Ordered through GrubHub. Specified in the comments to not put olives in the chicken riggies due to a severe allergy. Got my food and it was full of olives. I did get my money back, however the greens that I got were soggy and disgusting. I've tried this place multiple times and I am all about giving restaurants another chance. The price was 40 dollars for the riggies, greens and a slice of cheesecake that wouldn't fill up a toddler. I will absolutely never order from here again.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 3
Paul Paterakis
Pizza.Food/Value: AService/Wait Time: ADecor/Environment: AParking: B (Shared Parking Lot)Cash/Credit Cards: Yes*Photos by meFollow me on Instagram: @paulpaterakisTip me in Bitcoin: 14hzNnkbM5SKrUcLoxn3Vto1mx4BkTLdV9
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Lydia Vigna
Delicious pizza slices, and I've been coming here for years.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Lisa A.
Food was terrible. Sicilian pizza was as thick as a mattress, buffalo tenders were tiny nuggets with no flavor (we got medium), and everything else was bad. Will not go back.
Kelly O.
I base my star rating entirely on their house pizza, which is Utica style, and completely delicious. Their regular pizza is just okay.
Matt D.
Really wanted to like this place as there's not many real pizza options in Glenville aside from Pizza Works.Ordered a Sicilian pie,terrible little to no sauce or salt present.Poor quality ingredients just thrown together with no real purpose or intention. Sad.
Kate
Good pizza. Huge slices. Got 4 slices and 2 drinks for $16, good prices. A little greasy. Crust was very hard which is why it missed out on getting 5 stars. Would recommend
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Christa Lennen
Clean always clean. Open and well lit! Always greeted with a smile. Always have time to think about my order and not pushed to hurry. Food is worth the price, quantity and quality for the right price. Always right temp!
Unfortunately there was plastic trash mixed in the steak salad. I sent a message to restaurant before posting this review but received no response. Eat there at your own risk.
Robert Heikaus
Pizza is always good here. the slices are huge. Never had a meal that required service so can’t rate it. Love getting a couple slices here on a weekend with the kids.
Order the Utica style pizza was terrible. Swimming in a bad vodka type sauce and tasted awful. It could be on me that I ordered that. So maybe try the New York style. Service was fine order on line and it was ready when they said.
Paul Henry Lincoln
Food's great, nice atmosphere inside the restaurant but the delivery girl was rude when we ordered delivery, think her name was Sarah. We tipped her 20% and she acted as if we were cheap for not giving her more.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 1
Recommended dishes: Cheese Pizza, Chicken Wings
The Peoples Critic C.
Good service A little dreary decor Slices seemed like they were made a day earlier Too many croutons in salads
Rebecca Myers
The Pizza is delicious, nice and light with a crisp crunch. The waitress even gave us a lid for a sauce we particularly liked and joked with our 3 year old. Clean, nice atmosphere, I highly recommend.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cheese Pizza
G Palmatier
Their pizza quality is inconsistent: sometimes good, sometimes terrible.We ordered from them via GrubHub because Slice does their own delivery. Knowing pizza on a Friday night is busy, I placed our order at 4:45pm. At 6:00pm still no delivery, so I called to see what was going on. I was told it “just left with a girl” and it would be about 30 minutes. I only live 10 minutes away tops, but they told me they “had other deliveries”When the delivery person finally got to my house it was 6:35pm. She hands me our pizza, but no chicken tenders. I asked where the chicken tenders were, and she said that was all the gave her.I called the restaurant and takled to the manager who said “GrubHub already have you a refund, so you’re not getting any chicken tenders”! I was like “that’s what I paid for!!”, but she said “I don’t care, you got a refund anyway”. That was the last time we ever ordered from them. Despicable customer service!
Ordered through GrubHub. Specified in the comments to not put olives in the chicken riggies due to a severe allergy. Got my food and it was full of olives. I did get my money back, however the greens that I got were soggy and disgusting. I've tried this place multiple times and I am all about giving restaurants another chance. The price was 40 dollars for the riggies, greens and a slice of cheesecake that wouldn't fill up a toddler. I will absolutely never order from here again.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 3
Pizza.Food/Value: AService/Wait Time: ADecor/Environment: AParking: B (Shared Parking Lot)Cash/Credit Cards: Yes*Photos by meFollow me on Instagram: @paulpaterakisTip me in Bitcoin: 14hzNnkbM5SKrUcLoxn3Vto1mx4BkTLdV9
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Delicious pizza slices, and I've been coming here for years.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Food was terrible. Sicilian pizza was as thick as a mattress, buffalo tenders were tiny nuggets with no flavor (we got medium), and everything else was bad. Will not go back.
I base my star rating entirely on their house pizza, which is Utica style, and completely delicious. Their regular pizza is just okay.
Really wanted to like this place as there's not many real pizza options in Glenville aside from Pizza Works.Ordered a Sicilian pie,terrible little to no sauce or salt present.Poor quality ingredients just thrown together with no real purpose or intention. Sad.
Good pizza. Huge slices. Got 4 slices and 2 drinks for $16, good prices. A little greasy. Crust was very hard which is why it missed out on getting 5 stars. Would recommend
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Clean always clean. Open and well lit! Always greeted with a smile. Always have time to think about my order and not pushed to hurry. Food is worth the price, quantity and quality for the right price. Always right temp!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Wings, Cheese Pizza, Pepperoni Pizza
Unfortunately there was plastic trash mixed in the steak salad. I sent a message to restaurant before posting this review but received no response. Eat there at your own risk.
Pizza is always good here. the slices are huge. Never had a meal that required service so can’t rate it. Love getting a couple slices here on a weekend with the kids.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizza Display, Cheese Pizza, Pepperoni Pizza
Restaurantji Recommends
Order the Utica style pizza was terrible. Swimming in a bad vodka type sauce and tasted awful. It could be on me that I ordered that. So maybe try the New York style. Service was fine order on line and it was ready when they said.
Food's great, nice atmosphere inside the restaurant but the delivery girl was rude when we ordered delivery, think her name was Sarah. We tipped her 20% and she acted as if we were cheap for not giving her more.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 1
Recommended dishes: Cheese Pizza, Chicken Wings
Good service A little dreary decor Slices seemed like they were made a day earlier Too many croutons in salads
The Pizza is delicious, nice and light with a crisp crunch. The waitress even gave us a lid for a sauce we particularly liked and joked with our 3 year old. Clean, nice atmosphere, I highly recommend.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cheese Pizza
Their pizza quality is inconsistent: sometimes good, sometimes terrible.We ordered from them via GrubHub because Slice does their own delivery. Knowing pizza on a Friday night is busy, I placed our order at 4:45pm. At 6:00pm still no delivery, so I called to see what was going on. I was told it “just left with a girl” and it would be about 30 minutes. I only live 10 minutes away tops, but they told me they “had other deliveries”When the delivery person finally got to my house it was 6:35pm. She hands me our pizza, but no chicken tenders. I asked where the chicken tenders were, and she said that was all the gave her.I called the restaurant and takled to the manager who said “GrubHub already have you a refund, so you’re not getting any chicken tenders”! I was like “that’s what I paid for!!”, but she said “I don’t care, you got a refund anyway”. That was the last time we ever ordered from them. Despicable customer service!
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 3
Service: 1