Keystone's Mac Shack - Athens

14 S Court St, Athens
(740) 331-4272

Recent Reviews

Luke Postell

Food was good. Upset about the pricing. You shouldn't have a big thing in the window that says "1/2 price mac monday" when you have to order a drink to get half off. The cheapest drink being $3 kind of defeats the purpose of the half off. I was rung out for $30 and I asked them about the discount and they said I had to have a drink, and then it only came down to $25.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 5

Service: 2

Lunchboxeat

the prices are a little to much for me but the food is not that bad

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 4

Heuei Hejeiwi

Subpar food at best. The service was so bad it was actually

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 2

Service: 1

Lacie S.

We visited when we were on campus to see our daughter. Service was fast and Mac & Cheese was served hot. Everything was delicious. I just wish I would have ordered the smaller size. Oh well, had leftovers for later!

Rich W

Tasted ok, but wasn’t very hot, probably why me and my coworker both had food poisoning all night from it.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 1

Service: 3

LameStudiosInc

Great food, great drinks, cordial service, quick preparation time and open late. Flawless spot to hit after a bar crawl.

Kannon Seif

Truly a fantastic experience. I came here to see the game with my friends and band mates. The food was fantastic(I had the Black Sabbath.) there was only one person working there but was really nice. And the little tv showing trivia questions kept us entertained until our food was ready. Truly a great time?

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Brisket

Rusty Greenich

The Mac was decent if you are a drunk college student but If you are looking for a good meal I do not recommend the Mac was plain as hell the cookies where hard as bricks like I couldn’t even take a bite out of them best bet is to go to big mamas right beside it??‍♀️

Josie M.

Good mac and cheese. Definitely not worth the high price. Paid an extra $3 than normal ($16 total) for my order today, Sunday 10/29. Assuming prices were increased for Halloween weekend, but the higher prices were not posted anywhere within the restaurant or outside on the door/window. Very disappointed.

Finite

This is something only people who are suffering from alcohol poisoning will say is good. I guess there’s a reason it’s open until 4 AM.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 1

Service: 5

Angel Menkhaus

I absolutely adored it here, Ive been wanting to check out this place for so long but the reviews made me a bit nervous. Went in on a Monday after a long shift and was treated like royalty by the staff. Night crew❤️! Food was incredible and I will be coming back! Seriously great value in a college Town no excuses not to make this a tradition.If you haven't tried this place since opening give it another shot!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Rainbow Wolf

Heard such great things about this place so figured yea sure let's try it. Went with the classic mac n cheese, no meats, nothing fancy, just to compare flavors of other "plain" macaroni and cheese. Paid roughly $7 for a very small amount. First bite was a huge let down. It wasn't creamy, wasn't hot, not fresh, and really didn't have any flavor at all. Have honestly had better experience with a box of "Great value brand" macaroni and cheese that's only 52 cents a box. Even KFC has better macaroni.

Food: 1

Tina B.

I just found the best mac-n-cheese I've ever eaten, including my own made from scratch! I'm so glad I accidentally found this place. I tried the Black Sabbath; smoked bacon, mushrooms, and cheddar cheese. It was absolutely delicious!! This is a must try for all you macaroni and cheese lovers! You won't be disappointed.

Maddie W.

A nice place to get some comfort mac n cheese. Although it needs some more spices, the Mac is nice over all. I don't really like the tins they come in only because it has burnt my hand in the past. People who work here are nice. I would probably take it to go instead of dine in only because the music is very loud.

Lou Teixido

First time eating here. Young lady behind the counter is very kind and helpful. Mac and cheese is absolutely delicious.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Side of Cheese Sauce

Load More

Keystone's Mac Shack - Athens

14 S Court St, Athens, OH 45701
(740) 331-4272