I don't know how you make a simple turkey sub so delicious, but dang. I'm from the south, and we don't have a lot of great deli options, so Brooklyn Pickle is always a treat when we're back home in Syracuse. Restaurant is clean, service was fast and friendly, and the sandwiches are simple, but amazing. And we also like the owner!
Jim S.
This place can move people! At least 10 people working the counter area putting sandwiches together! The meat, cheese, bread, all fresh! There is no better sandwich, anywhere. The soups are fresh and homemade. The whole sandwich is too big for anyone to finish, so I took the other half home. They offer half sandwich's, which is like a normal size sandwich. Wide verity of chips, drinks, home made cookies and desserts. There is seating inside and out. Very comfortable and the rest rooms are clean. Highly recommended
John Lizzi
You don't have to travel to NYC for great deli sandwiches, sides & desserts. Corned beef on Rye with Russian dressing, excellent, as are all their sandwiches.
T.L.M. H.W.B.
Customer for 30+ years. Never a bad sandwich, ever… best corned beef on rye!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Doug W.
Food was great. Service was moderately fast but the place was clean. If you ever want alot of deli meat with 2 pieces of what is supposed to be called bread (lol...that is how much meat there is) go here! I have been for years when I visit the Syracuse area.
John Mchugh
Great subs and
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
mark lehman
Great atmosphere and the cornedbeef sandwich was huge and delicious.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Edward S.
A Syracuse classic. These guys have been great since the mid seventies. I only wish they'd serve matzaball soup and potato pancakes. You cannot beat the Pickle.
Patti Collins
Gary makes my favorite Mac & Cheese and the sandwiches have been so good.
Joe P
Always a good place to eat in the
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Roast Beef, Roast Beef Sandwich, Italian Sub, Neptune Stew, blt, Chili
Little pricey but food was great. Bit of a line but it moved fast. Definitely be back.
Jennifer S
I’ve been coming to BP west for over 25 years. I must say everything recently is still so good if not better. Gary makes my favorite Mac & Cheese and the sandwiches have been so good. Fresh ingredients and well portioned. I do miss the wheat sub rolls. Keep up the good work over there. We appreciate you all! I always mean to take a photo of my turkey sandwich on wheat, but I’m too busy eating it. Maybe next time.
My wife and I are eating here numerous times there are two locations in syracuse, great sandwiches, soups and
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Mariah Galletta
A great little sandwich shop to check out especially if you want something less expensive. They have gluten free bread. Around $8 for a sandwich at the moment. Also selling the buckets they make the pickles in for $2 currently which is great for gardening work if you do that.. highly recommend!
I don't know how you make a simple turkey sub so delicious, but dang. I'm from the south, and we don't have a lot of great deli options, so Brooklyn Pickle is always a treat when we're back home in Syracuse. Restaurant is clean, service was fast and friendly, and the sandwiches are simple, but amazing. And we also like the owner!
This place can move people! At least 10 people working the counter area putting sandwiches together! The meat, cheese, bread, all fresh! There is no better sandwich, anywhere. The soups are fresh and homemade. The whole sandwich is too big for anyone to finish, so I took the other half home. They offer half sandwich's, which is like a normal size sandwich. Wide verity of chips, drinks, home made cookies and desserts. There is seating inside and out. Very comfortable and the rest rooms are clean. Highly recommended
You don't have to travel to NYC for great deli sandwiches, sides & desserts. Corned beef on Rye with Russian dressing, excellent, as are all their sandwiches.
Customer for 30+ years. Never a bad sandwich, ever… best corned beef on rye!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Food was great. Service was moderately fast but the place was clean. If you ever want alot of deli meat with 2 pieces of what is supposed to be called bread (lol...that is how much meat there is) go here! I have been for years when I visit the Syracuse area.
Great subs and
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Great atmosphere and the cornedbeef sandwich was huge and delicious.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
A Syracuse classic. These guys have been great since the mid seventies. I only wish they'd serve matzaball soup and potato pancakes. You cannot beat the Pickle.
Gary makes my favorite Mac & Cheese and the sandwiches have been so good.
Always a good place to eat in the
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Roast Beef, Roast Beef Sandwich, Italian Sub, Neptune Stew, blt, Chili
Restaurantji Recommends
Little pricey but food was great. Bit of a line but it moved fast. Definitely be back.
I’ve been coming to BP west for over 25 years. I must say everything recently is still so good if not better. Gary makes my favorite Mac & Cheese and the sandwiches have been so good. Fresh ingredients and well portioned. I do miss the wheat sub rolls. Keep up the good work over there. We appreciate you all! I always mean to take a photo of my turkey sandwich on wheat, but I’m too busy eating it. Maybe next time.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pastrami Sandwich, Rice Pudding, Brooklyn Pickle Special, Cream Cheese Brownie
Brooklyn pickle is so delicious ???
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Italian Sub, Soups
My wife and I are eating here numerous times there are two locations in syracuse, great sandwiches, soups and
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
A great little sandwich shop to check out especially if you want something less expensive. They have gluten free bread. Around $8 for a sandwich at the moment. Also selling the buckets they make the pickles in for $2 currently which is great for gardening work if you do that.. highly recommend!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5