We have been going to this bar regularly for 2 years! Enjoy most of the staff and the food has been on point!! The staff and many diners have remarked favorably about my 8 lb service animal.Today, a couple became angry and very nasty about my service animal calling me obscene names using vulgar language!The owner aware of my dog being a service animal asked us to leave!Evidently he has no notion of the American disability act!!
Food: 4
Donald Fletcher
You will not be disappointed. The food is very good. The service is just as good. The food is consistently fabulous. I have been going there for years and have not had a bad meal there. Always enjoyable. Always looking forward to going back
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Mark LoGiurato
Interesting Irish pub with good Italian food!! The food is made to order fresh and very tasty. The staff is very friendly and accommodating. Nice bar area with good well drinks.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Veronica Blanco
I live in the neighborhood and this is my first time after a long time. The food was amazing, tasty, fresh, well plated. The waitress amazing ? she made our experience fun and I cannot wait to return. Go Peggie! I highly recommend the NY steak, so good, but you cannot be wrong with any items in the menu. The dessert so fresh and tasty.Great place to enjoy a great lunch or dinner with friends or family... Just go!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Sam Baker
Very nice dinner there. Service was excellent.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Vanessa S.
Went here for the first time 1 month ago. I should be ashamed of myself lived in the neighborhood my whole life and never been. Really good old fashioned cooking, service was great. Took a very long time for the food to come out don't come super hungry. The restaurant is well taken care of with a nice home like feeling.
4min33seconds
Wow. Was completely blown away. Food is incredible. Some of the most fresh seafood I’ve had anywhere in New York and one of the better meals I’ve had in the past month of 2 continents and 4 states, including Michelin restaurants. A+. The sole, scallops and even the onion soup were truly remarkable.
Loved the food and service, but the noise factor was horrible.Even in the back seating area, you can't have a
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Seafood Combo
Ken Musillo
Very disappointed the food was not so good two orders of fillet of sole filled with bones,chicken pallard with salad on top was overcooked and hard.As far as the fish the waiter said we get fresh fish here duh I should hope so but that does not answer why all the bones never going back.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 2
Service: 3
Diane D.
Terrible place poor service food absolutely disgusting stay away. Waitress a disaster took so long even to give us the bread basket which was completely stale. Do yourself a favor stay home and cook Negative zero
Scott G.
I've passed this place literally hundreds of times in my life. Never really thought much about it until I found it listed on Yelp last night with pretty good reviews. I called before going to ask someone if there was an available table for 4 (which there was ONE table left for us at opening time, 5pm), and if they use MSG in their food. It's a common misconception that one needs to worry about MSG only in Asian restaurants. Our friend at Erin's Isle said that it was unlikely that they do, and if they do, it would likely be very limited to certain things on their menu, as they make their own homemade stock. We agreed that if my step-mom, who is "allergic" to MSG, would go to the restaurant, we would double-check to make sure that her choices were MSG-free.We got there in no time flat, were seated immediately, and the waiter (same fellow who helped me on the phone) gave us the Specials. He has a way about him that made everything sound incredible, even with his thick accent that I had some trouble understanding! His service was quite good, even though he was distracted at times with conversation with other customers, and the busboys could definitely use some more training (instead of looking around the room for anyone who needs help, they tended to look at the floor or the ceiling or each other), but they were helpful upon request.The Onion Soup wasn't the best I've had, as it was a little sour for some reason, but I enjoyed it regardless... and the presentation was actually really nice, with a big piece of bread ON TOP with melted cheese on top of it. Never seen Onion Soup that way before. And this restaurant has pretty decent bread in the basket they put on your table when you arrive.I got a Stuffed Chicken special, which was spectacular, smothered with gravy and sauteed mushrooms. Yum. My wife loved her salad, and I apologize I don't know the name of it. The step-mom got the Chilean Sea Bass Special, which was beautifully prepared. I didn't try it but it looked superb, and she really liked it. She went home last night with no symptoms from MSG, so I presume all was good. My daughter got the Rigatoni Vodka, which was creamy but not really that great. All in all, this is a place I would return to, though I think I need to save some money up to do so!
Linda P.
It is very cozy!! The food is very good,portions are large and the waitstaff and bartenders are always friendly,efficient and welcoming.
