Charming pie shop / bakery. Found the flavored lattes to be really good as they make their own syrups. Got the pumpkin syrup with real pumpkin. Staff is very friendly too.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Mr F G And Mrs M S.
The pie here can be pretty pricey but it's worth it. The pumpkin pie that we got were absolutely delicious. The staff here were also friendly and polite. Great pie selection!
Emme K.
Loved how there is a place for quick pick up of pies. There is a good selection of your classic pies like apple and pumpkin, but there are also other kinds (berry, pecan, etc.). There are also quiches and savory pies that I'll have to try next time. Service was great and happy to find this place!
Sylvia Isler
Stopped in here to get a few pies. And the first thing I noticed was the lack of professionalism/rudeness of the cashier. The cashier was serving another customer and looked at me and said "know what you want?" - as opposed to something polite like "Hi, may I help you?". Body language and attitude galore. It went downhill from there.When I asked for a whole mixed berry pie. He said - Oh we don't have that. I was staring right at a sign that said 'Mixed Berry Pie" and there was...a mixed berry pie right next to the sign. He then claimed that they only are sold by the slice but he would make an exception (oh gee thanks).The counter was disorganized and filthy -open Tums bottle, used tissues, unfinished snacks, etc. Reminded me of a bodega.As for berry pie -- soggy crust, overly processed filling. My partner gagged on the undercooked, soggy vegetable quiche. Totally gross. If you consider yourself a fan or even a connoisseur of pies, take a pass on Noble Pies.Take a hard pass on Noble Pies - it's anything but.
AA A.
Lovely selection of use. The Irish sales fellow is charming! Darling shop. Easy arming. Great for dinner pies too! Beautifully decorated!
Iris B.
We tried Apple Crumb, peach, dirt pie, and cherry. I loved the cherry pie, my family loved the apple crumb and peach pies!
Carol D.
Excellent Apple crumb pie! I understand that the selection of savory pies is also great!
Sylvia
Stopped in here to get a few pies. And the first thing I noticed was the lack of professionalism/rudeness of the cashier. The cashier was serving another customer and looked at me and said "know what you want?" - as opposed to something polite like "Hi, may I help you?". Body language and attitude galore. It went downhill from there.When I asked for a whole mixed berry pie. He said - Oh we don't have that. I was staring right at a sign that said 'Mixed Berry Pie" and there was...a mixed berry pie right next to the sign. He then claimed that they only are sold by the slice but he would make an exception (oh gee thanks).The counter was disorganized and filthy -open Tums bottle, used tissues, unfinished snacks, etc. Reminded me of a bodega.As for berry pie -- soggy crust, overly processed filling. My partner gagged on the undercooked, soggy vegetable quiche. Totally gross. If you consider yourself a fan or even a connoisseur of pies, take a pass on Noble Pies.Take a hard pass on Noble Pies - it's anything but.
Sylvia I.
Stopped in here to get a few pies. And the first thing I noticed was the lack of professionalism/rudeness of the cashier. The cashier was serving another customer and looked at me and said "know what you want?" - as opposed to something polite like "Hi, may I help you?". Body language and attitude galore. It went downhill from there. When I asked for a whole mixed berry pie. He said - Oh we don't have that. I was staring right at a sign that said 'Mixed Berry Pie" and there was...a mixed berry pie right next to the sign. He then claimed that they only are sold by the slice but he would make an exception (oh gee thanks). The counter was disorganized and filthy -open Tums bottle, used tissues, unfinished snacks, etc. Reminded me of a bodega. As for berry pie -- soggy crust, overly processed filling. My partner gagged on the undercooked, soggy vegetable quiche. Totally gross. If you consider yourself a fan or even a connoisseur of pies, take a pass on Noble Pies. Take a hard pass on Noble Pies - it's anything but.
Gabby G.
I've enjoyed everything I've had there but really love the sweet pies. Cherry is my fav. Not overly sweet and buttery, flaky crust.
