Food is usually good. Sandwiches are put together very sloppily. Service is always in a rush so they tend to be short and impatient with customers. They also scream your name for your order very loudly even if you are right there which is somewhat understandable but mostly seems like taking out their frustrations on customers.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 4
Service: 2
Emma Willer
Good and a lot of it. Minor things can be smoother, but a place i will return to.
Robert Buckert
Honestly a bit underwhelmed, but still going for four stars, a low 4, maybe high 3. This was personally my first visit to Nathan's, which has been on my list for a while as a Rochester tradition, with the friendly slogan, "Comfort in a cup." According to their website:"Nathan’s Soup and Salad has been serving homestyle soups, salads and breads to Rochesterians since 1980."I went with my uncle as soon as they opened at 11am. We both ordered large "Smoked Chicken and Sweet Corn Chowder" and got two breads, one garlic and cheese, the other cheddar cheese. Fast and easy service. The soup was good, but not as great as I was expecting. The smoke tasted a bit artificial and there wasn't as much corn as I would've liked from a corn chowder, but the flavor was overall fine. The breads were also good, especially after dipped in the hot soup. Would be excellent if the bread was briefly warmed in an oven as it was a bit tough and cold. Would return, but would try another, more recommended flavor of soup.Having started in the city on Park Ave., they now only have two locations, both in Henrietta. Here at the Genesee Regional Market and one store at RIT, neither in the city which is a bit disappointing.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Cheese Bread
Elizabeth Myakishev-Rempel
delicious, filling soup. I really enjoyed the flavor.croissant was mediocre: not crispy like I expected but it went well with the soup so I don't mind.
Kelly D.
I ordered and paid for a large soup, a medium soup was delivered! The soup was good but the portion was very small for the money that is why I ordered a large.
Zoe Prince
Every time I go my order is wrong and takes multiple times to get right. If they get your order right the food is great, but that’s IF. For some reason plain sandwiches are very hard to make. I have created WAY too much food waste by ordering from them and wasted way too much money ordering food and then going home to eat it for it to be wrong and me needing to throw it out due to allergies
ari b
Best food on R.I.T but if you're thinking about spending real money instead of dining dollars, i recommend going off campus.
Ava Ciliberti
Today soups include crab with red pepper , and chicken gumbo . I just had large size gumbo , with whole grain mini loaf
Sammy Myakishev-Rempel
delicious, filling soup. I really enjoyed the flavor.croissant was mediocre: not crispy like I expected but it went well with the soup so I don't mind.
Terry Lindsey
We ate there then they closed the next day. I hope it wasn't something we did. The food was great and its closing is a real loss.
The soups here are great and the bread it as well. They get you your the food quickly and is always good. Would recommend during the cold days of the year. I always got the chicken noodle and sometimes the broccoli cheese and they were good.
Saikhanaa Z
So bad. Order a hot sandwich that is not even hot it was basically frozen on one side. Tasteless chicken. Even they give it for free I wouldn't eat it. So bad!
Alexis C.
I just started recently going here and boy do I love it! At first I thought it was a little pricey, I might still think that. But once I get the warm soup and warm bread in my body the debate begins. So far I have had the Italian wedding and tomato bisque and both were very great. I very much enjoyed the Italian wedding. Both times I ate it with the rosemary bread. This bread is nice and warm and a mini loaf for only $2! (The debate on price continues). This is a quick go to lunch and any time spot. I have heard the Mac and cheese is pretty good and they do have mini sandwiches but I DO think those are a little pricey. But maybe my mind will change after trying it?
Alex C.
I just started recently going here and boy do I love it! At first I thought it was a little pricey, I might still think that. But once I get the warm soup and warm bread in my body the debate begins. So far I have had the Italian wedding and tomato bisque and both were very great. I very much enjoyed the Italian wedding. Both times I ate it with the rosemary bread. This bread is nice and warm and a mini loaf for only $2! (The debate on price continues). This is a quick go to lunch and any time spot. I have heard the Mac and cheese is pretty good and they do have mini sandwiches but I DO think those are a little pricey. But maybe my mind will change after trying it?
