Overpriced, bad service, owners don't get it - just focus on extracting as much price as possible. Significantly more expensive than any alternatives
Braden Smith
Hand Rolled Bagels is a must-visit! The aroma of fresh, hand-rolled bagels is irresistible, offering the perfect mix of crunchy and soft with a great variety to choose from. It's my go-to spot in Rye for a quick, delicious bite.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Kevin Kim
Fantastic bagels, excellent service!
Charlie McMillan
Did I spend $17 on 2 bagels and lox spread?Yes.Was it one of the best bagels I’ve ever had?Yes.Would I do it again?Definitely.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Eunice Park
best bagels ever!!! Definitely need to check it out if you’re nearby!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
karin Ben-Zeev
Great bagels
Food: 5
Service: 5
Ann L.
This place really has some of the best bagels I've ever had in the area. I had a lox bagel with cream cheese on an everything bagel and it was soft, fresh-tasting, and full of flavor. Definitely try this place out!
Eunice P.
this is where all the locals know to get bagels. Stop by to try the softest chewiest most authentic bagels in ny. you won't regret it. & yes, like any other busy and popular shop you might have to wait, but it's all worth it in the end.
Jeannie Kim
Just moved to the area and I've been on searching for a solid bagel place. The cream cheese spread bagels, sandwiches, and coffee. The food hits the spot every time and the staff here are super friendly.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Egg Bacon Cheese, Egg & Cheese, Everything Bagel with Cream Cheese Doctored Up with Lox at Home, Butter or Jelly, Tuna Melt, Spread on a Bagel
Bob G
I've lived all over NYC and personally I think these are the best bagels in the area...by far. Are they a bit pricey? Yes, but I just spent a week in park slope Brooklyn where the prices were about the same if not higher for bagels half the size and half the quality. This place is constantly crowded so the naysayers here are very much the minority. Of course its inexcusable to be way overcharged but I've never experienced that. The staff could be a little more smiley but I'm not going to avoid this place based on that.
They touch money & charge cards and then prepare food wearing the same gloves --- and cash out the next customer & prepare more food (with the same gloves!). This is NOT sanitary. Everyone working here does this! Pluses: The bagels are good (minus the unsanitary preparation). Minuses: The pricing. The sky is the limit.
Stanislaus St. Marks
Yeah, you'll get "rolled" allright, 5 bucks for a bagel with cream cheese.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 4
Elizabeth Suzuki
These bagels are big & fluffy, and better thsn NYC bagels!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Christine Smith
If I could rate zero stars I would. I totally understand everything is expensive and has gone up in price. But when does it become highway robbery where you are cheating your customers? I stopped into the bagel store on my way to work to pick up some bagels for my Staff. I bought 1 dozen bagels, 5 muffins, 3 small cream cheeses, large OJ, 16oz soda and at first she tried to charge me $120 and change but I questions the astronomical amount and she rerung it and it came out to $90 and change the second time. I feel as if she was cheating me. I did some research and both emporium bagels in Harrison and Lenny’s bagels in Rye Brook would have charged me $68 for the exact same items. That’s a huge difference in price! I can say without a doubt I will never step foot back into this bagel shop and I will be sure to tell my friends and family to avoid it
Liz Dommermuth
it’s not the type of place you go to and get amazing customer service .. it’s the place you go to if you want the best bagel you’ve ever ate in this area .. it’s just like going into a NYC bagel shop .. fast paced … your in and your out… but damn it’s worth it for the bagels… they could tell me to F-off while handing me my bagel and i would still go back … as for the price of the food .. it’s RYE, NY people .. what do you expect they are selling bagels and have to cover their rent and make money. you pay a little more but you get a better bagel ! i highly recommend but i wouldn’t go in there with the expectation you are going to be treated with sweet hello’s and five star customer service.
Overpriced, bad service, owners don't get it - just focus on extracting as much price as possible. Significantly more expensive than any alternatives
Hand Rolled Bagels is a must-visit! The aroma of fresh, hand-rolled bagels is irresistible, offering the perfect mix of crunchy and soft with a great variety to choose from. It's my go-to spot in Rye for a quick, delicious bite.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Fantastic bagels, excellent service!
Did I spend $17 on 2 bagels and lox spread?Yes.Was it one of the best bagels I’ve ever had?Yes.Would I do it again?Definitely.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
best bagels ever!!! Definitely need to check it out if you’re nearby!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Great bagels
Food: 5
Service: 5
This place really has some of the best bagels I've ever had in the area. I had a lox bagel with cream cheese on an everything bagel and it was soft, fresh-tasting, and full of flavor. Definitely try this place out!
this is where all the locals know to get bagels. Stop by to try the softest chewiest most authentic bagels in ny. you won't regret it. & yes, like any other busy and popular shop you might have to wait, but it's all worth it in the end.
Just moved to the area and I've been on searching for a solid bagel place. The cream cheese spread bagels, sandwiches, and coffee. The food hits the spot every time and the staff here are super friendly.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Egg Bacon Cheese, Egg & Cheese, Everything Bagel with Cream Cheese Doctored Up with Lox at Home, Butter or Jelly, Tuna Melt, Spread on a Bagel
I've lived all over NYC and personally I think these are the best bagels in the area...by far. Are they a bit pricey? Yes, but I just spent a week in park slope Brooklyn where the prices were about the same if not higher for bagels half the size and half the quality. This place is constantly crowded so the naysayers here are very much the minority. Of course its inexcusable to be way overcharged but I've never experienced that. The staff could be a little more smiley but I'm not going to avoid this place based on that.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 5
Service: 3
Restaurantji Recommends
They touch money & charge cards and then prepare food wearing the same gloves --- and cash out the next customer & prepare more food (with the same gloves!). This is NOT sanitary. Everyone working here does this! Pluses: The bagels are good (minus the unsanitary preparation). Minuses: The pricing. The sky is the limit.
Yeah, you'll get "rolled" allright, 5 bucks for a bagel with cream cheese.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 4
These bagels are big & fluffy, and better thsn NYC bagels!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
If I could rate zero stars I would. I totally understand everything is expensive and has gone up in price. But when does it become highway robbery where you are cheating your customers? I stopped into the bagel store on my way to work to pick up some bagels for my Staff. I bought 1 dozen bagels, 5 muffins, 3 small cream cheeses, large OJ, 16oz soda and at first she tried to charge me $120 and change but I questions the astronomical amount and she rerung it and it came out to $90 and change the second time. I feel as if she was cheating me. I did some research and both emporium bagels in Harrison and Lenny’s bagels in Rye Brook would have charged me $68 for the exact same items. That’s a huge difference in price! I can say without a doubt I will never step foot back into this bagel shop and I will be sure to tell my friends and family to avoid it
it’s not the type of place you go to and get amazing customer service .. it’s the place you go to if you want the best bagel you’ve ever ate in this area .. it’s just like going into a NYC bagel shop .. fast paced … your in and your out… but damn it’s worth it for the bagels… they could tell me to F-off while handing me my bagel and i would still go back … as for the price of the food .. it’s RYE, NY people .. what do you expect they are selling bagels and have to cover their rent and make money. you pay a little more but you get a better bagel ! i highly recommend but i wouldn’t go in there with the expectation you are going to be treated with sweet hello’s and five star customer service.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 3