Old River Mill sourdough bakery

323 Spook Rock Rd # 9, Suffern
(845) 537-2392

Recent Reviews

Austin e Baker

(Translated by Google) I immediately sent it to the bakery and the Pandelochnam has it on hand(Original)איך גלייך דאס געזינדל ביי די בעקעריי און דער פאנדעלאטשנם האט עס ביי פאר

Christopher M.

What a great place to venture. I purchased some outstand bread and some baked goods from this little treasure (GREAT PRICES). They have a variety of Polish meats and a number of other European products. The staff is just lovely. Well worth the trip from Jackson Heights!

Shloime Sebbag

(Translated by Google) I met the family at the bakery and the fundraiser took care of it(Original)איך גלייך דאס געזינדל ביי די בעקעריי און דער פאנדעלאטשנם האט עס ביי פאר

Michal Klark

The best texture ever you can feel the smooth full origenal taste. Never seen such good quality

yossy dancziger

Best taste!

Joseph Weberman

If you want to develop a taste in sour dough you should start here. Best sour dough ever

Bobby31225

I've been here before but just after staying in Winchester Bay for 8 nights this July I thought I'd do a review of the place. 2 years ago when I was there they had many more things to sell, but this year I was told a new owner-manager? 2 years ago I bought some jam from them and they even mailed it to my house, of course I had to pay. This year I did get jam and just walked across the street to the post office and did it myself. They don't do the mailing thing anymore. No big deal. The day before I left I bought one of their huge cinnamon rolls and boy was it good!! Cost $7.25 but it was enough for 4 people! Still a nice place but was better 2 years ago,in my opinion.

debrap757

Fabulous breads, coffee, and candies. Friendly staff. Great roadside stop. Reasonable prices. Restroom available. They also sell sourdough starter to try at home. Wine available for sale, too.

CRAIG C

Word of mouth in our campground was that we should go find the sour dough bread shop up the street. We stopped by and were pleasantly surprised with their breads, bagels, sweets, and their special butter! It’s right on the corner in WBay and the highway, so stop by and grab a brownie.

teithiwrCymraeg

Stopped by this place while on a road trip as we were hungry. Had a simple cream cheese toasted bagel, but it was amazing. Place looks a little dated but don’t let that put you off.

Sam Krau

Amazing Bret delicious unbelievable

Chaim Rottenberg

Best challas ever!!!

simon kraus

You're the best of the best Bakery

Philip J

Good and very good food for a home made sandwich I will try again and service is very good and I will eat here again

DillyisDolli-ing

I scored some excellent bread and wine too! The staff is friendly and they carry a variety of jams, relishes, yummy yummy!

Load More