This cute corner spot on Purdy Ave- off Purchase St, in posh Rye, NY, bills itself as a bakery- but you can also get coffee and other non-coffee beverages such as Golden Milk, Chai, Hot Chocolate (don't know what it tastes like), etc. Specializing in pies, you can find savory and sweet types here. I thought I was safe by coming here at 9:10am- and since hours on their website, Google AND Yelp are listed as 8am, I was safe. Right? No. While the high schooler was pleasant, she was just opening up when I got here. She did triple-duty as she made my iced chai (their frother/machine 'wasn't hot yet', rang me up+bagged my items AND opened boxes to remove pies and fill up their respective sections in the glass covered counter. There was no way of knowing what's what except for the pie cards. I got a Vegetarian Quiche with goat and Swiss cheeses+ Sun-dried tomatoes+ onions+etc and a mini 'Dirt' Chocolate pie from the fridge. Best of the best? No. While I loved the puddin-y chocolate filling in my mini pie, the cream piping didn't give me that 'creamy', fresh whip cream taste- plus the crust didn't help. My Vegetable Quiche filling was also rich tasting- had a wonderful melty feel with the Swiss and goat cheeses when I popped it in the oven at home. But again, their crust doesn't flaunt that all-butter pie crust recipe and tastes oily.Butter isn't at the heart of their pies. The $29.50 I paid for the large Veggie Quiche was mind-boggling and the $16 for the Dirt Chocolate Pie wasn't worth it either. I can almost see why folks feel Noble Pies is firing on all cylinders- but to me, it's all about the butter- which isn't in their crust.
Natalie Gialluca-Purcell
Both sweet and savory pies are delicious! A bit pricey but totally worth it! The egg savory pies are the best I’ve ever had and the peanut butter cupwas divine.
Meg Rosenberg
I went peach picking and bumped into Noble Pies. I had sampled their pies at the farmer’s market near my home and was thrilled to visit their brick and mortar store! I had a slice of the great “Will you marry me Cherry Pie” with crumb topping. The coffee machine wasn’t working and the person behind the counter kindly made a French press cup just for me! And it had real cream!! I took away a quiche and a slice of the cherry pie for my daughter. It’s hard to find good pie these days, but these people have it. Also love their chicken pot pie and their pecan pie. The pie disappeared before I could take its picture but the pie themed decor in the shop is homey.
Deborah Laureano
Went in trying to find a lemon meringue. Got something just as delicious, their lime pie! Gentleman there was very helpful. Will be back!
Charming pie shop / bakery. Found the flavored lattes to be really good as they make their own syrups. Got the pumpkin syrup with real pumpkin. Staff is very friendly too.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The pie here can be pretty pricey but it's worth it. The pumpkin pie that we got were absolutely delicious. The staff here were also friendly and polite. Great pie selection!
Loved how there is a place for quick pick up of pies. There is a good selection of your classic pies like apple and pumpkin, but there are also other kinds (berry, pecan, etc.). There are also quiches and savory pies that I'll have to try next time. Service was great and happy to find this place!
Stopped in here to get a few pies. And the first thing I noticed was the lack of professionalism/rudeness of the cashier. The cashier was serving another customer and looked at me and said "know what you want?" - as opposed to something polite like "Hi, may I help you?". Body language and attitude galore. It went downhill from there.When I asked for a whole mixed berry pie. He said - Oh we don't have that. I was staring right at a sign that said 'Mixed Berry Pie" and there was...a mixed berry pie right next to the sign. He then claimed that they only are sold by the slice but he would make an exception (oh gee thanks).The counter was disorganized and filthy -open Tums bottle, used tissues, unfinished snacks, etc. Reminded me of a bodega.As for berry pie -- soggy crust, overly processed filling. My partner gagged on the undercooked, soggy vegetable quiche. Totally gross. If you consider yourself a fan or even a connoisseur of pies, take a pass on Noble Pies.Take a hard pass on Noble Pies - it's anything but.
Lovely selection of use. The Irish sales fellow is charming! Darling shop. Easy arming. Great for dinner pies too! Beautifully decorated!
We tried Apple Crumb, peach, dirt pie, and cherry. I loved the cherry pie, my family loved the apple crumb and peach pies!
Excellent Apple crumb pie! I understand that the selection of savory pies is also great!
