Sorry but if I can mold my pizza dough into any shape I please after it’s been “cooked” and delivered to me that is not ok. And no this is not a photo of the cheese. Two stars only because the manager or owner whoever I spoke to on the phone sent a new one and a comp dessert (which honestly is the least he can do on a $70 order of 2 pies) but if he is reading this, try not to be so defensive to the ones letting you know of YOUR mistake! Even if you’ve “only heard this twice in 10 years” that is twice too many nor should I as a paying customer be made to feel accused of lying. Sent this one back with the driver just to prove my point. And by the way this is not even the first time I’ve had this problem at Gino’s Seaford. Not coming back here again thanks to his arrogant attitude. Humility goes a long way in business
Todd Ryan
Warning: Terrible food quality and service recently. (Wasn’t very good before this either really) With 281 reviews you can probably tell (much like other businesses do they are probably having staff submit reviews upon hiring) starting to see why the owner sold to that kid all those years ago. Prices and food better elsewhere. Barstool Pizza’s review of this place is accurate “It’s alright if you’re hungry”
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
elena f
Best Customer Service and great food!
Steven Damiano
Got a buffalo chicken pizza and half dozen garlic knots. Was really looking forward to trying this place but unfortunately I was catfished by instagram and Dave portnoy.Its a shame because the pie did have potential, however it was dry as all hell. Buffalo chicken itself was tasty, but again dry. Pizza had no kind of sauce on it whatsoever. It was just bread, cheese and chicken. No ranch drizzle, no sauce base.One and done for me. Not worth the $38 price tag, I’d rather spend my hard earned money at Umberto’s.
Estef R
Disgusting pizza I don’t know how they call themselves a pizzeria. Unflavored and greaty pizzas.
Food: 1
Jonathan G.
Food is good, service is good, just a little over priced on certain items. Two slices snd 6 knots almost $12 is just taking advantage of people ... nice local spot I over priced
sophia nauth
I went there last Saturday night and the waiter was awesome , very friendly, all smiles and because of him I will definitely go back , service is what makes one feel very comfortable, Food was Fantastic also.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Loaded Garlic Knots
A.S.
Ginos is the best pizza in seaford! I grew up on Tarrallos, so I know good pizza! They also have the most delicious soups! The chicken escarole and bean is out of this world! Their catering is always on point as well! Definitely worth every penny and calorie!
Excellent Pizza made by a very professional and friendly staff. Sliced sausage like I like it and perfect leopard skinning in the crust. Busy place call early!!! In my top ten on LI for sure!
Anthony Adri Vineo-Temule
Fantastic service, friendly but not annoying! I hate yappers when I'm hungry so I like the get and go. Everything fast and smooth. Come from New york Italian family. Grew up moved around in the Bronx, Brooklyn and Staten Island before coming to Long Island. David portnoy has this place at an 8.0 but I would say quality wise is not more than above average . This doesn't even come close to borough style slice and is lower on the list for long island for me. You'll get your food fast. It's edible and inoffensive. The sauce saves it. 6.5/10
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 1
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizza Slice
Ashley A.
Came here because I saw a specific pizza on Instagram that I needed to try. It did not disappoint!! The cauliflower pizza crust with ricotta, pepperoni and hot honey is SO good. Their mozzarella sticks are also great. Staff was very friendly as well
Jo M.
Great pizza all of the time never disappoints We qualify take out here a lot the kids love it
Vincent M.
I've been wanting to try Gino's of Seaford since my high school days, and I finally had the chance today. I placed an order on Uber Eats, and since I live only 6 minutes away from Gino's, my meal arrived at my home in about 25 minutes, which, in my opinion, is amazing. I ordered five items: Chicken Parmigiana, baked clams, a regular cheese pizzetta, garlic knots with vodka sauce, and buffalo wings with BBQ sauce as the wing sauce. First, I savored the Chicken Parmigiana, which had a beautiful taste; the chicken was tender and delicious, and the sauce was perfect. Next up were the baked clams, which were quite delicious, but in my opinion, the breading was slightly mushy. The vodka sauce on the garlic knots was one of the best I've had in a long time, but unfortunately, the sauce made the knots mushy and overly saucy, which affected my overall experience. The pizzetta was very good with a tasty sauce, though a bit salty for my liking. I would definitely return for their pizza and dishes featuring vodka sauce. Everything else was decent. I appreciate that Gino's is innovative and creates new dish ideas to set their restaurant apart, which is something I admire about restaurants. I would certainly go back to try their new creative dishes in the future.
