The Irishman Pub and Eatery

5601 Main St, Williamsville
(716) 626-2670

Recent Reviews

complicatedland

A little bit noisy inside, consider another option if you are looking for a dinner with some conversation. Food and beer are ok.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 5

Service: 4

Teresa F.

St. Patrick's Day weekend...great band (The Rig), bartenders at outdoor bar were so friendly. 10 of us get a table at the last minute in a packed bar. Food was so good. Everything came out hot and fresh. Irish Onion soup is a must! Loved our whole experience!

Mark

I stopped here last summer with my brother during a trip back home to Buffalo. In defense, it was one of those music nights that all the bars and restaurants had in the area, and I think it was a Thursday evening. REALLY cool atmosphere, but we tired for fifteen minutes, after making our way to the bar, AT the bar, just to get two beers. After ignoring us to get to others who were already served and sitting at the bar, the barmaid finally got us a round. We should have purchased three because the rest of the attempts were fruitless. They had so many people there and the barmaids decided to all of a sudden abandon the bar to help carry out food from the kitchen. We just ended up leaving. I get it though; they were SUPER busy, but at least put a couple more people on when you have a gorgeous summer evening with bands playing. Really a turn off, to be honest.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 3

Service: 2

Ann Marie Didio-Harbin

We went there when it wasn't very busy and our service was horrible. Their menu is uninspired. If you're looking for a typical bar food then this is the place they go.

John K.

We've been here with big groups two times. The second time we reserved the big back room. The food is good. I had the beef on weck on a gluten free role, which had salt on the top, which was a treat. The service was very good. The ambience is a standard, comfortable Irish pub. A good place to spend time with family on a cold night.

Allen M.

I had the Mac and cheese. Very cheesy! But the grilled chicken on top was overcooked. My wife had the fish tacos and said they were slightly better than ok. Service was young and inexperienced but got the job done. Ambience was ok, a basic Irish pub. Outdoor live music in the summer is great though.

Tony Geitgey

Beef on Weck was amazing. Awesome drink - Screwed Up Irishman...soooo good.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Beef on Weck

Chris Polus

We had a company outing there. Services was great. Food was good and the kept it coming. Happy hour specials are real good. Worth going for happy hour.

Katherine Coffey

My family and I hosted my father’s memorial luncheon in the back room last Saturday. I plan a number of events for work and I couldn’t speak more highly of an experience, especially during a difficult time. From the minute we walked in there Michael welcomed us, sat down to review menu and package options (unlike other restaurants I connected with). He even provided us a sample of a menu item to clear up some confusion. He treated us as though we were his family, reached out a few times leading up to the event to check in on our needs and was beyond flexible with understanding the nature of the event and uncertainty of attendance. His staff did a wonderful job setting up the event space for us with flowers, photos, and memorabilia that I dropped off. Food was fantastic, drinks a plenty, all while preparing for the blizzard conditions that were approaching. Truly one of the best customer experiences I have ever experienced!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Irish Spring Rolls, Caesar Salad, Beef on Weck

Niccole Jefferlone

We love this place. Best Cobb salad in Buffalo!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: The Reuben, Ruben

Jessica R.

We do enjoy this place but the food was just ok nothing crazy special. The service was fast for a Saturday lunch hour and we enjoyed being able to sit wherever we wanted as it wasn't crowded. We would like to go back for another day to try more options. We had fun and the beer was great.

Nancy Lesswing

Wonderful onion soup!!!!!! DelishGreat service

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 3

Service: 4

Recommended dishes: Fries, Fish and Chips

James

The last time I went my Guinness didn't taste correct but every other time it's right. But I like this place been going since 2013

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 4

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Fries, Fish and Chips

Geoff Schall

We were there for New Years Eve, so it's not the best time for a review. Food was cool (Irish Meatloaf and gravy was congealed). Food was a little over salted.Parking: Parking lot for six cars. Unsure if any are designated for handicap.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 4

Service: 5

Debbi Clemens

We just celebrated Nollaig Na MBan - Women’s Little Christmas on January 6 th here.The service Reilly gave our group of 15 was excellent and the food was tasty! We will be coming back again soon.Parking: There’s street parking plus city lots also.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Chicken Pot Pie, Bangers and Mash, Shepherd's Pie

Load More