Stopped in here to get a few pies. And the first thing I noticed was the lack of professionalism/rudeness of the cashier. The cashier was serving another customer and looked at me and said "know what you want?" - as opposed to something polite like "Hi, may I help you?". Body language and attitude galore. It went downhill from there.When I asked for a whole mixed berry pie. He said - Oh we don't have that. I was staring right at a sign that said 'Mixed Berry Pie" and there was...a mixed berry pie right next to the sign. He then claimed that they only are sold by the slice but he would make an exception (oh gee thanks).The counter was disorganized and filthy -open Tums bottle, used tissues, unfinished snacks, etc. Reminded me of a bodega.As for berry pie -- soggy crust, overly processed filling. My partner gagged on the undercooked, soggy vegetable quiche. Totally gross. If you consider yourself a fan or even a connoisseur of pies, take a pass on Noble Pies.Take a hard pass on Noble Pies - it's anything but.
Stopped in here to get a few pies. And the first thing I noticed was the lack of professionalism/rudeness of the cashier. The cashier was serving another customer and looked at me and said "know what you want?" - as opposed to something polite like "Hi, may I help you?". Body language and attitude galore. It went downhill from there. When I asked for a whole mixed berry pie. He said - Oh we don't have that. I was staring right at a sign that said 'Mixed Berry Pie" and there was...a mixed berry pie right next to the sign. He then claimed that they only are sold by the slice but he would make an exception (oh gee thanks). The counter was disorganized and filthy -open Tums bottle, used tissues, unfinished snacks, etc. Reminded me of a bodega. As for berry pie -- soggy crust, overly processed filling. My partner gagged on the undercooked, soggy vegetable quiche. Totally gross. If you consider yourself a fan or even a connoisseur of pies, take a pass on Noble Pies. Take a hard pass on Noble Pies - it's anything but.
I've enjoyed everything I've had there but really love the sweet pies. Cherry is my fav. Not overly sweet and buttery, flaky crust.
Restaurantji Recommends
This cute corner spot on Purdy Ave- off Purchase St, in posh Rye, NY, bills itself as a bakery- but you can also get coffee and other non-coffee beverages such as Golden Milk, Chai, Hot Chocolate (don't know what it tastes like), etc. Specializing in pies, you can find savory and sweet types here. I thought I was safe by coming here at 9:10am- and since hours on their website, Google AND Yelp are listed as 8am, I was safe. Right? No. While the high schooler was pleasant, she was just opening up when I got here. She did triple-duty as she made my iced chai (their frother/machine 'wasn't hot yet', rang me up+bagged my items AND opened boxes to remove pies and fill up their respective sections in the glass covered counter. There was no way of knowing what's what except for the pie cards. I got a Vegetarian Quiche with goat and Swiss cheeses+ Sun-dried tomatoes+ onions+etc and a mini 'Dirt' Chocolate pie from the fridge. Best of the best? No. While I loved the puddin-y chocolate filling in my mini pie, the cream piping didn't give me that 'creamy', fresh whip cream taste- plus the crust didn't help. My Vegetable Quiche filling was also rich tasting- had a wonderful melty feel with the Swiss and goat cheeses when I popped it in the oven at home. But again, their crust doesn't flaunt that all-butter pie crust recipe and tastes oily.Butter isn't at the heart of their pies. The $29.50 I paid for the large Veggie Quiche was mind-boggling and the $16 for the Dirt Chocolate Pie wasn't worth it either. I can almost see why folks feel Noble Pies is firing on all cylinders- but to me, it's all about the butter- which isn't in their crust.
Both sweet and savory pies are delicious! A bit pricey but totally worth it! The egg savory pies are the best I’ve ever had and the peanut butter cupwas divine.
I went peach picking and bumped into Noble Pies. I had sampled their pies at the farmer’s market near my home and was thrilled to visit their brick and mortar store! I had a slice of the great “Will you marry me Cherry Pie” with crumb topping. The coffee machine wasn’t working and the person behind the counter kindly made a French press cup just for me! And it had real cream!! I took away a quiche and a slice of the cherry pie for my daughter. It’s hard to find good pie these days, but these people have it. Also love their chicken pot pie and their pecan pie. The pie disappeared before I could take its picture but the pie themed decor in the shop is homey.
Went in trying to find a lemon meringue. Got something just as delicious, their lime pie! Gentleman there was very helpful. Will be back!
We travel just for the chicken pot pie!