Rare650 Prime Steak and Sushi

650 Jericho Turnpike, Syosset
(516) 496-8000

Recent Reviews

Roshni Chandihok

Used to love Rare650 but it's significantly downgraded. I dined here a few weeks ago for a family dinner and the restaurant was so crowded you couldn't even walk through the tables because they were so close to one another. It was ridiculous. The manager explained to us that they were compensate for the fact they were hosting a few events upstairs and needed to accomodate for space in the downstairs restaurant. In my eyes, this not only impacts the dining experience for a guest (lack of space) but also results in lack of attention in the kitchen, waiting staff, and quality of food when a restaurant is so overly busy... Unfortunately, this was exactly what happened.We were assigned two waiters for some odd reason - one which took care of food orders and one which took care of drinks and dessert (assuming this helped them move quicker with orders). When paying $$$$ for a steakhouse meal, this is not the kind of experience I expect to receive. Furthermore, the food was extremely disappointing. Appetizers came out cold, sushi was not fresh, and entrees / steak lacked flavor.Disappointed to say the least, will definitely not be returning.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Michael Cianciaruso

Rare 650 has vastly improved their service issues and now contends with the top steakhouses out there. Had a very enjoyable experience with attentive wait staff and excellent food selections.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

GeoMike122

Very nice atmosphere and delicious food. The steaks were perfectly cooked. The sushi and appetizers were all unique and tasty. Desserts were superb.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Charred Spanish Octopus, Deconstructed Apple Pie, Lobster Mac & Cheese, Tuna Tartare, Marinated Skirt Steak

Chandni Chandihok

As someone who really looked forward to visiting Rare650 again, my dining experience fell drastically short of expectations.Upon entering the restaurant, I couldn't help but notice how closely packed the tables were, making the atmosphere feel cramped and uncomfortable. It was challenging to engage in conversation without feeling like we were intruding on neighboring conversations.Moving on to the main event—the food. We ordered the signature ribeye steak, expecting a sensation of flavor and tenderness. Unfortunately, what arrived at my table was a disappointment in every sense. Each bite felt like a chore, devoid of the satisfaction I typically associate with a good steak.Moreover, the sides accompanying the steak were equally lackluster. The truffle mashed potatoes were lukewarm and seemed to have been sitting out for far too long. The mushrooms lacked any freshness or vibrancy.This place used to be a great vibe and quality food a couple years ago but I would not recommend this place any longer.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

carlyle bigby

It was great service food was spectacular environment everthing. Hidden

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 4

Recommended dishes: Deconstructed Apple Pie

D D

Beautiful restaurant, we made reservations yet had to wait as they overbooked. We waited for the server again. Server took our order, did not receive any bread or water until I mentioned that we felt neglected the manager came over & apologized. Great food, crab cakes were delicious.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 4

Soniya Yunatanova

Very good

Anne Rosenfeld

Really nice place with great weekday

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Princesse H

Best steak I ever taste. Service is great drink is great and food is even better.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Happycustomer6

It was an amazing experience. The manager was so nice. He came an spoke to us in very authentic way. It was our mom's 1st anniversary without our father and he made sure to be very thoughtful and charismatic. We appreciate it. It made her day! The food was so good. The waiters were beyond nice. Even the valet was nice. A great time all around. ?We are going to plan my sisters birthday party to be here. Love it here ...

LIfoodie

We celebrated our anniversary by having dinner at RARE650 and it was fabulous!! The restaurant is beautiful and the staff was very welcoming. By the end of our dinner, we knew the name of every staff member. The service was professional and very friendly. Our martinis were served in iced glasses which is always a plus and speaks highly of the bar staff. We ordered dinner from the special weekday menu and there were so many wonderful choices to select from. Our appetizers were crispy rice with tuna and lobster bisque, both very good. The New York strip steak came rare, as ordered, and was very tasty. I had the honey glazed pork chop with chutney, squash and the most delicious mushrooms I have ever eaten. Most restaurants overcook pork chops but this chop was perfectly cooked and the entire dish was spectacular! I will definitely order this again. The banana cream pie for dessert was more like a tart but was very tasty. This restaurant is a winner so don't hesitate to go and enjoy a fabulous meal!

Tina ramnauth

This was my first time dining in at prime steak house and let me just say that this place has become one of my favoriteThe food was delicious and the ambiance was amazingWill definitely be go back hereThe staff knows how to make their guests feel at home

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Mashed Potatoes

The best customer service I can recall having in a restaurant. Full stop. We were attended to by multiple gentlemen throughout the night but it was never unwanted or overbearing. Standing ovation for the staff!

Nicole Pellegrino

This restaurant is incredible! The ambiance is spectacular, the service is great and the good is absolutely delicious! We called around 530pm on a Saturday and they told us to walk in around 6. The valet staff was professional, the hostess’ were so nice and they sat us right away.We had two waiters who worked hand in hand and worked very well together. They both came over right away. Both were very knowledgeable of the menu and the specials and they were both so nice! They asked us if we were there for a special occasion and it was just my birthday which we didnt plan to mention but they made the experience special.We ordered a bone-in ribeye, the large sushi platter, and Pellegrino sparkling water. They brought over bread, evoo with pepper, and the pellegrino with lemon, lime and orange. The food came quickly and was presented very well. We ordered the steak with a side of the truffle butter and it was SO good. The sushi platter was so fresh and went perfectly with the steak. The waiters checked in frequently and the general manager came over to see how our experience was as well. They even brought over these delicious warm doughnuts with white chocolate, a raspberry sauce on top, a candle and a chocolate happy birthday sign, which was unexpected and a really nice surprise.One of the best restaurant experiences we’ve had in a while and we will definitely be back!

Stanja Fleetwood

Does anyone else love this restaurant as much as I do. The happy hour food and Cosmo is amazing!Parking: The Parking lot is adequate but I opt for valet.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Charred Spanish Octopus, Colorado Lamb Chops, Tuna Tartare

Load More