Sorry but if I can mold my pizza dough into any shape I please after it’s been “cooked” and delivered to me that is not ok. And no this is not a photo of the cheese. Two stars only because the manager or owner whoever I spoke to on the phone sent a new one and a comp dessert (which honestly is the least he can do on a $70 order of 2 pies) but if he is reading this, try not to be so defensive to the ones letting you know of YOUR mistake! Even if you’ve “only heard this twice in 10 years” that is twice too many nor should I as a paying customer be made to feel accused of lying. Sent this one back with the driver just to prove my point. And by the way this is not even the first time I’ve had this problem at Gino’s Seaford. Not coming back here again thanks to his arrogant attitude. Humility goes a long way in business
Warning: Terrible food quality and service recently. (Wasn’t very good before this either really) With 281 reviews you can probably tell (much like other businesses do they are probably having staff submit reviews upon hiring) starting to see why the owner sold to that kid all those years ago. Prices and food better elsewhere. Barstool Pizza’s review of this place is accurate “It’s alright if you’re hungry”
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Best Customer Service and great food!
Got a buffalo chicken pizza and half dozen garlic knots. Was really looking forward to trying this place but unfortunately I was catfished by instagram and Dave portnoy.Its a shame because the pie did have potential, however it was dry as all hell. Buffalo chicken itself was tasty, but again dry. Pizza had no kind of sauce on it whatsoever. It was just bread, cheese and chicken. No ranch drizzle, no sauce base.One and done for me. Not worth the $38 price tag, I’d rather spend my hard earned money at Umberto’s.
Disgusting pizza I don’t know how they call themselves a pizzeria. Unflavored and greaty pizzas.
Food: 1
Food is good, service is good, just a little over priced on certain items. Two slices snd 6 knots almost $12 is just taking advantage of people ... nice local spot I over priced
I went there last Saturday night and the waiter was awesome , very friendly, all smiles and because of him I will definitely go back , service is what makes one feel very comfortable, Food was Fantastic also.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Loaded Garlic Knots
Ginos is the best pizza in seaford! I grew up on Tarrallos, so I know good pizza! They also have the most delicious soups! The chicken escarole and bean is out of this world! Their catering is always on point as well! Definitely worth every penny and calorie!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Grandma, Chicken Roll, Chicken Parm, Buffalo Chicken Pizza
Love this place. We were delighted to see the dining room reopened. The food and service were fantastic! Highly recommend!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Horrible slice of regular pizza under cooked dough all mozzarella no sauce …
Restaurantji Recommends
Excellent Pizza made by a very professional and friendly staff. Sliced sausage like I like it and perfect leopard skinning in the crust. Busy place call early!!! In my top ten on LI for sure!
Fantastic service, friendly but not annoying! I hate yappers when I'm hungry so I like the get and go. Everything fast and smooth. Come from New york Italian family. Grew up moved around in the Bronx, Brooklyn and Staten Island before coming to Long Island. David portnoy has this place at an 8.0 but I would say quality wise is not more than above average . This doesn't even come close to borough style slice and is lower on the list for long island for me. You'll get your food fast. It's edible and inoffensive. The sauce saves it. 6.5/10
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 1
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizza Slice
Came here because I saw a specific pizza on Instagram that I needed to try. It did not disappoint!! The cauliflower pizza crust with ricotta, pepperoni and hot honey is SO good. Their mozzarella sticks are also great. Staff was very friendly as well
Great pizza all of the time never disappoints We qualify take out here a lot the kids love it
I've been wanting to try Gino's of Seaford since my high school days, and I finally had the chance today. I placed an order on Uber Eats, and since I live only 6 minutes away from Gino's, my meal arrived at my home in about 25 minutes, which, in my opinion, is amazing. I ordered five items: Chicken Parmigiana, baked clams, a regular cheese pizzetta, garlic knots with vodka sauce, and buffalo wings with BBQ sauce as the wing sauce. First, I savored the Chicken Parmigiana, which had a beautiful taste; the chicken was tender and delicious, and the sauce was perfect. Next up were the baked clams, which were quite delicious, but in my opinion, the breading was slightly mushy. The vodka sauce on the garlic knots was one of the best I've had in a long time, but unfortunately, the sauce made the knots mushy and overly saucy, which affected my overall experience. The pizzetta was very good with a tasty sauce, though a bit salty for my liking. I would definitely return for their pizza and dishes featuring vodka sauce. Everything else was decent. I appreciate that Gino's is innovative and creates new dish ideas to set their restaurant apart, which is something I admire about restaurants. I would certainly go back to try their new creative dishes in the future.