5 De Mayo Mexican Restaurant

611 Old Country Rd, Westbury
(516) 280-7795

Recent Reviews

Dante Garcia

Cute restaurant that feels like a hidden gem. The food was fresh and hot, I recommend the empanadas. Prices are great too with good deals for Taco Tuesday. The staff was so friendly and attentive. 10/10 experience. Can’t recommend this place enough.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

lilmac

The drinks were great, as was the ambiance, and the waitstaff and management were friendly. That being said, 3 out of 4 of us thought our entrees were just okay. We ordered tableside guacamole, but it was forgotten and never arrived. To be fair, there was a party of about 20 that was taking up a lot of the waiters' attention during that time. Although we decided not to order dessert, an order of flan was brought over to us gratis, and it was delicious! Although our experience was mixed, I will certainly give them another chance.

Shirley Luk

I came here on Tuesday night. The music is good , the food and drink are delicious and amazing, the waiter is passionate and nice. I am satisfied the service for sure !

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Mike Nolin

Up here working on a job since last January, first Mexican restaurant I've tried. Nothings ever like your favorite place back home, but it wasn't bad. I was concerned at first, dinner time, and I was the only customer in the place. Made me wonder why. Up here from Tennessee, little costly! More like twice the price.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 4

Service: 5

Shauri Mealing

I just remember the food was over cooked and very bland. There were things a Mexican restaurant should have like crema. The guacamole was dark and old. Which we didn’t even touch because of the appearance. Never going here again.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 2

Service: 2

LoriH

Food was really great. We had 3 apps and 3 different entrees. Service was not up to Par. Waitress was asked 4 different times for 4 different things and we had to ask other workers to get them.

Connor C.

When my girl friend and I walked in we were welcome with a smile. And felt very welcomed at the door, the food was very good, if your looking for a quite place to eat with Mexican food. And very wholesome atmosphere and service. Would go back again

Toni M.

To celebrate my birthday this year, I invited 7 dear friends and family members to join me for my birthday brunch. Although the food was mostly good, and the atmosphere was pleasant, a couple of things did not sit right with me, which is why I have only given a 3* review. First of all: When my bill came, I was shocked to see that I was charged for 2 beers and a cola. At almost $60.00 a person, I assumed those "beverages: were among the included drinks. Although the waitress told me she had provided those guests with an "acceptable list of complimentary drinks, my guests refuted that claim. ( FYI: She never mentioned anything about which drinks were included, when she addressed my end of the table, either.) At then end of the meal, I was presented with the bill (which I had asked come to me when I arrived,) and was confused as to why the bill was so high, ($596.30.) I asked the waitress for a detailed bill, and she then said there was a 20% gratuity included on the bill. When I questioned that, she said: "Oh, I thought I told you about that earlier." She did NOT! I was unpleasantly surprised, because I do did not feel a 20% gratuity was warranted at a buffet, particularly when one of my quests had to go to the bar herself, to get the aforementioned cola, because the waitress was no where to be found! All in all, I felt a little ripped off. Two of my quests ate heartily, while the rest of us at respectfully. I was very glad that I hosted the meal, because I would have been mortified to tell them what that total was. I "may" go back for a dinner sometime, but it is extremely unlikely that I, or anyone I know, will ever again go there for the brunch!

Angry F.

Solid food. Nice service. Amazing flan. Latin music really got you in the mood. Fun.

Lynn

Quaint restaurant that was not crowded at 5:00 on a Friday night. Was'nt crowded the last time I went either. The staff is friendly and the food was plentiful and delicious. I would recommend the steak fajita. Great Place.

Steven Varjian

Really like this place a lot. Nice service, real good food. Wish I would see more support from locals here! Each time I go, not a lot of people. Trust me. You’ll like it! In an area where there are not a lot of Mexican restaurants, this is a gem.

Francis Hernandez

I feel like prices for drinks and food are terrible expensive. They don’t offer any happy hour and not promotion at all. A virgen pina colada about $9?! That’s crazy you pay for a virgin drink what you could pay for a very good cocktail in other places. Also we ordered a Queso Fundido appetizer which is supposed to be an appetizer for a table and it just come with 3 flour tortillas and if you ask for more tortilla they charge you around 2 dollars per order of 3 tortillas.I feel that they food and drinks aren’t enough good to be that expensive. Also that there are not enough workers at the place so it’s really complicated to get refills and they are always too busy on weekends.

Malvin Vásquez

To be honest all we ordered was too salty, we ate a little bit but we were not happy at all. The al pastor tacos was really salty and also the shrimps tacos were not well done and too salty too.

Stephen Ryder

We researched the menu and the prices before going in, and they were reasonable.When we got the bill, the prices were doubled,This restaurant gouches the costumers.

Ruben T.

We had a party of eight people at 5 DeMayo The service was excellent, the staff was very pleasant and friendly. The Ambiance was nice and not to loud. Everyone in our party was saying how good the food was. Not only was the restaurant & food excellent it, but the portions were extremely large. You will not be disappointed.

Load More