I love you ? ? sisters!!! ?♀️ This is fabulous my family is doing big things!! ❤️❤️
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Oatmeal Raisin Cookies, Diane's Strawberry Scooter Crunch Cookies
Brie Clark
I ordered a cookie cake for my son’s birthday. The cake was delicious and they added 2 specialty cookies on the cake that I didn’t expect that was a nice touch! Shana was especially friendly and welcoming when I picked up the cake. I will definitely be back for future birthdays and events. Thank you!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Epiphany Humphrey
I've been shopping with them for years and I've never been disappointed, by far the best cookies in Rochester Ny. They also do cakes and brownies ? They also have Keto
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cookies N Creme Cookie, Corey's Chocolate Chip Cookies, Diane's Strawberry Scooter Crunch Cookies, Snickerdoodle Cookies, Brookies, Cheesecake Cookies, S'Mores Cookies, Strawberry Cookies and Creme Cookies
Brian Phillip
Called they hung up… drove across town to try, oh well.
Google user
My son gave me a Father's Day gift of the sampler which I'm still working through. I'm not the chocolate junkie like my wife but EVERYTHING was top-notch!. My favorite is Diane's Cookie Strawberry Scooter Crunch - almost heaven! And all of the chocolate versions are also great! The Chinese Noodles were approached carefully (who wants chocolate-covered noodles?) but disappeared quickly since they were butterscotch covered in chocolate. What's not to love?? Pic shows me most of the way through...
Jeff Guerdat
My son gave me a Father's Day gift of the sampler which I'm still working through. I'm not the chocolate junkie like my wife but EVERYTHING was top-notch!. My favorite is Diane's Cookie Strawberry Scooter Crunch - almost heaven! And all of the chocolate versions are also great! The Chinese Noodles were approached carefully (who wants chocolate-covered noodles?) but disappeared quickly since they were butterscotch covered in chocolate. What's not to love?? Pic shows me most of the way through...
Kayla
10/10 stawberry cookie is very good i would try it again :)
Harvey Watts
Amazing taste great service, a must have experience!
Jennifer Bowser
We ordered a variety sampler of cookies and they were great! The owner was very friendly, even when I changed my pick-up time. Our favorite flavors so far are the Jackie's Banana Pudding, Strawberry Cookies N Cream, and Diane's Strawberry Scooter Crunch. Soft, fresh, and individually wrapped! Yum!
Kathleen Sanchez
We ordered cookies for my son’s birthday party- the S’more and Strawberry Scooter Crunch. In the middle of the party my husband hid some upstairs as he saw people slipping them in their purses, to make sure he had some for later!!! Decadent and delicious! We will absolutely order again:)
These cookies are so good and the service was great. The people are so nice. I’m definitely ordering again. Fresh and so…. Good
Y Cruz
My job ordered some of these cookies, and boy all of them were good!! Everyone kicked the s'mores cookies to side boyyy did they miss out. It was sooo good. Also the BP Reese's cookies are great. All of them honestly . Would recommend and will be taking a trip for a few cookies
Aleva from Rochester
Fresh, soft, delicious homemade cookies. The double chocolate chip are no joke. Any chocolate-lover would strongly approve. They were still warm when I picked them up. So fresh.
Susan Munday
Outstanding, lovely, customer experience. The owner went above and beyond to ensure my husband got his special birthday cookie delivery on time and with great care taken. Everything exceeded my expectations. Thank you Yummy Cookie Jar.
Sharon Sullivan
Wow!!! These cookies are amazing and so delicious!! The Strawberry Crunch cookie just melts in your mouth. I have been baking for 67 years and I was really surprised at just how good these cookies are!!!
I love you ? ? sisters!!! ?♀️ This is fabulous my family is doing big things!! ❤️❤️
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Oatmeal Raisin Cookies, Diane's Strawberry Scooter Crunch Cookies
I ordered a cookie cake for my son’s birthday. The cake was delicious and they added 2 specialty cookies on the cake that I didn’t expect that was a nice touch! Shana was especially friendly and welcoming when I picked up the cake. I will definitely be back for future birthdays and events. Thank you!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I've been shopping with them for years and I've never been disappointed, by far the best cookies in Rochester Ny. They also do cakes and brownies ? They also have Keto
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cookies N Creme Cookie, Corey's Chocolate Chip Cookies, Diane's Strawberry Scooter Crunch Cookies, Snickerdoodle Cookies, Brookies, Cheesecake Cookies, S'Mores Cookies, Strawberry Cookies and Creme Cookies
Called they hung up… drove across town to try, oh well.
My son gave me a Father's Day gift of the sampler which I'm still working through. I'm not the chocolate junkie like my wife but EVERYTHING was top-notch!. My favorite is Diane's Cookie Strawberry Scooter Crunch - almost heaven! And all of the chocolate versions are also great! The Chinese Noodles were approached carefully (who wants chocolate-covered noodles?) but disappeared quickly since they were butterscotch covered in chocolate. What's not to love?? Pic shows me most of the way through...
My son gave me a Father's Day gift of the sampler which I'm still working through. I'm not the chocolate junkie like my wife but EVERYTHING was top-notch!. My favorite is Diane's Cookie Strawberry Scooter Crunch - almost heaven! And all of the chocolate versions are also great! The Chinese Noodles were approached carefully (who wants chocolate-covered noodles?) but disappeared quickly since they were butterscotch covered in chocolate. What's not to love?? Pic shows me most of the way through...
10/10 stawberry cookie is very good i would try it again :)
Amazing taste great service, a must have experience!
We ordered a variety sampler of cookies and they were great! The owner was very friendly, even when I changed my pick-up time. Our favorite flavors so far are the Jackie's Banana Pudding, Strawberry Cookies N Cream, and Diane's Strawberry Scooter Crunch. Soft, fresh, and individually wrapped! Yum!
We ordered cookies for my son’s birthday party- the S’more and Strawberry Scooter Crunch. In the middle of the party my husband hid some upstairs as he saw people slipping them in their purses, to make sure he had some for later!!! Decadent and delicious! We will absolutely order again:)
Restaurantji Recommends
These cookies are so good and the service was great. The people are so nice. I’m definitely ordering again. Fresh and so…. Good
My job ordered some of these cookies, and boy all of them were good!! Everyone kicked the s'mores cookies to side boyyy did they miss out. It was sooo good. Also the BP Reese's cookies are great. All of them honestly . Would recommend and will be taking a trip for a few cookies
Fresh, soft, delicious homemade cookies. The double chocolate chip are no joke. Any chocolate-lover would strongly approve. They were still warm when I picked them up. So fresh.
Outstanding, lovely, customer experience. The owner went above and beyond to ensure my husband got his special birthday cookie delivery on time and with great care taken. Everything exceeded my expectations. Thank you Yummy Cookie Jar.
Wow!!! These cookies are amazing and so delicious!! The Strawberry Crunch cookie just melts in your mouth. I have been baking for 67 years and I was really surprised at just how good these cookies are!!!