I bought my wedding cake from Sue and my first and second anniversary cakes as well. It's just amazing. If you want an amazing cake, with flavors to match for your wedding, birthday or just because Sweet Sweet Sues is your place.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Wedding Cake
Ron and Joe
This is my 4th specialty cake from Sweet Sweet Sues! The absolute best cake and cake Designer, they never disappoint. I highly recommend the Cinnabon and signature wedding cake it is the most delicious combination. People could not stop raving about the taste of the cake and the beauty of the cake. Thank you for being an amazing business.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Wedding Cake
Jannine Ramlochan
Dom and Sue made the most stunning custom 5-tier cake for my September wedding. Dom patiently designed the cake and made recommendations when I was unsure of what would look good. I thought his sketch was beautiful but seeing the actual cake took my breath away. Dom is an ARTIST! He added so much detail when he sculpted that cake - it was beyond my imagination. Unlike most wedding cakes, this cake was not dry at all. They had a wide array of flavors for both the actual cake and the fillings. I don't like raspberry but when I tasted the white chocolate frosting with raspberry drizzle, I had to have it. The chocolate with chocolate ganache - well balance sweetness and out of this world delicious. Truly one of the best cakes I have ever tasted. Thank you Dom and Sue for contributing your incredible talent to my wedding day!
Food: 5
Recommended dishes: Wedding Cake
Anthony C. / AC Electric inc
Susan made a beautiful and delicious two tired cake with our New York theme for our daughters 18th birthday! It was fabulous and reasonably priced. Highly recommended and will use her again! Thank you!
Cora Musso
I couldn’t be more happier with this beautiful cake that Dominick and sue made for my sons 30th birthday party!! Delicious and beautiful!!
Marissa Ravelo
Couldn’t have been happier!! The consultation was easy as can be and the cake turned out beyond my expectations…just GORGEOUS!! Plus it was delish…people still talking about it days after the party. Thank you so so much and can’t wait to order my next cake with you. The only complaint I have is that I didn’t find you earlier :) ;)
gail resnick
Shout out to Sweet Sue's for my beautiful and delicious birthday 'Movie" cake,complete with a bag of popcorn. Everyone of my guests loved the cake! If you want a different, creative,delicious cake;Sweet Sue's on Main Street in Staten Island is the place to go. And they deliver to your venue.
Justina
Ordered two dozen cupcakes for an 80th birthday favor. Asked for wedding cake cupcakes with no raspberry, having been regular customers when SSS was on annadale road years ago, I expected the same quality. Half of the cupcakes were browned, burnt, and dry. The cupcakes also were missing the iconic crystallized edible decorations that enticed me to order them in the first place. Considering we paid over $100 for 24 cupcakes, we were disappointed. Order was placed well in advance so there would be no last minute rush but they weren’t even decorated nicely. the ones that weren’t burnt were delicious but i’m not sure what happened, disappointed :/
Lucy Ruggieri-Lind
Ordered my wedding cake @ $9/serving was beautiful but a complete rip off. Asked for chocolate buttercream cream and raspberry preserves. I didn't see any preserves, next day contacted them about it and they told me a thin layer was put on and was absorbed by the cake. For $9/slice it should be oozing raspberries. Sorry super disappointed. Thought I was going to get quality, never mind I'll go to Annadale Bakery or Piece a Cake.
Melissa Taibi
My father is an avid coin collector so when he turned 60 this past week we knew we needed a special coin themed cake. I had contacted Sue and throughout the process she was kind and responsive. I sent them an image of what I would like and to say they NAILED IT is an understatement. The cake was magnificent (everyone was raving about it) but more importantly it was DELICIOUS. We got chocolate cake with cannoli cream filling and it was very moist and very fresh. Also, the outer layer of the cake, which in these specialty cakes is usually a firm inedible fondant, was soft and incredibly delicious (dying for the recipe!). Cant wait to use her business again in the future for our special events! Highly highly recommend!
Ordered my wedding cake @ $9/serving was beautiful but a complete rip off. Asked for chocolate buttercream cream and raspberry preserves. I didn't see any preserves, next day contacted them about it and they told me a thin layer was put on and was absorbed by the cake. For $9/slice it should be oozing raspberries. Sorry super disappointed. Thought I was going to get quality, never mind I'll go to Annadale Bakery or Piece a Cake.
Deborah K
Dom was nothing but accommodating and helpful with the design of my wedding cake. I couldn’t have asked for a better designer. His wife made the most moist and flavorful cake which wasn’t too sweet, it was a perfect marble cake and her cannoli filling was fantastic! 5 busts of our dogs were placed on the cake. Everyone who knew our dogs, knew exactly who each dog was. Dom and Sue, we thank you from the bottom of our hearts for making our cake not only delicious but a cake that matched who we are.
Paulina
If you want a beautifully decorated cake as a show piece then this is the place but on taste it sadly missed the mark. I did get a beautiful cake although I do feel the original picture of what I sent in as far as the topper was nicer, still very happy with the way it looked. Moving on to taste. I specifically asked that the cake not be crazy sweet but when I tasted it, it was a pure sugar rush and a little grainy on top of it from the sugar. This is also the feedback I got from almost anyone who tasted the cake. Sadly, 2/3 of this $13 per serving cake went to waste even though I had more people than the cake was meant for. It was very dense like someone else below had mentioned. Like John below had said they need to improve greatly on customer service because I also did get the feeling like they were doing me a favor by letting me order a cake from them. Would it order again? Only if I wanted it specially for a showpiece and not as a source of dessert. I had a whole candy table for my baby shower so everything else substituted it. Bruno’s definitely hit the spot on pastries.
