Napoli's Pizzeria

2920 US-6, Slate Hill
(845) 355-6161

Recent Reviews

Amy Marie

WOW!! I pass this place all the time omw back from Middletown to Sussex and kept saying I would stop and get a pie. I finally did and their pizza is PHENOMENAL. I got a large pepperoni and sausage. Pizza was fresh, sauce was filled with flavor, cheese was perfect and bubbly and the crust had the perfect crunch. Absolutely amazing. Friendly staff too. Give them a try!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Tina Miller

Never again! Pizza was very salty. Tasteless crust. You can keep the garlic knots. Rip off.

Sean O'connor

Pretty mediocre, At best.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 2

Service: 1

Daniel Volpe

Some of the best pizza around, with friendly staff and quick service. A great place for a slice or a meal.

Barbara Harriman

Wheelchair accessibility: There were handicapped spots that were easily accessible by wheelchair mobile individuals.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza N Pin Wheel

Francesca Reindel

Napoli's is our go to for great Italian comfort food! From classics like baked ziti and pizza, to the innovative twist on a garlic knot - the Warrior Knot sandwich - everything was delicious. I would recommend for catering as well - everything was well packaged and organized.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Roberta R.

Napoli's is the best! I was at a party catered by Napoli's last night and everything was amazing! The Warrior Knots far exceeded my expectations which were already super high! I had half of a Chicken Parmigiana and Eggplant Parmigiana and they were both scrumptious! (I took home a Meatball and a Shrimp Warrior Knot for dinner tonight!) The Chicken Francese was way better than many I have had in fancy Italian restaurants. I don't know how Napoli's does it! And as a pasta lover the Penne Vodka and Baked Ziti were delicious!! The presentation was beautiful and the salad was fresh, delicious and looked like a work of art! I was so full that I didn't even remember to have their famous pizza. Well, next time! With Napoli's here there is no need to cook or stress about having a holiday party or even a simple family dinner! Just call them and they will take care of everything with great food and wonderful, personal customer service!

Lizzy Colon

We ordered a sicilian supreme pizza, it was so hard and burnt we could barely bite through it, no suace, and had a long black hair baked into the crust. $30 for 1 pie and couldn't even eat

Food: 1

Ken L.

Stopped in on our way home from northern Jersey. It's kind of an oasis in the middle of nowhere. Lots of different pizzas to try , you can buy by the slice. Prices are reasonable. There is plenty of private lot parking and they have two covered tables outside where you can eat. Would stop again if traveling through the area.

Kathy W.

Napoli's is great. We get pizza from them a lot. Prices are reasonable and they are less than a mile away. I love stacking up on my coupons to get a free pie after purchasing ten pies.

Matthew Ramsay

Delicious food! Amazing pizza!! The best food and people !! Go Warriors!!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Jay M.

Nice pizza, decent selection of food good wings, try mango jabinaro habanero wings, just the right amount of hot

Bennie King

$27.50 for a large margaritas pizza !! Not even a large pie with all the toppings cost that much ! I got screwed ! Please check your menu online it’s very hard to read your prices. Again even a meat lovers pizza looks to be less than $27.50 . ?

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 4

Service: 1

Brenda Condon

Margherita pizza was disgraceful.Basil was wilted and dry.

Food: 1

Service: 4

Wanda G.

Best baked clams I've ever had. They know how to cook them, and if you've never had them anywhere else, have them here. Their pizza and Stromboli's and calzones are fabulous as well.

Load More