Excellent food and service.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Chicken Francese
Good food and great
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Chicken Parm with Spaghetti
Friendly, personable waiters, Reservations recommended for dinner. Nicest table by the corner fireplace.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Steak Special, Baked Potato, Surf and Turf, Francaise, Baked Clams
We have been going to this bar regularly for 2 years! Enjoy most of the staff and the food has been on point!! The staff and many diners have remarked favorably about my 8 lb service animal.Today, a couple became angry and very nasty about my service animal calling me obscene names using vulgar language!The owner aware of my dog being a service animal asked us to leave!Evidently he has no notion of the American disability act!!
Food: 4
You will not be disappointed. The food is very good. The service is just as good. The food is consistently fabulous. I have been going there for years and have not had a bad meal there. Always enjoyable. Always looking forward to going back
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Interesting Irish pub with good Italian food!! The food is made to order fresh and very tasty. The staff is very friendly and accommodating. Nice bar area with good well drinks.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
I live in the neighborhood and this is my first time after a long time. The food was amazing, tasty, fresh, well plated. The waitress amazing ? she made our experience fun and I cannot wait to return. Go Peggie! I highly recommend the NY steak, so good, but you cannot be wrong with any items in the menu. The dessert so fresh and tasty.Great place to enjoy a great lunch or dinner with friends or family... Just go!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Very nice dinner there. Service was excellent.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Went here for the first time 1 month ago. I should be ashamed of myself lived in the neighborhood my whole life and never been. Really good old fashioned cooking, service was great. Took a very long time for the food to come out don't come super hungry. The restaurant is well taken care of with a nice home like feeling.
Wow. Was completely blown away. Food is incredible. Some of the most fresh seafood I’ve had anywhere in New York and one of the better meals I’ve had in the past month of 2 continents and 4 states, including Michelin restaurants. A+. The sole, scallops and even the onion soup were truly remarkable.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Sole Francese, Baked Clams
Restaurantji Recommends
Loved the food and service, but the noise factor was horrible.Even in the back seating area, you can't have a
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Seafood Combo
Very disappointed the food was not so good two orders of fillet of sole filled with bones,chicken pallard with salad on top was overcooked and hard.As far as the fish the waiter said we get fresh fish here duh I should hope so but that does not answer why all the bones never going back.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 2
Service: 3
Terrible place poor service food absolutely disgusting stay away. Waitress a disaster took so long even to give us the bread basket which was completely stale. Do yourself a favor stay home and cook Negative zero
I've passed this place literally hundreds of times in my life. Never really thought much about it until I found it listed on Yelp last night with pretty good reviews. I called before going to ask someone if there was an available table for 4 (which there was ONE table left for us at opening time, 5pm), and if they use MSG in their food. It's a common misconception that one needs to worry about MSG only in Asian restaurants. Our friend at Erin's Isle said that it was unlikely that they do, and if they do, it would likely be very limited to certain things on their menu, as they make their own homemade stock. We agreed that if my step-mom, who is "allergic" to MSG, would go to the restaurant, we would double-check to make sure that her choices were MSG-free.We got there in no time flat, were seated immediately, and the waiter (same fellow who helped me on the phone) gave us the Specials. He has a way about him that made everything sound incredible, even with his thick accent that I had some trouble understanding! His service was quite good, even though he was distracted at times with conversation with other customers, and the busboys could definitely use some more training (instead of looking around the room for anyone who needs help, they tended to look at the floor or the ceiling or each other), but they were helpful upon request.The Onion Soup wasn't the best I've had, as it was a little sour for some reason, but I enjoyed it regardless... and the presentation was actually really nice, with a big piece of bread ON TOP with melted cheese on top of it. Never seen Onion Soup that way before. And this restaurant has pretty decent bread in the basket they put on your table when you arrive.I got a Stuffed Chicken special, which was spectacular, smothered with gravy and sauteed mushrooms. Yum. My wife loved her salad, and I apologize I don't know the name of it. The step-mom got the Chilean Sea Bass Special, which was beautifully prepared. I didn't try it but it looked superb, and she really liked it. She went home last night with no symptoms from MSG, so I presume all was good. My daughter got the Rigatoni Vodka, which was creamy but not really that great. All in all, this is a place I would return to, though I think I need to save some money up to do so!
It is very cozy!! The food is very good,portions are large and the waitstaff and bartenders are always friendly,efficient and welcoming.