Order from this place all the time which I’m not going to anymore came in today to use the bathroom and the racist Mexican guy that barely speaks English said for me not to come back bc I didn’t buy anything today for using the bathroom you just lost out on a weekly customer
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Robert Ferone
Great location for our large group to meet. They take outstanding care of us.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: An Authentic Sicilian Square Pie Squarepizza
Sabrina
Order chicken Marsala, got this buttery slop. Usually when I order chicken Marsala it’s a brown sauce with mushrooms and onions. This was pure butter and oil with mushrooms and oil thrown in. Wouldn’t recommend this place.
Food: 1
maya seifert
Found this place during the pandemic when I was working from home and needed to pick up a quick dinner. Love their Sicilian Square pie and pick it up now at least twice a month for my family. Nice crust, good amount of cheese and delicious sauce. Will keep coming back!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Tina DeBenedetto
If you haven’t yet had the square pie from The Square on Annadale I suggest that you order your next square pie from here, it will not disappoint! Pizza holds up really good in the freezer for reheating too!
Food: 5
Service: 5
THE LIFE OF A TEEN AGER
Ordered take out , got 2 bacon-cheeseburgers both were terribly dry . Fried calamari was like a rubber gaskets , and rise ball way dry and burnt , do you're self a favor don't eat
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 5
G A
Customer service is horrendous. The place is run by a bunch of kids. I paid $19.00 for a margarita pie, which was not a margarita pie. It was a regular cheese pie with a few pieces of fresh mozzarella. The last time that I checked, a margarita pie was made ENTIRELY of fresh mozzarella. Called the place, and they pretty much told me to kick rocks! They have a picture posted to their website of an actual margarita pie. What they gave me wasn't even close. I posted a picture of what they think a margarita pie is. The picture on the left is what I got, and the picture on the right (from their website) is what I should have gotten. This is what happens when you let kids run your business!
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 3
Service: 1
Fadi Soliman
This place has a great awesome L&B pieand a huge rice ball to die for also had an awesome server she was theOnly Server I’ve had any experience with there but she’s all I need. She was very courteous, attentive and pleasant to work with she didn’t skip a beat. Thank you Olivia you’re a Rockstar and thank you Square I will be returning regularly and catering my parties from here.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: An Authentic Sicilian Pie, Sicilian Square Pie
pat larocco
Food is
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Buffalo Chicken Wings, An Authentic Sicilian Square Pie Squarepizza, Sicilian Square Pie
The $9.99 pie is bad quality. The guy refused to give soda even the signs says with soda.
Destiny Hernandez
Waited over an hour for the pizza and no one knew where the driver was , first time ordering from here & last . I heard the customer service is terrible but still wanted to try ! Never again !!!!
James C.
Worst pizza in nY we ordered a pizza with 4 toppings. $6 each topping just put on a cheese pizza already cooked. there were a few pieces of each item DO NOT GO HERE! I am a foodie and from Texas we have better pizza here and thats not saying much. If in Staten Island go to Brothers AMAZING youtube dave Portnoy and brothers review He is spot on the BEST
y j
Never ate her. I only did take out, but as Brooklyn guy that only lived 12 blocks from the L&B, this pizza is the same. Everything else I ever ordered was 100% on the money. Even the salads were 100%.It's definitely worth your time and money.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: An Authentic Sicilian Square Pie Squarepizza, Sicilian Square Pie
Carli H.
CUSTOMER SERVICE IS AMAZING !!!Amanda o Leary is the best counter worker ! And the gluten free pizza was delicious The ambiance is a 10/10the gluten free pizza was exquisite
Very similar to L&B
Order from this place all the time which I’m not going to anymore came in today to use the bathroom and the racist Mexican guy that barely speaks English said for me not to come back bc I didn’t buy anything today for using the bathroom you just lost out on a weekly customer
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Great location for our large group to meet. They take outstanding care of us.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: An Authentic Sicilian Square Pie Squarepizza
Order chicken Marsala, got this buttery slop. Usually when I order chicken Marsala it’s a brown sauce with mushrooms and onions. This was pure butter and oil with mushrooms and oil thrown in. Wouldn’t recommend this place.
Food: 1
Found this place during the pandemic when I was working from home and needed to pick up a quick dinner. Love their Sicilian Square pie and pick it up now at least twice a month for my family. Nice crust, good amount of cheese and delicious sauce. Will keep coming back!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
If you haven’t yet had the square pie from The Square on Annadale I suggest that you order your next square pie from here, it will not disappoint! Pizza holds up really good in the freezer for reheating too!
Food: 5
Service: 5
Ordered take out , got 2 bacon-cheeseburgers both were terribly dry . Fried calamari was like a rubber gaskets , and rise ball way dry and burnt , do you're self a favor don't eat
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 5
Customer service is horrendous. The place is run by a bunch of kids. I paid $19.00 for a margarita pie, which was not a margarita pie. It was a regular cheese pie with a few pieces of fresh mozzarella. The last time that I checked, a margarita pie was made ENTIRELY of fresh mozzarella. Called the place, and they pretty much told me to kick rocks! They have a picture posted to their website of an actual margarita pie. What they gave me wasn't even close. I posted a picture of what they think a margarita pie is. The picture on the left is what I got, and the picture on the right (from their website) is what I should have gotten. This is what happens when you let kids run your business!
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 3
Service: 1
This place has a great awesome L&B pieand a huge rice ball to die for also had an awesome server she was theOnly Server I’ve had any experience with there but she’s all I need. She was very courteous, attentive and pleasant to work with she didn’t skip a beat. Thank you Olivia you’re a Rockstar and thank you Square I will be returning regularly and catering my parties from here.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: An Authentic Sicilian Pie, Sicilian Square Pie
Food is
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Buffalo Chicken Wings, An Authentic Sicilian Square Pie Squarepizza, Sicilian Square Pie
Restaurantji Recommends
The $9.99 pie is bad quality. The guy refused to give soda even the signs says with soda.
Waited over an hour for the pizza and no one knew where the driver was , first time ordering from here & last . I heard the customer service is terrible but still wanted to try ! Never again !!!!
Worst pizza in nY we ordered a pizza with 4 toppings. $6 each topping just put on a cheese pizza already cooked. there were a few pieces of each item DO NOT GO HERE! I am a foodie and from Texas we have better pizza here and thats not saying much. If in Staten Island go to Brothers AMAZING youtube dave Portnoy and brothers review He is spot on the BEST
Never ate her. I only did take out, but as Brooklyn guy that only lived 12 blocks from the L&B, this pizza is the same. Everything else I ever ordered was 100% on the money. Even the salads were 100%.It's definitely worth your time and money.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: An Authentic Sicilian Square Pie Squarepizza, Sicilian Square Pie
CUSTOMER SERVICE IS AMAZING !!!Amanda o Leary is the best counter worker ! And the gluten free pizza was delicious The ambiance is a 10/10the gluten free pizza was exquisite