Got stuck at walmart decided to grab some food.This place has an amazing atmosphere with very good service and food. Sarah did outstanding job at serving.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
David Brooks
Nice place, food was great had the Mardi Gras special shrimp and sausage gumbo.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Skye G.
The food was so good will definitely come back :) my boyfriend and I had their ribs and they were so juicy. Mac and cheese was delicious and their veggies were on point.
taylor snyder
Was very disappointed with the experience, right away it was immediately a rush. The waitress barely got to our table I couldn’t even express how bad the food was because she never returned I did ask the “manager” to send her and when she came back I explained the issues and was offered free desert…. To a meal that was still on the table. The coupe sitting behind us didn’t have menus and silverware and she said that isn’t her job she apologizes , very disappointed everything is your job and not to put on another staff, you work as a team. We both looked at each other as if we thought the same thing. “That isn’t my job” well then you probably shouldn’t be working where there is work to be done. Not to mention the side salad came out 15 mins later my partners soup (both appetizers) and RIGHT after the meals came out. Someone did come out to apologize but how is that a fair dining experience? Soggy bread warm coleslaw recooked fries? Photo is the BREADLESS French onion soup and the “margarita” never seen ones served with a lemon and orange even tho the menu says SALT&LIME
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
William Lounsbury
Started with a margarita, they forgot the salt on the rim. The French onion soup was the worst I’ve had and came out at the same time as my meal. I asked for tenderloin and coconut shrimp with mash potatoes. What I got was prime rib with a baked potato because they were out of tenderloin. Best part of the meal was the potato and they couldn’t even mash it. My suggestion, go to the bulls head in. Same price but they serve good food on time. Fish fry was on soggy bread and the Cole slaw was warm, French fries tasted like they were cold and recooked again. Waitress took our order and never came back. Was offered free desert for the inconvenience so I asked the manager he did take $20 off but it was a very disappointing experience to say the LEAST
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Elizabeth A.
I went on January 20 to celebrate my birthday. I had never been before. Probably the best meal I've had in years. Lately, I don't like to dine out because it's expensive and the food is never worth what I've spent but this place is a game changer. I had the special "pot roast"- Just amazing and cooked to perfection. I will be back and the Fancy Farmer will be highly recommended!
Teresa Gorman
Beautiful place and our waitress was awesome!! My meal was disappointing but the dessert was excellent. The sweet potato fries were not made there but the sauce was good. The salad had some mushy tomatoes and mushy mandarin orange slices, but the onions and walnuts were good. The dressing was not homemade.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 2
Service: 5
michael
Nice place nice atmosphere food communication and menu board in regards to specials are not what they come out to the table.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Bacon Bourbon Burger
Harold Hagadorn
My wife and I went to the Fancy Farmer with high expectations and we were not disappointed. The food was delicious, the atmosphere was fantastic, and the staff was terrific. It is sometimes difficult to meet high expectations but this place did so flawlessly. We will be back !!
Best prime rib I ever had! The restaurant is wonderful, staff were great and friendly. What a fantastic addition to Sharon Springs NY
Kim Marie Papp
The best prime rib I have ever had!!! The place is beautiful and welcoming! Staff was so nice. John had the chicken, he said it was fantastic. What a great addition to Sharon Spring. We will definitely be back!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Jeff Butler
Place was fantastic. Good atmosphere, great food. We had a large party with small children and chaos, and they were patient and accommodating. Awesome Ribeye steak. Thank you!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
jessica wilson
The place is beautiful and the service was great! The name “Fancy Farmer” and the atmosphere set my expectations high. The best part about the whole meal was the bread bowl. The lobster bisque taste like cheese whiz very thick with no natural, homemade ingredient, taste. The second course, the salad. The salad was bagged and salad dressing was bottled. The salad laid flat on the plate. It was a horrible presentation. I ordered the scallop special. My plate came out wet from the steamed vegetables, with the flavor that ran into the rest of my entrée. The scallops had no sear and the mashed potatoes were mediocre. They also didn’t remove the seeds from the zucchini and yellow squash, which would eliminate some of the wetness in the vegetables and would allow them to brown. My husband ordered the salmon that was over cooked also with no sear. Over all just a big disappointment. The place is a fraud.
Atmosphere: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Scallops
Michael Oconnell
I got there at 5:15 [ Friday evening ] and there was only one other table in there, but still was unable to get out of there before 7:00. I had the prime rib special which by the time it came out, the vegetables very cold, potatoes were lukewarm . the young girl waitress is amazing she runs a little fanny off and unfortunately we did not have her, ours, just took our order and that was about it. Never came back for another drink order, so they lost out on another drink. Brought us our check and never asked if we wanted to have dessert. So she lost on yet another upcharge..For the positive!! they Do have plenty of parking and I like the insides, it is a real cool farmer theme. And there is Stewart's across the street, so when you do not get dessert, you can go there.. maybe a 3rd time is a charm??Note,, it was a full house by 7pm..
