This place is so inconsistent!!! I like consistency. The standards literally change by the hour. Sometimes you give dressings, cole slaw, and pickle, sometimes you don't! Sometimes you care, sometimes you don't! Tonight I decided I would rather cook then deal with Greek Island Diner's inconsistency... Figure it out, because you are now blacklisted for me!
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 5
Service: 1
#SmartHomeSecurityNY
Everything was fresh and delicious! Great diner ❤️
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
sandra hernandez
Dietary restrictions: Very accommodating to allergies restrictions. Everything was cooked to perfection.Parking: Plenty of parkingKid-friendliness: Several tables had kids the servers were very friendly. Everyone that came to the diner seemed to be happy to be there. They seemed like they frequent this place.
Recommended dishes: French Toast
Peter Daly
A very nice diner. The staff is always friendly and they provide an enjoyable dining experience. The food is very good and priced reasonably.I recommend you give them a try.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Triple Decker Turkey Club
james
Great service and food on a very busy Sunday morning.
Janet I.
The third time going here for breakfast and the last. We HATE runny eggs. We very assertively tell waitress no runny egg whites in over medium eggs. And every time, egg snot! Home fries burnt to a crisp horrible. And below the burnt layer, tasteless mushy potatoes. Not wasting anymore time or money on lousy breakfast with cheap bacon. Love the gyro hash, will get it to go and make my own eggs.
Sabrina Goss
We love that they deliver and the food is always consistent.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Rosiani S.
Consistently great food. A huge selection of soups everyday. My dad loves the gyros and my sister loves the burgers. The spinach salad is great and the bacon was not
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Jackie S.
Cute place decorated for Xmas. Service was amazing food was normal diner food. Prices went up recently but seems to be average.
Erik B.
Great food and great service. Really enjoyed my meal. Fresh and delicious. Server was very attentive and the staff were very freindly. Definitely going back.
Went here 2 days in a row. Their corned beef hash is legit, and their sandwiches are the size of a toddler. I got their french dip and it was loaded. Avgolemono soup is quite delicious as well. Second day i got their pancake hungry man breakfast. Pancakes are light and fluffy, a bit on the delicate side but delicious. Bacon is nice and crispy without being brittle, and they cooked my over-medium eggs perfect! Yolk was nice and runny without any of that snotty undercooked egg white, a procedure most other diners cant seem to perfect. And the service was immaculate, never felt ignored or like i was waiting. There’s a reason it’s busy and they earned the 5 stars. Good job
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Karen Reed
Great breakfast!
Glenn Fallucca
Fun diner with standard fare. Worth stopping in for a meal. Service was quick and
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Christine Kohronas
Moved to the area recently and we’re so glad we found this diner! Every meal so far has been delicious and their coffee is the best! The staff is always so friendly. Glad to have such a great place nearby.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Greek Style Chicken Breast
LI Local
Our favorite dinner even if it's a bit of a drive! Great food, large portions, super affordable, and the entire staff is beyond incredible!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Grape Leaves, Falafel Plate, French Toast, Chicken Gyro Platter, Pastrami Sandwich, Greek Gyro on Pita, Tuna on Rye with Fries, Philly Cheese Steak Pita Melt, Greek Style Chicken Breast, Reuben, Home Fries & Toast, Toast, Cheesecake, Home Fries, Cakes, Western Omlette Panini, Fruit Pies, Greek Salad with Grilled Chicken, Triple Decker Turkey Club, Cheese Cake of the Day
This place is so inconsistent!!! I like consistency. The standards literally change by the hour. Sometimes you give dressings, cole slaw, and pickle, sometimes you don't! Sometimes you care, sometimes you don't! Tonight I decided I would rather cook then deal with Greek Island Diner's inconsistency... Figure it out, because you are now blacklisted for me!
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 5
Service: 1
Everything was fresh and delicious! Great diner ❤️
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Dietary restrictions: Very accommodating to allergies restrictions. Everything was cooked to perfection.Parking: Plenty of parkingKid-friendliness: Several tables had kids the servers were very friendly. Everyone that came to the diner seemed to be happy to be there. They seemed like they frequent this place.
Recommended dishes: French Toast
A very nice diner. The staff is always friendly and they provide an enjoyable dining experience. The food is very good and priced reasonably.I recommend you give them a try.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Triple Decker Turkey Club
Great service and food on a very busy Sunday morning.
The third time going here for breakfast and the last. We HATE runny eggs. We very assertively tell waitress no runny egg whites in over medium eggs. And every time, egg snot! Home fries burnt to a crisp horrible. And below the burnt layer, tasteless mushy potatoes. Not wasting anymore time or money on lousy breakfast with cheap bacon. Love the gyro hash, will get it to go and make my own eggs.
We love that they deliver and the food is always consistent.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Consistently great food. A huge selection of soups everyday. My dad loves the gyros and my sister loves the burgers. The spinach salad is great and the bacon was not
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Cute place decorated for Xmas. Service was amazing food was normal diner food. Prices went up recently but seems to be average.
Great food and great service. Really enjoyed my meal. Fresh and delicious. Server was very attentive and the staff were very freindly. Definitely going back.
Restaurantji Recommends
Went here 2 days in a row. Their corned beef hash is legit, and their sandwiches are the size of a toddler. I got their french dip and it was loaded. Avgolemono soup is quite delicious as well. Second day i got their pancake hungry man breakfast. Pancakes are light and fluffy, a bit on the delicate side but delicious. Bacon is nice and crispy without being brittle, and they cooked my over-medium eggs perfect! Yolk was nice and runny without any of that snotty undercooked egg white, a procedure most other diners cant seem to perfect. And the service was immaculate, never felt ignored or like i was waiting. There’s a reason it’s busy and they earned the 5 stars. Good job
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Great breakfast!
Fun diner with standard fare. Worth stopping in for a meal. Service was quick and
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Moved to the area recently and we’re so glad we found this diner! Every meal so far has been delicious and their coffee is the best! The staff is always so friendly. Glad to have such a great place nearby.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Greek Style Chicken Breast
Our favorite dinner even if it's a bit of a drive! Great food, large portions, super affordable, and the entire staff is beyond incredible!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Grape Leaves, Falafel Plate, French Toast, Chicken Gyro Platter, Pastrami Sandwich, Greek Gyro on Pita, Tuna on Rye with Fries, Philly Cheese Steak Pita Melt, Greek Style Chicken Breast, Reuben, Home Fries & Toast, Toast, Cheesecake, Home Fries, Cakes, Western Omlette Panini, Fruit Pies, Greek Salad with Grilled Chicken, Triple Decker Turkey Club, Cheese Cake of the Day