Papa Johns Pizza

2271 Kresge Dr, Amherst
(440) 282-7272

Recent Reviews

Juan Martinez

Pizza is a little bit under cooked.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 3

Service: 4

William McCormack

Idk what they changed.. but even their cheesey bread was trash. It was warm but not good.. ended up tossing almost all of it cheesy bread

Food: 1

Service: 2

ᗩntonia ᙅaroline

Floppy undercooked

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 1

Service: 3

brittany hembree

My crust was raw and my jalapeño bites

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 2

Service: 4

Recommended dishes: Cheese Pizza

Eryn Macmahan

Spent $50 on an online order, never received an order confirmation, called the store only to be told they never received the order and to call a 1800 number they were going to give us. Called the 1800 number and the woman on the phone said they found our order it was a technical error and she was going to manually put it in. Received a call back 15 minutes later saying the store was “temporarily closed” & a refund was being done and I’d receive the money in 5-7 days….

Service: 1

Ryan Kasubinski

Just another pizza joint in Ohio with stupid hillbillies running it.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 3

Veda Beasley

The employees were great. The pizza sucks. Ordered the Shakaroni. It's nothing like they advertise. Crust was thin, hardly no toppings and payed an extra $3 for sausage. Couldn't taste the cheese, not even sure if it had cheese. I know I won't be going back there. And my father said h would rather have Marcos pizza before he orders there again.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 1

Service: 4

Sarah Wicked

We've been back 2 in a month. We had to give them a little break service had gotten a little slack We had a few orders with issues, But we're are back and food tastes better than ever. Just tried the Mike's hot honey pepperoni. ..so good!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Hawaiian BBQ Chicken

Angela Soto

This pizza taste nothing like it did in the 90s. It taste like a 2nd grader made it. Even little Cesar's is better.

Food: 1

Adam Ramos

I haven't eaten papa John's in years and figured out why today what I had was a gas station pizza not good and to top it off it went right through me and heart burn all night P.Johns gets an F ......garbage

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 1

Service: 4

Melany Aviles

Do not order from them. I specifically told the guy that answered the phone that I never used my credit and he went on to tell me I did. He was rude and told me that I did use my credit when I didn’t. They want to give you an attitude while doing it. This is not the first time somebody has giving me an attitude and I have also been hung up on by them as well. I’m done getting food from them. Never had to leave a bad review for somebody before. I’m fed up.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

vCloutedx16

Great pizza and service, but I’m thinking they need to invest in a new pizza slicer, I always have to rip the pieces apart, slow down and make eatable cuts … thank youParking: No parking period

Tom VanSickle

Hadn't tried a Papa John's pizza for some time and have to say it was a pleasant surprise . Nice

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 5

Ricky DC

Do not order from the Papa John's on Southside Drive in Louisville Kentucky. They are thieves. They stole over $30 from me by not delivering pizza I had ordered. I called customer service on 2 different occasions to get this resolved and I still have not been refunded my money. They stole my money and it seems as though I am not getting it back. I do not know what else to do besides put this warning out to others to possibly keep you from being a victim of this shady business. Do not do business with these crooks. Please, Do Not do business at the Southside Drive Papa John's in Louisville Kentucky.

Ohio Man

Missed getting Papa Johns I used to get it all the time when they delivered in my area, They don't deliver that far, farthest is like 3 or 4 streets over. So only way to get it is to drive all the way across town. Had very little issues with my orders, a time or two I would get wrong order, other than seldom issues the pizza's were spot on.

Load More