One-Eyed Cat Brewing

5893 Main St, Williamsville
(716) 204-8493

Recent Reviews

Molly Moran

We had a mini family reunion at One Eyed Cat Brewing and 10/10 would recommend this location for any of your event needs. Kinzie was incredible to work with and the event was well organized and perfectly executed. The food and drinks were wonderful. We’ll be back both for events and just to have a drink in a great space!

Perry J.

Excellent! Highly recommend. The brilsket is melt-in-your-mouth delicious! The portions are generous and the sides were tasty as well. We are new to the area and will make this a regular stop!

Lindsay Richter

Food and drinks were delicous! Will definalty be back!!

Geoff Schall

Great Brews. Great food, Great Atmosphere!

A R.

Nice selection of beer and other drinks. Good place to hang and have conversations with friends.

Jeff Pitts

Great food, great beer, nice selection and always rotating. The BBQ plates are good size and the atmosphere is cozy, clean and enjoyable.

Zach J

Stopped in for the first time last night and I was thoroughly impressed! Nice quiet, quaint, and cozy spot tucked away in the middle of Williamsville. Very welcoming, homey feel to the place - drank pretty much all of the lagers that they had to offer, my favorite being the german pilsner/lager “Pillow Talk”. This beer had the right balance of both malt and hop character.Kenzie the bartender was quick, attentive, and super friendly. She is definitely an asset to the business. I didn’t eat anything besides the french fries but the fries were tasty and honestly all of the food smelled and looked very good. I think that the kitchen and the brewery/taproom might be two separate businesses so that might be something to consider upon arrival but as I said before, the food that I had was good and everything that I saw come out of the kitchen looked on par with the food that I had.My only complaint about this place would be the parking/parking lot or lack thereof. I definitely will be back, this spot would honestly is an ideal place to watch a Bills game or grab a drink/bite to eat after work. Cheers ?

Sara K.

I've been wanting to try their BBQ since I heard their commercial on the radio and finally got the opportunity. My friend joined me and neither of us drink much alcohol so we were strictly there for food. There is no wait staff. I was glad they brought our food out to us, at least, but basically you can order from the table by scanning the code and grab your food from the pick up window or order from the bar when ready. So after sitting and deciding our meal we went up to the bar. We waited a moment and a staff member took our order. To be noted: they do not have drinks on tap, like Pepsi or Coke. The explanation was that there simply is no room. Can't order a jack and coke for example. They do have bottled Stewart's soda. There is no diet soda option. There weren't a lot of food options. And 2 choices were marked sold out. I was still happy with my options and meal. Our food didn't take long at all. I enjoyed the brisket (chose two sauces) and my two sides (mac and cheese and loaded potato salad). For the sauces, I had the OG BBQ and Tennessee Red. The red was a little spicy but nothing overwhelming. Both were good. They had about 5 more sauce options to choose from. To finish checking out, we had to stand at the bar and wait. That's probably the only thing I didn't like was not having wait staff or drink refills. Otherwise, both staff and patrons were very polite and personable. Even though it looks fancy on the outside it's casual. You can dress up or down and be perfectly fine there. They had a TV up with trivia questions too.

John Kwiecinski

Great beer and good variety. Food was fantastic. Not loud like other breweries. Good place to meet friends and family. My new favorite place.

JRT OUTDOORS

Great beers, good atmosphere! The beers were all great and we had a good time there. The food from pork belly bbq was great as well!

Brian L.

Great beer with good selection. Ryan, the bartender was great and help us with our selection of beers. We had Cajun sweet potato tots, which were awesome. There is also a good BBQ menu. Has both inside and outside seating, very nice small place. I would definitely recommend this place to anyone.

Jeffrey ODonnell

Very unique interior for a tap room and they make it work quite well. Good outside seating area when the weather cooperates. Good menu and beers I’ve tried have all been excellent.

M. Klein

Have driven by a lot of times and never had the opportunity to check it out. Happened to be up in that direction and noticed a nice outdoor patio with some cozy lighting and a fire pit. So we had to stop in and check it out.I was impressed with the indoor space. Bigger than I thought. The outside has an older ambiance, whereas the inside has a more modern feel. Our bartender was really friendly and the staff there did a great job.The drinks are reasonable. There is a BBQ restaurant attached/inside the space that was only serving lite snacks when we were there. So I can only speak to the beer and seltzer that we had. Both were really good! If you want a place to relax on a patio or inside, it's a solid option.The only things preventing it from being a five star is just some aesthetics / touch-up work, cleaning the gutters that had little trees starting to grow out of them, etc. Small things. But definitely a cool spot!

Dad of three boys

Very unique interior for a tap room and they make it work quite well. Good outside seating area when the weather cooperates. Good menu and beers I’ve tried have all been excellent.

Lauren S.

Awesome beers, great service, love the spacious outdoor area- definitely a hidden gem!

Load More