First time trying Anthony’s. I must say amazing experience all around. The girl at the front register was so nice, the sandwich making guy in the back(who I thought was Anthony himself but I didn’t know) good personality. The inside looks spotless, great decor, and felt very cool inside.I got one of Thursday specials which is the Porchetta with the crispy skin! It comes with broccoli rabe and fresh smoked mozzarella. I must say this might be the best pork sandwich I’ve ever eaten.Great crunch to the skin, very flavorful, the broccoli rabe is a great complement and the mozz is also a great addition. Best sandwich on Staten Island.We also tried the rice ball with and without meat, and the potato croquettes. Might be best on the island. So fresh!!I can’t wait to go back to try the others(except Thursday because Thursdays you know what I’m getting!!!)Anthony you out did yourself!!My score10 out of 10
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Anthony Garuccio
From 1 anthony to another the godfather was ? the maria was good also. We will be back!
robert carter
Awesome sandwiches, good prices
Thomas Rossi
Outstanding! Delicious meatballs, crunchy bread! All fresh food. Generous portions. Friendly service. A true family business.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Chaz Ku
So far I’m working my way through the menu and everything has been great. Pastrami was really good worth the wait. Friendly atmosphere and excellent service glad this place is in my neighborhood
Gary DeBiase
A hole in the wall with fantastic food! Wednesday is pastrami day, Thursday is porchetta day both are hand crafted and amazing! ?
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Do It for Johnny, Anthony's, Ella's Chick-N Sandwhich
michael loprete
Had the pastrami for the first time and it was fantastic this was on a Wednesday,great conversation friendly
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Do It for Johnny
Kaitlyn Barba
I can’t say enough good things about this place.The food is delicious and fresh. Customer service is top notch.We love their daily specials!!Rice balls, banana pudding, porchetta, prosciutto are all amazingsandwiches are big that I always have leftoversCompetitors serve way less for the amount they charge. Quality food like this is WORTH the money.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Kaitlyn Barba-Johnson
I can’t say enough good things about this place.
The food is delicious and fresh. Customer service is top notch.
We love their daily specials!!
Rice balls, banana pudding, porchetta, prosciutto are all amazing
sandwiches are big that I always have leftovers
Competitors serve way less for the amount they charge. Quality food like this is WORTH the money.
Laura
Sorry I waited so long to try this place!!! DELICIOUS! Probably the best hero sandwich I ever had!!!! I had the MARIA and I can't wait to try the rest!!!!
This is one of my go-to spots. Everything I’ve tried is delicious. Daily specials. Always fresh. It’s a very clean and nice looking place too with a couple of bar stools to eat in; otherwise it’s a takeout spot. They are super friendly too.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Stephanie Giardina
The sandwiches here are incredible!! Huge and amazing combos! They have a different special everyday.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Alessandra Pedalino
Best sandwich catering! Ordered a variety of sandwiches and each one was absolutely delicious. Definitely catering from here for my next party.
John Parisi
Hands down best sandwich shop in NYC!We had a "friends giving" party and gave Anthony the freedom to make enough food for 20 people. Needless to say our expectations were achieved 10 times over. Only downside was that there were no left overs because oue guests didn't stop eating.Highly recommend for a lunch time snack or a party!Thank you Anthony's Paninoteca
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Rob
Lovely little sandwich shop in great kills town. I've placed orders over the phone and picked up in the specified time with no issues. I can only speak for the "Never forget hero" as it's the only one I've ordered, many times. But it is packed out, absolutely delicious and totally satisfying. Would definitely recommend. It is expensive, but so worth it
First time trying Anthony’s. I must say amazing experience all around. The girl at the front register was so nice, the sandwich making guy in the back(who I thought was Anthony himself but I didn’t know) good personality. The inside looks spotless, great decor, and felt very cool inside.I got one of Thursday specials which is the Porchetta with the crispy skin! It comes with broccoli rabe and fresh smoked mozzarella. I must say this might be the best pork sandwich I’ve ever eaten.Great crunch to the skin, very flavorful, the broccoli rabe is a great complement and the mozz is also a great addition. Best sandwich on Staten Island.We also tried the rice ball with and without meat, and the potato croquettes. Might be best on the island. So fresh!!I can’t wait to go back to try the others(except Thursday because Thursdays you know what I’m getting!!!)Anthony you out did yourself!!My score10 out of 10
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
From 1 anthony to another the godfather was ? the maria was good also. We will be back!
Awesome sandwiches, good prices
Outstanding! Delicious meatballs, crunchy bread! All fresh food. Generous portions. Friendly service. A true family business.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
So far I’m working my way through the menu and everything has been great. Pastrami was really good worth the wait. Friendly atmosphere and excellent service glad this place is in my neighborhood
A hole in the wall with fantastic food! Wednesday is pastrami day, Thursday is porchetta day both are hand crafted and amazing! ?
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Do It for Johnny, Anthony's, Ella's Chick-N Sandwhich
Had the pastrami for the first time and it was fantastic this was on a Wednesday,great conversation friendly
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Do It for Johnny
I can’t say enough good things about this place.The food is delicious and fresh. Customer service is top notch.We love their daily specials!!Rice balls, banana pudding, porchetta, prosciutto are all amazingsandwiches are big that I always have leftoversCompetitors serve way less for the amount they charge. Quality food like this is WORTH the money.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I can’t say enough good things about this place. The food is delicious and fresh. Customer service is top notch. We love their daily specials!! Rice balls, banana pudding, porchetta, prosciutto are all amazing sandwiches are big that I always have leftovers Competitors serve way less for the amount they charge. Quality food like this is WORTH the money.
Sorry I waited so long to try this place!!! DELICIOUS! Probably the best hero sandwich I ever had!!!! I had the MARIA and I can't wait to try the rest!!!!
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
This is one of my go-to spots. Everything I’ve tried is delicious. Daily specials. Always fresh. It’s a very clean and nice looking place too with a couple of bar stools to eat in; otherwise it’s a takeout spot. They are super friendly too.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The sandwiches here are incredible!! Huge and amazing combos! They have a different special everyday.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Best sandwich catering! Ordered a variety of sandwiches and each one was absolutely delicious. Definitely catering from here for my next party.
Hands down best sandwich shop in NYC!We had a "friends giving" party and gave Anthony the freedom to make enough food for 20 people. Needless to say our expectations were achieved 10 times over. Only downside was that there were no left overs because oue guests didn't stop eating.Highly recommend for a lunch time snack or a party!Thank you Anthony's Paninoteca
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Lovely little sandwich shop in great kills town. I've placed orders over the phone and picked up in the specified time with no issues. I can only speak for the "Never forget hero" as it's the only one I've ordered, many times. But it is packed out, absolutely delicious and totally satisfying. Would definitely recommend. It is expensive, but so worth it
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: 9-11 Hero