Cafe Milano Pizzeria and Restaurant

401 Forest Ave, Staten Island
(718) 720-1313

Recent Reviews

Johnny Zangrillo

Pizza was decent. Wouldn’t let me use the bathroom because it was st Patrick’s day parade even though I was a paying customer claiming “bathroom was only working for employees and not customers”. Hope you enjoy the 2 cents you saved on my toilet flush … willNot be returning again and will recommend against to friends. Nice mistake :)

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 3

Service: 1

L Shoemaker

Atmosphere is nothing special. Really doesn't look like it does in the pictures but the pizza is amazing.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Elizabeth Gomez

This place is absolutely amazing I had the pizza and dessert and it was delicious ? bout to go back soon and order something different this place take me way back ❤️

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Mor Sarr

I have been ordering here for the past 10 years and my son recently ordered a chicken sorentino not knowing they put pork in. We asked to replace the order for a chicken parm...a nasty person on the phone not only refused but wanted to charge me an extra $10.They lost me as a customer.

Food: 1

Service: 1

Chris Bentsen

Cafe Milano is always my go to spot on the north shore.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Vodka Chicken Slice of Pizza

Janet Reaves

Best Pizza on the

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Hazel Shroff

Ordered food from here for NYE. We asked for extra bread and this is what they gave us. Cold hard as a rock spread out inside the box. Also asked for extra dressing and this is what they provided. Food was okay. Going to stop wasting money on food that i know i can make better at home. Save yourself the trouble and

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 3

Service: 1

Joseph Iacono

Really great pizza in the area. We live on South Shore so we do not usually come by, but we had basketball and we’re in area.Really great pizza. Cooked perfect with excellent undercarriage. No flop at all.Sauce was very good and complimented their dough well.Perfect spice.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza Slice, Garlic Knots

M S

I like this place for take out and sometimes for quick informal dine in. The meatballs are very good. Pizza is really good too and the actually have a good gluten free crust. Haven't been disappointed yet.

Food: 4

Sole C

We order here all the time but lately the food has not been good you either get it cold or burned. When you call to complain the girls are rude and nasty and they never fix the problem. Definitely lost a customer tonight after our order was cold and burnt. Called to complain and the girl was so rude and she was like “ you want me to tell the driver to pick it up and reheat it” very sarcastic she was. Called again to speak to manager and obviously nothing was done my kids had to reheat all the food.

Food: 1

Service: 1

Christina Rivas

When I arrived, I was told I had to order my food at the register before I sat down. I have never been at a restaurant where I was told to order, pay, and then sit. ? I had ordered Fettuccine Alfred with shrimp. There wasn't enough sauce, the noodles was under cooked, there was no flavor at all. I ordered lobster ravioli, which had no lobster. I had this dish before somewhere else. They should definitely take this dish off the menu or at least let someone know not to expect lobster. Then, as we were sitting down eating, a fly flew on the Fettuccine Alfred, told the waitress, the cook in the back told to waitress that it was seasoning, which that was a lie, even the waitress said it was definitely a fly. We got our money back on that one dish. I paid a total of $94 dollars on what, I don't know. I don't recommend this place to anyone. I will never come here again. I'm actually writing this as I'm sitting here. Disgusting

Diab Ala

The worse service I ever saw putting into consideration we’ve been costumers for many years but today it just sealed it for us not to go or order from them again I added a pic of my yelp review explaining what happen

T

Great pizza grandma pie amazing.. excellent dessert options. All around good place for pizza.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

L&j

Great pizza grandma pie amazing.. excellent dessert options. All around good place for pizza.

Melinda Torres

Where is the powdered sugar tho?3rd time I ordered zepoles and its delivered like this (even in the winter)

Load More

Cafe Milano Pizzeria and Restaurant

401 Forest Ave, Staten Island, NY 10310
(718) 720-1313