No way he responded to someone "i don't have time to read it" that's the only reason i gave 5 starseven though not melting cheese should be a crime.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Cindy Diepenhorst
Drove 3 hours to get this pizza. Was not disappointed at all. Was raised on dicarlos in west virginia and saw this was closer. Definitely worth the
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Tray of Pizza
Alex Cochran
I wish I had visited sooner! I love pizza, and this restaurant has some of the best pizza I have ever had. It is sliced in squares, but larger than usual sheet pizzas, has the cheese added after it comes out of the oven, and has minimal sauce. They only offer pepperoni and banana peppers as toppings, but the pizza would be just fine plain, to be honest. The crust is NOT GREASY, and neither is the cheese. I'm really impressed and will be a repeat customer. They sell by the slice, and the slices are filling. They also have great pepperoni rolls and a delightful marinara sauce. Great vibe inside and cool staff who seem to really be passionate about their food. 10/10 a real hidden gem!Vegetarian options: You can order cheese or banana peppers for your toppings.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pep Roll
Lisa Altschuler
Grew up in the Valley. Wellsburg and Elm Grove are my measuring sticks. I live in Medina now, so I grabbed a tray for my friends from Follansbee who also live here.You guys nailed it. The crust was even and perfect - this is my biggest issue with other DiCarlos in the Valley.Sauce, pepperoni and cheese tasted just as I remember from home.If yinz know, yinz know... The Falls location definitely knows.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
David Lewis
Love the original pizza here. I paid for 2 slices and they showed Love ❤️.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Matt
Ok - you either like Ohio Valley style pizza or you don't. My wife grew up along the Ohio River, so to her this was just how pizza was - partially melted cheese and a choice between pepperoni, pepperoni, or pepperoni. While it isn't my personal favorite (NYC thin for me), it is a great change of pace, and the crust is really good - crispy on the outside with some fluff in the center. I also like supporting local businesses.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Roll
David Neal
I’m From Marrins Ferry and we had one in town so I grew up on DiCarlos. Worked there in high school, my brother managed it. The Akron location was good when it opened, but has gone down hill ever since, very inconsistent . I’ve never left a review on anyplace, and never thought I would ever leave a bad review for DiCarlos. Hope the Dicarlo family ( Amazing Family) does an intervention soon before their name is tarnished. If you want to experience true Dicarlos, take a trip down to Wheeling or Stubenville and you will experience true Ohio Valley Pizza. Tonight was the last time over paying for someone to ruin my favorite pizza. Leaving this review because this is not true DiCarlos pizza. Some people may like it…. Just not me. Good luck and i hope you get it right soon, for the sake of the Dicarlo name.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Bambi Olschager
I lived in Wintersville and always looked forward to when I ordered Dicarlo's. My favorite day was pizza day at school. They always had Dicarlo's. Haven't tried this one yet but I live fairly far away from this location and have to figure out how to get it home hot.
LeStraTele
Okay. You need to know before you order here, this is a little different than most pizza you are used to. They only offer a couple of toppings, pepperoni, and banana peppers. The cheese is added after the pizza is cooked. (I assume. It isn't melted or browned). But if you are up for trying something different, this is worth it. Nice crust and excellent sauce. The people working there are very nice too.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza
Jules Ginaldi
Moving to area from Philly and needed to accomplish two very important items, 1. find a house and 2. find a pizza place. After trying a few in the area I stopped in DiCarlo's and it will be my new pizza stop. Love the dough, sauce is fantastic and an overall great pie! Glad I stopped in....
Grew up on Ohio Valley pizza and it's far and few left around . Moved to Akron about 5 years ago and there are many great pizza places but nothing like this! Wow exactly what I have been craving and searching for around this area for years. Crunchy thin crust . I can taste the garlic in the sauce . The fresh grated cheese and cold to luck warm pepperoni. It's simple and amazing ! The service was also great . He was very nice and pizza was ready within minutes. He even brought it out to us when it was ready. This will now be one of my top choices for pizza. Thank you for simplicity of perfection. ?
Darren Plotts
It was really good I grew up in south east ohio we had 4 DiCarlo's and couldn't wait to go try this one and they knocked it out of the park
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
austin
I understand it’s a different style of pizza but ewww gross. My pizza was cold as were the toppings (which the toppings are supposed to be so that part is fine) i also got a pepperoni roll. The sauce and crust are both gross and I have regrets after eating it. Ive never left a review this soon, I literally just finished my last bite of the pepperoni roll, which was slightly below average but infinitely better than the pizza. I’d advise you stay away; there are much better places nearby. As an added bonus, the premises smelled like cigarettes when I picked up my food and while two of the employees were nice (prepping food) the guy at the register instantly left as i came in the door with only a grumble towards my direction (perhaps he needed a smoke!).
Andrew Edwards
As a New Yorker from Brooklyn, one can appreciate a Pizza shop (in OHIO) that can provide a couple a slices and quick can of Cherry Coke. They even bring it to your car while you wait. Also get the extra cheese, the put nice layer of freshly shredded mozzarella for a unique twist. Absolutely recommend ?
