so I will waste my time and send in the pictures I took of the rat poop in the back! Shhh don’t worry I have to expose you guys ! Maybe the old boomer manager should’ve took a hike. I hope you enjoy cleaning before the health inspector comes in! I’ve never worked in a disorganized in my life! I cannot wait until they get their head out of their behind!Working here is an absolute nightmare. Paychecks were never correct.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Recommended dishes: Cheese Pizza
Pizza was cold, bottom was burned, and if I wanted bread sticks I would have ordered them. Where’s the pizza.
Food: 1
Service: 1
You're not going here for ambiance. You're there because the pie is fantastic. Maybe it was an off day when I went in, because they hadn't even started my order, despite being told it would be 45 minutes pick up and I showed up after an hour.But, after at least a half hour of waiting, they brought out my pies and garlic knots (get knots... a bunch. 3 won't do. Trust me). The food was just spectacular. I like the one in perinton better because they usually have my food ready when I get there, but if I'm in Henrietta, I'm going their for pie.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 3
Recommended dishes: Cheese Pizza