Yotality

5759 Main St, Williamsville
(716) 276-3268

Recent Reviews

Tamara R.

Ew. The floors are so filthy that they make squelching sounds as your feet stick to them. The walls and machines are filthy and needs to be wiped down, same with chairs. The basic lack of regard for health and hygiene made me really uneasy, but I'd just had an MRI and i wanted a treat darn it. Sadly, the flavors tasted wildly chemical. The young lady behind the counter, howeve, was helpful and sweet. Deep wipes downs of all surfaces a couple times a day would make a big difference in the skeevy atmosphere, but the flavors need a natural overhaul.

Ashley R.

I would go back as this is the only frozen yogurt place close by for me. The first frozen yogurt place I went to while living in Florida was Menchie's frozen yogurt (there is one that is in Canada). Anyways, there was frendly service, but in the second visit the person checking us out was also trying to check out and keep up with her FaceTime conversation with her friend. Sadly Menchies's had little sample cups with little spoons so you knew what kind of flavor you were getting and if you liked it. The service here didn't look like they even offered such a thing so it was basically good luck hopefully you enjoyed the flavors/flavor that you picked. And Menchies had such a better inviting atmosphere and layout. Inside Yotottaly looked bland and a rush paint job on the walls and lots of empty space especially near the front entrance. Menchies was super colorful inside. I will be back as my kids love the frozen yogurt and picking of your own toppings. But I definitely do prefer Menchies over Yotottaly.

Lady Lightning98

Love these self-serve frozen yogurt shops!Several flavors to choose from & a great selection of toppings. Eat in or take out.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Frozen Yogurt, Frozen Yogurt with Lots of Toppings

Kim Haas

I wish there were other

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Frozen Yogurt with Lots of Toppings

Izzy M

Amazing froyo / ice cream place, toppings are usually delicious. I’ve been coming here for years. However, it was never really been the same after COVID. Always seem to have flavors and toppings missing, costs went up a ton… I don’t blame the employees, not really. The food is still good, though. So I would recommend coming here (just, y’know, not all the time. unless you’re okay with getting diabetes lol)!

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 5

Service: 4

Cheesy Chick

Great time, food and staff. Oscar liked it too.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Ava Crawford

Maybe if you say close at 9pm, be loyal about it. We travelled 30 mins and got there at 6:30 and all the lights were off and no one answered when we called

Cathy Olmstead

Ice cream to go.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Frozen Yogurt with Lots of Toppings, Yogurt Sundae

Tim Mondello

Build your own sundaes.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 4

Recommended dishes: Frozen Yogurt, Frozen Yogurt with Lots of Toppings

Sally Or

Plenty of flavors and toppings.

Alice Kreiter

My first time - great

Amber Duman

Very clean exceptional customer service and very safe and child friendly environment

Lynn K

Many different flavors of yogurt all are very good choices with lots of toppings to choose from.

Tammy E.

So many flavors! Without the swirl option between every two handles this operation offers many more flavors than the usual fro-yo establishment. I was pleasantly surprised by how creamy all of the options were. In our 4 days in town I made two trips to this place - it made my day each visit! The only negative part of this place was the parking - it is around the back and could be a pain in rainy or snowy months. Wouldn't stop me coming here, though!

Shaliza Szuba

This is a very relaxing and pretty place to bring the family to try different flavors of frozen yogurts, gelatos and Italian ices. It’s a build-your-own dessert experience and they even give you the opportunity to sample before buying. We enjoyed making the right selection! They change the selection as they get new desserts. We love the experience but wish they had smaller dishes instead of the only big size bowl. The young woman at the counter was very sweet and helpful. Giving it four stars because we only wanted a small treats because it was close to dinner time and didn’t want to waste a big cardboard bowl.

Load More