Great food, great service and friendly staff
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Got stuck at walmart decided to grab some food.This place has an amazing atmosphere with very good service and food. Sarah did outstanding job at serving.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Nice place, food was great had the Mardi Gras special shrimp and sausage gumbo.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The food was so good will definitely come back :) my boyfriend and I had their ribs and they were so juicy. Mac and cheese was delicious and their veggies were on point.
Was very disappointed with the experience, right away it was immediately a rush. The waitress barely got to our table I couldn’t even express how bad the food was because she never returned I did ask the “manager” to send her and when she came back I explained the issues and was offered free desert…. To a meal that was still on the table. The coupe sitting behind us didn’t have menus and silverware and she said that isn’t her job she apologizes , very disappointed everything is your job and not to put on another staff, you work as a team. We both looked at each other as if we thought the same thing. “That isn’t my job” well then you probably shouldn’t be working where there is work to be done. Not to mention the side salad came out 15 mins later my partners soup (both appetizers) and RIGHT after the meals came out. Someone did come out to apologize but how is that a fair dining experience? Soggy bread warm coleslaw recooked fries? Photo is the BREADLESS French onion soup and the “margarita” never seen ones served with a lemon and orange even tho the menu says SALT&LIME
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Started with a margarita, they forgot the salt on the rim. The French onion soup was the worst I’ve had and came out at the same time as my meal. I asked for tenderloin and coconut shrimp with mash potatoes. What I got was prime rib with a baked potato because they were out of tenderloin. Best part of the meal was the potato and they couldn’t even mash it. My suggestion, go to the bulls head in. Same price but they serve good food on time. Fish fry was on soggy bread and the Cole slaw was warm, French fries tasted like they were cold and recooked again. Waitress took our order and never came back. Was offered free desert for the inconvenience so I asked the manager he did take $20 off but it was a very disappointing experience to say the LEAST
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
I went on January 20 to celebrate my birthday. I had never been before. Probably the best meal I've had in years. Lately, I don't like to dine out because it's expensive and the food is never worth what I've spent but this place is a game changer. I had the special "pot roast"- Just amazing and cooked to perfection. I will be back and the Fancy Farmer will be highly recommended!
Beautiful place and our waitress was awesome!! My meal was disappointing but the dessert was excellent. The sweet potato fries were not made there but the sauce was good. The salad had some mushy tomatoes and mushy mandarin orange slices, but the onions and walnuts were good. The dressing was not homemade.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 2
Service: 5
Nice place nice atmosphere food communication and menu board in regards to specials are not what they come out to the table.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Bacon Bourbon Burger
My wife and I went to the Fancy Farmer with high expectations and we were not disappointed. The food was delicious, the atmosphere was fantastic, and the staff was terrific. It is sometimes difficult to meet high expectations but this place did so flawlessly. We will be back !!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
Best prime rib I ever had! The restaurant is wonderful, staff were great and friendly. What a fantastic addition to Sharon Springs NY
The best prime rib I have ever had!!! The place is beautiful and welcoming! Staff was so nice. John had the chicken, he said it was fantastic. What a great addition to Sharon Spring. We will definitely be back!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Place was fantastic. Good atmosphere, great food. We had a large party with small children and chaos, and they were patient and accommodating. Awesome Ribeye steak. Thank you!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The place is beautiful and the service was great! The name “Fancy Farmer” and the atmosphere set my expectations high. The best part about the whole meal was the bread bowl. The lobster bisque taste like cheese whiz very thick with no natural, homemade ingredient, taste. The second course, the salad. The salad was bagged and salad dressing was bottled. The salad laid flat on the plate. It was a horrible presentation. I ordered the scallop special. My plate came out wet from the steamed vegetables, with the flavor that ran into the rest of my entrée. The scallops had no sear and the mashed potatoes were mediocre. They also didn’t remove the seeds from the zucchini and yellow squash, which would eliminate some of the wetness in the vegetables and would allow them to brown. My husband ordered the salmon that was over cooked also with no sear. Over all just a big disappointment. The place is a fraud.
Atmosphere: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Scallops
I got there at 5:15 [ Friday evening ] and there was only one other table in there, but still was unable to get out of there before 7:00. I had the prime rib special which by the time it came out, the vegetables very cold, potatoes were lukewarm . the young girl waitress is amazing she runs a little fanny off and unfortunately we did not have her, ours, just took our order and that was about it. Never came back for another drink order, so they lost out on another drink. Brought us our check and never asked if we wanted to have dessert. So she lost on yet another upcharge..For the positive!! they Do have plenty of parking and I like the insides, it is a real cool farmer theme. And there is Stewart's across the street, so when you do not get dessert, you can go there.. maybe a 3rd time is a charm??Note,, it was a full house by 7pm..
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 3
Service: 2