Mark the Matey
This shop has by far some of the bests soups I’ve ever had as of the 2020-2021 semesters. I couldn’t recommend them enough.
Food is usually good. Sandwiches are put together very sloppily. Service is always in a rush so they tend to be short and impatient with customers. They also scream your name for your order very loudly even if you are right there which is somewhat understandable but mostly seems like taking out their frustrations on customers.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 4
Service: 2
Good and a lot of it. Minor things can be smoother, but a place i will return to.
Honestly a bit underwhelmed, but still going for four stars, a low 4, maybe high 3. This was personally my first visit to Nathan's, which has been on my list for a while as a Rochester tradition, with the friendly slogan, "Comfort in a cup." According to their website:"Nathan’s Soup and Salad has been serving homestyle soups, salads and breads to Rochesterians since 1980."I went with my uncle as soon as they opened at 11am. We both ordered large "Smoked Chicken and Sweet Corn Chowder" and got two breads, one garlic and cheese, the other cheddar cheese. Fast and easy service. The soup was good, but not as great as I was expecting. The smoke tasted a bit artificial and there wasn't as much corn as I would've liked from a corn chowder, but the flavor was overall fine. The breads were also good, especially after dipped in the hot soup. Would be excellent if the bread was briefly warmed in an oven as it was a bit tough and cold. Would return, but would try another, more recommended flavor of soup.Having started in the city on Park Ave., they now only have two locations, both in Henrietta. Here at the Genesee Regional Market and one store at RIT, neither in the city which is a bit disappointing.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Cheese Bread
delicious, filling soup. I really enjoyed the flavor.croissant was mediocre: not crispy like I expected but it went well with the soup so I don't mind.
I ordered and paid for a large soup, a medium soup was delivered! The soup was good but the portion was very small for the money that is why I ordered a large.
Every time I go my order is wrong and takes multiple times to get right. If they get your order right the food is great, but that’s IF. For some reason plain sandwiches are very hard to make. I have created WAY too much food waste by ordering from them and wasted way too much money ordering food and then going home to eat it for it to be wrong and me needing to throw it out due to allergies
Best food on R.I.T but if you're thinking about spending real money instead of dining dollars, i recommend going off campus.
Today soups include crab with red pepper , and chicken gumbo . I just had large size gumbo , with whole grain mini loaf
delicious, filling soup. I really enjoyed the flavor.croissant was mediocre: not crispy like I expected but it went well with the soup so I don't mind.
We ate there then they closed the next day. I hope it wasn't something we did. The food was great and its closing is a real loss.
Restaurantji Recommends
The soups here are great and the bread it as well. They get you your the food quickly and is always good. Would recommend during the cold days of the year. I always got the chicken noodle and sometimes the broccoli cheese and they were good.
So bad. Order a hot sandwich that is not even hot it was basically frozen on one side. Tasteless chicken. Even they give it for free I wouldn't eat it. So bad!
I just started recently going here and boy do I love it! At first I thought it was a little pricey, I might still think that. But once I get the warm soup and warm bread in my body the debate begins. So far I have had the Italian wedding and tomato bisque and both were very great. I very much enjoyed the Italian wedding. Both times I ate it with the rosemary bread. This bread is nice and warm and a mini loaf for only $2! (The debate on price continues). This is a quick go to lunch and any time spot. I have heard the Mac and cheese is pretty good and they do have mini sandwiches but I DO think those are a little pricey. But maybe my mind will change after trying it?
I just started recently going here and boy do I love it! At first I thought it was a little pricey, I might still think that. But once I get the warm soup and warm bread in my body the debate begins. So far I have had the Italian wedding and tomato bisque and both were very great. I very much enjoyed the Italian wedding. Both times I ate it with the rosemary bread. This bread is nice and warm and a mini loaf for only $2! (The debate on price continues). This is a quick go to lunch and any time spot. I have heard the Mac and cheese is pretty good and they do have mini sandwiches but I DO think those are a little pricey. But maybe my mind will change after trying it?
This shop has by far some of the bests soups I’ve ever had as of the 2020-2021 semesters. I couldn’t recommend them enough.