Teresa Dean
The cupcakes were very sweet and delicious! The staff was great too.
I bought my wedding cake from Sue and my first and second anniversary cakes as well. It's just amazing. If you want an amazing cake, with flavors to match for your wedding, birthday or just because Sweet Sweet Sues is your place.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Wedding Cake
This is my 4th specialty cake from Sweet Sweet Sues! The absolute best cake and cake Designer, they never disappoint. I highly recommend the Cinnabon and signature wedding cake it is the most delicious combination. People could not stop raving about the taste of the cake and the beauty of the cake. Thank you for being an amazing business.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Wedding Cake
Dom and Sue made the most stunning custom 5-tier cake for my September wedding. Dom patiently designed the cake and made recommendations when I was unsure of what would look good. I thought his sketch was beautiful but seeing the actual cake took my breath away. Dom is an ARTIST! He added so much detail when he sculpted that cake - it was beyond my imagination. Unlike most wedding cakes, this cake was not dry at all. They had a wide array of flavors for both the actual cake and the fillings. I don't like raspberry but when I tasted the white chocolate frosting with raspberry drizzle, I had to have it. The chocolate with chocolate ganache - well balance sweetness and out of this world delicious. Truly one of the best cakes I have ever tasted. Thank you Dom and Sue for contributing your incredible talent to my wedding day!
Food: 5
Recommended dishes: Wedding Cake
Susan made a beautiful and delicious two tired cake with our New York theme for our daughters 18th birthday! It was fabulous and reasonably priced. Highly recommended and will use her again! Thank you!
I couldn’t be more happier with this beautiful cake that Dominick and sue made for my sons 30th birthday party!! Delicious and beautiful!!
Couldn’t have been happier!! The consultation was easy as can be and the cake turned out beyond my expectations…just GORGEOUS!! Plus it was delish…people still talking about it days after the party. Thank you so so much and can’t wait to order my next cake with you. The only complaint I have is that I didn’t find you earlier :) ;)
Shout out to Sweet Sue's for my beautiful and delicious birthday 'Movie" cake,complete with a bag of popcorn. Everyone of my guests loved the cake! If you want a different, creative,delicious cake;Sweet Sue's on Main Street in Staten Island is the place to go. And they deliver to your venue.
Ordered two dozen cupcakes for an 80th birthday favor. Asked for wedding cake cupcakes with no raspberry, having been regular customers when SSS was on annadale road years ago, I expected the same quality. Half of the cupcakes were browned, burnt, and dry. The cupcakes also were missing the iconic crystallized edible decorations that enticed me to order them in the first place. Considering we paid over $100 for 24 cupcakes, we were disappointed. Order was placed well in advance so there would be no last minute rush but they weren’t even decorated nicely. the ones that weren’t burnt were delicious but i’m not sure what happened, disappointed :/
Ordered my wedding cake @ $9/serving was beautiful but a complete rip off. Asked for chocolate buttercream cream and raspberry preserves. I didn't see any preserves, next day contacted them about it and they told me a thin layer was put on and was absorbed by the cake. For $9/slice it should be oozing raspberries. Sorry super disappointed. Thought I was going to get quality, never mind I'll go to Annadale Bakery or Piece a Cake.
My father is an avid coin collector so when he turned 60 this past week we knew we needed a special coin themed cake. I had contacted Sue and throughout the process she was kind and responsive. I sent them an image of what I would like and to say they NAILED IT is an understatement. The cake was magnificent (everyone was raving about it) but more importantly it was DELICIOUS. We got chocolate cake with cannoli cream filling and it was very moist and very fresh. Also, the outer layer of the cake, which in these specialty cakes is usually a firm inedible fondant, was soft and incredibly delicious (dying for the recipe!). Cant wait to use her business again in the future for our special events! Highly highly recommend!
Restaurantji Recommends
overpriced and under delivered. plain and simple
Ordered my wedding cake @ $9/serving was beautiful but a complete rip off. Asked for chocolate buttercream cream and raspberry preserves. I didn't see any preserves, next day contacted them about it and they told me a thin layer was put on and was absorbed by the cake. For $9/slice it should be oozing raspberries. Sorry super disappointed. Thought I was going to get quality, never mind I'll go to Annadale Bakery or Piece a Cake.
Dom was nothing but accommodating and helpful with the design of my wedding cake. I couldn’t have asked for a better designer. His wife made the most moist and flavorful cake which wasn’t too sweet, it was a perfect marble cake and her cannoli filling was fantastic! 5 busts of our dogs were placed on the cake. Everyone who knew our dogs, knew exactly who each dog was. Dom and Sue, we thank you from the bottom of our hearts for making our cake not only delicious but a cake that matched who we are.
If you want a beautifully decorated cake as a show piece then this is the place but on taste it sadly missed the mark. I did get a beautiful cake although I do feel the original picture of what I sent in as far as the topper was nicer, still very happy with the way it looked. Moving on to taste. I specifically asked that the cake not be crazy sweet but when I tasted it, it was a pure sugar rush and a little grainy on top of it from the sugar. This is also the feedback I got from almost anyone who tasted the cake. Sadly, 2/3 of this $13 per serving cake went to waste even though I had more people than the cake was meant for. It was very dense like someone else below had mentioned. Like John below had said they need to improve greatly on customer service because I also did get the feeling like they were doing me a favor by letting me order a cake from them. Would it order again? Only if I wanted it specially for a showpiece and not as a source of dessert. I had a whole candy table for my baby shower so everything else substituted it. Bruno’s definitely hit the spot on pastries.
The cupcakes were very sweet and delicious! The staff was great too.