Stopped in with my son for a slice and it was near closing time, so we got two grandma slices and sat down to eat. Then we decided to get a plain pie to go. Scottio was very friendly, chatted for a bit while the pizza cooked. It was my first time there, but I'll be back. Garlic knots are killer, and the pie is thick old school crust with a nice flavorful sauce and just the right amount of cheese. Nice to meet you, Scottio!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Garlic Knots, Slice
CHECITY TM
I was craving pizza and stopped by this pizza spot. I ordered one grandma slice and I kid you not it's the next day and I can't stop thinking about this pizza. Delicious!!!!!! I need a whole
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Grandma Pizza
xKingPac
I derive immense pleasure from the pizza’s flavor profile. It possesses remarkable depth, marked by the exquisite quality of its sauce and cheese. The pizza, graced with a delicately thin yet crisply textured slice, affords the palate the privilege of savoring every nuance, all the while retaining a delightful element of crunch.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Susan K.
The food was spectacular. The service was out of this world, and the ambience is a Pizza Place!!! If you're in the neighborhood, come to the pizza place and get spectacular food !!! there
Neela Singh
Great service and great food owner is very kind my daughter loves going there
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
One Man Gang
Place has tanked since it was Pizza Amore. As a patron of the later for 40 years this dosnt compare. The new owner (previous employee i believe) needs a lesson in manors. Has a real attitude problem and he's always "out of" stuff. In the land of pizza on every corner...try another. You've lost a customer.
Jeannette A
Extremely arrogant, rude obnoxious owner. Their food is poor quality just like their attitude. Don’t eat here. Only gave 1 star because it doesn’t allow you to give none.
Bob M.
THE BEST PIZZA EVER and SCOTTY IS A is a great guy I have lived in the area for 40 years and I've tried all the pizza in the area. This place is the best. nothing in the area compares with this e
Jay G.
Poor quality food, served with an attitude. Pizza did not look fresh, like it was sitting there all day. Pretty much take out only, as the crew of misfits inside make it very unwelcoming. Luckily there was a nearby trash can to dispose of this waste they call pizza. Better off with frozen Elio's or Celeste. Scottio's ----- more like Scotti NO's.
All of their slices taste amazing and fresh ! Definitely my favorite pizza shop in the neighborhood. Sicilian is my go to slice!Parking: Always available parking spots!
AzA Aaa
Truly of the best pizza place I have ever been.An authentic atmosphere with a soul and heart, which is so difficult to find these days. Highly recommend and worth a trip from NYC.
Jill M.
I just finished 2 regular slices, a grandmas slice and a spinach roll. Everything is always so good. The owner and staff are very nice. I'm always happy to give my local pizzeria Scottio's my business.
alex paravani
Great cheese slice, my favorite in the area by far. Wish they were open Monday's.
kevin abrams
4 stars based solely on the fact that they sell Italian ices!!! I reserve the fifth star for when I actually try their food. Great selection of ices and they would have got five stars just for that but there was no rainbow ice..... That having been said, the chocolate fudge flavor was amazing. Please get your ices here and help keep Italian ices in pizzerias!!! Enjoy!
Stopped in with my son for a slice and it was near closing time, so we got two grandma slices and sat down to eat. Then we decided to get a plain pie to go. Scottio was very friendly, chatted for a bit while the pizza cooked. It was my first time there, but I'll be back. Garlic knots are killer, and the pie is thick old school crust with a nice flavorful sauce and just the right amount of cheese. Nice to meet you, Scottio!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Garlic Knots, Slice
I was craving pizza and stopped by this pizza spot. I ordered one grandma slice and I kid you not it's the next day and I can't stop thinking about this pizza. Delicious!!!!!! I need a whole
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Grandma Pizza
I derive immense pleasure from the pizza’s flavor profile. It possesses remarkable depth, marked by the exquisite quality of its sauce and cheese. The pizza, graced with a delicately thin yet crisply textured slice, affords the palate the privilege of savoring every nuance, all the while retaining a delightful element of crunch.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The food was spectacular. The service was out of this world, and the ambience is a Pizza Place!!! If you're in the neighborhood, come to the pizza place and get spectacular food !!! there
Great service and great food owner is very kind my daughter loves going there
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Place has tanked since it was Pizza Amore. As a patron of the later for 40 years this dosnt compare. The new owner (previous employee i believe) needs a lesson in manors. Has a real attitude problem and he's always "out of" stuff. In the land of pizza on every corner...try another. You've lost a customer.
Extremely arrogant, rude obnoxious owner. Their food is poor quality just like their attitude. Don’t eat here. Only gave 1 star because it doesn’t allow you to give none.
THE BEST PIZZA EVER and SCOTTY IS A is a great guy I have lived in the area for 40 years and I've tried all the pizza in the area. This place is the best. nothing in the area compares with this e
Poor quality food, served with an attitude. Pizza did not look fresh, like it was sitting there all day. Pretty much take out only, as the crew of misfits inside make it very unwelcoming. Luckily there was a nearby trash can to dispose of this waste they call pizza. Better off with frozen Elio's or Celeste. Scottio's ----- more like Scotti NO's.
Great pizza best on
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Sausage Roll, Chicken Parmigiana, Garlic Knots Dozen, Slice, Special Pizza, Garlic Bread
Restaurantji Recommends
All of their slices taste amazing and fresh ! Definitely my favorite pizza shop in the neighborhood. Sicilian is my go to slice!Parking: Always available parking spots!
Truly of the best pizza place I have ever been.An authentic atmosphere with a soul and heart, which is so difficult to find these days. Highly recommend and worth a trip from NYC.
I just finished 2 regular slices, a grandmas slice and a spinach roll. Everything is always so good. The owner and staff are very nice. I'm always happy to give my local pizzeria Scottio's my business.
Great cheese slice, my favorite in the area by far. Wish they were open Monday's.
4 stars based solely on the fact that they sell Italian ices!!! I reserve the fifth star for when I actually try their food. Great selection of ices and they would have got five stars just for that but there was no rainbow ice..... That having been said, the chocolate fudge flavor was amazing. Please get your ices here and help keep Italian ices in pizzerias!!! Enjoy!