Gatsby's Landing

1362 Old Northern Blvd, Roslyn
(516) 277-2318

Recent Reviews

Dave Castel

What a great place I never knew existed. Honestly I didn’t know what to expect. The menu was a little bit of this and a little bit of that. Different flavors that I didn’t expect like the sliders. The cheesesteak sandwich demolishes anything from Philadelphia! Will definitely be back again!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Matty B.

There is a reason to continue to return here my clients as well as myself love the ambiance (warm, inviting, beautiful views and perfect music) , the food is consistently delicious with a diverse menu that has something for everyone with fresh made pasta dishes, thoughtful specials and unique fish presentations that are spot on. Jared and staff continue to provide an exceptional experience whether it is the handcrafted cocktails or recommendations for a wine to compliment the meal - you cannot make a bad choice.

Powerhouse 1.

ldr: Food 9/10; Vibe 10/10; Service 10/10; Cleanliness 6/10; Value 7/10 great ambiance

Jean Liu

The waiter is very

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 3

Service: 4

Joy E.

Been here a few times recently. Everything is always great and delicious! The food is always consistent the few times I've been and the staff is friendly. The ambiance is warm and friendly, harkening back to the roaring twenties! Jenna, the manager, is great! She really goes out of her way to make sure everyone is happy and you can see that in her attitude! Would recommend and I will be back! :)

Andres Felipe Rios

I came here with my wife- this restaurant is amazing. The food is delicious. Jenna (the manager), went above and beyond with our drinks and food recommendations. This place was so busy and even so, all of our orders came on time and our server was very attentive. We will be coming back soon for another date night!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Melissa Lopez

This is hands down my favorite go to spot! We went last night, last minute reservation and they accommodated us!Our server Mateo was super friendly and helpful with all of our drinks & orders. Super friendly staff and all very attentive. Their vibe is exactly what you want when you're out with friends, family or even on a date night. Love it!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Overall- very disappointing. fish way overpriced for portion size and presentation. waitress was nice but did not explain the food correctly. Fish was minuscule and salad was small, some greens, very little cheese and dates. We were told it was based on ‘baby' lettuce, it was actually some type of mesculin or arugula. Hostess approached us while dining, tried to explain to us why portions were so tiny. Although portions were small she said the taste is all that mattered. We came to a restaurant to eat, not to taste. Nobody tried to make it better. They just shrugged the issue away. It was also rushed. Although the place was not full they had us in and out. We walked out feeling ripped off and still hungry. Thank God for last night's left overs.

Nicole Pellegrino

Good food, pretty view, nice ambiance, nice staff, and good music!

Dina Zel

Beautiful atmosphere, excellent service, gluten free options, unique dishes, nice presentation, warm bread, DELICIOUS!Only wish had more vegan optionsDietary restrictions: Celiac friendly. Needs vegan options

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

CathyF

This restaurant is amazing! Beautiful inside as well as amazing water views. Food was delicious and service was impeccable! Highly recommend! Will definitely be returning in the future!

G Q.

The place is beautiful and bar looks nice for a drink but I went for dinner and got an app, entree and dessert and everything was so bland and underwhelming. The service was eh, not bad but not great. But the food being that tasteless is just annoying and disappointing because it's pricey and the " name" has a reputation but it's just all hype. Don't go here to eat. Maybe just for a drink at the bar.

Let's Go

Great food and ambience. The clams on my seafood pasta was really fresh. We were there for a business lunch. The server looked kinds of nervous. He had a little trouble listening and got an order wrong. The service was not bad, just needs to be improved. Smile more!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 3

Nate D.

Cheese board was underwhelming . Came with a stack of pepperoni that looked like it belonged in a pizza parlor. The cheese was hard. Nice grapes though.

Michelle K.

This place is always a 5 out of 5 for us until today. The food is excellent and generous. The waiters are also attentive and provide excellent service every single time we go. The only problem today was the new manager. He went around introducing himself to every table with white customers and purposely skipped ours. He went out of his way to avoid our table and ignore our existence. He's not responsible for us but if he was going around introducing himself he shouldn't blatantly ignore the only non white patrons. Even when we were leaving he was short with us and basically said "bye thanks." AKA don't come back because you're not white. My husband and I normally love this place. We come here for special occasions and have been coming here since before we were married. This is the first time we had an uncomfortable encounter. Again, I want to emphasize the rest of the staff are phenomenal. They always treat us with respect and provide the best service. We also love the food. It's the new manager with the goatee who treated us with indifference.

Load More