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Heather Dantuma
Did not expect the Ohio Valley style pizza to be good, but this is now easily one favorite pizzas.
No way he responded to someone "i don't have time to read it" that's the only reason i gave 5 starseven though not melting cheese should be a crime.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Drove 3 hours to get this pizza. Was not disappointed at all. Was raised on dicarlos in west virginia and saw this was closer. Definitely worth the
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Tray of Pizza
I wish I had visited sooner! I love pizza, and this restaurant has some of the best pizza I have ever had. It is sliced in squares, but larger than usual sheet pizzas, has the cheese added after it comes out of the oven, and has minimal sauce. They only offer pepperoni and banana peppers as toppings, but the pizza would be just fine plain, to be honest. The crust is NOT GREASY, and neither is the cheese. I'm really impressed and will be a repeat customer. They sell by the slice, and the slices are filling. They also have great pepperoni rolls and a delightful marinara sauce. Great vibe inside and cool staff who seem to really be passionate about their food. 10/10 a real hidden gem!Vegetarian options: You can order cheese or banana peppers for your toppings.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pep Roll
Grew up in the Valley. Wellsburg and Elm Grove are my measuring sticks. I live in Medina now, so I grabbed a tray for my friends from Follansbee who also live here.You guys nailed it. The crust was even and perfect - this is my biggest issue with other DiCarlos in the Valley.Sauce, pepperoni and cheese tasted just as I remember from home.If yinz know, yinz know... The Falls location definitely knows.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Love the original pizza here. I paid for 2 slices and they showed Love ❤️.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Ok - you either like Ohio Valley style pizza or you don't. My wife grew up along the Ohio River, so to her this was just how pizza was - partially melted cheese and a choice between pepperoni, pepperoni, or pepperoni. While it isn't my personal favorite (NYC thin for me), it is a great change of pace, and the crust is really good - crispy on the outside with some fluff in the center. I also like supporting local businesses.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Roll
I’m From Marrins Ferry and we had one in town so I grew up on DiCarlos. Worked there in high school, my brother managed it. The Akron location was good when it opened, but has gone down hill ever since, very inconsistent . I’ve never left a review on anyplace, and never thought I would ever leave a bad review for DiCarlos. Hope the Dicarlo family ( Amazing Family) does an intervention soon before their name is tarnished. If you want to experience true Dicarlos, take a trip down to Wheeling or Stubenville and you will experience true Ohio Valley Pizza. Tonight was the last time over paying for someone to ruin my favorite pizza. Leaving this review because this is not true DiCarlos pizza. Some people may like it…. Just not me. Good luck and i hope you get it right soon, for the sake of the Dicarlo name.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
I lived in Wintersville and always looked forward to when I ordered Dicarlo's. My favorite day was pizza day at school. They always had Dicarlo's. Haven't tried this one yet but I live fairly far away from this location and have to figure out how to get it home hot.
Okay. You need to know before you order here, this is a little different than most pizza you are used to. They only offer a couple of toppings, pepperoni, and banana peppers. The cheese is added after the pizza is cooked. (I assume. It isn't melted or browned). But if you are up for trying something different, this is worth it. Nice crust and excellent sauce. The people working there are very nice too.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza
Moving to area from Philly and needed to accomplish two very important items, 1. find a house and 2. find a pizza place. After trying a few in the area I stopped in DiCarlo's and it will be my new pizza stop. Love the dough, sauce is fantastic and an overall great pie! Glad I stopped in....
Restaurantji Recommends
Grew up on Ohio Valley pizza and it's far and few left around . Moved to Akron about 5 years ago and there are many great pizza places but nothing like this! Wow exactly what I have been craving and searching for around this area for years. Crunchy thin crust . I can taste the garlic in the sauce . The fresh grated cheese and cold to luck warm pepperoni. It's simple and amazing ! The service was also great . He was very nice and pizza was ready within minutes. He even brought it out to us when it was ready. This will now be one of my top choices for pizza. Thank you for simplicity of perfection. ?
It was really good I grew up in south east ohio we had 4 DiCarlo's and couldn't wait to go try this one and they knocked it out of the park
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I understand it’s a different style of pizza but ewww gross. My pizza was cold as were the toppings (which the toppings are supposed to be so that part is fine) i also got a pepperoni roll. The sauce and crust are both gross and I have regrets after eating it. Ive never left a review this soon, I literally just finished my last bite of the pepperoni roll, which was slightly below average but infinitely better than the pizza. I’d advise you stay away; there are much better places nearby. As an added bonus, the premises smelled like cigarettes when I picked up my food and while two of the employees were nice (prepping food) the guy at the register instantly left as i came in the door with only a grumble towards my direction (perhaps he needed a smoke!).
As a New Yorker from Brooklyn, one can appreciate a Pizza shop (in OHIO) that can provide a couple a slices and quick can of Cherry Coke. They even bring it to your car while you wait. Also get the extra cheese, the put nice layer of freshly shredded mozzarella for a unique twist. Absolutely recommend ?
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Did not expect the Ohio Valley style pizza to be good, but this is now easily one favorite pizzas.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5