Sadley the pizza was terrible, no sauce and burnt on top. It was like eating dough. Got this on 9/15/22. Not sure I would try again. Got the square pizza with ham. So disappointed in this pizza...
Sarah Hovsepian
Really great pizza but they do not wear gloves
Sarah h
Amazing pizza but they mess up our order sometimes and do not wear gloves
Neil Waite
This place was awesome for a long time, as of late the effort put in by staff has gone to hell though. When the daily special changed from larges to mediums sucked but understandable with the way business are hurting lately, but doesn’t make sense for how they handle the rest of their business.Wanted to use a “buy one pizza get one free” coupon tonight, after putting in the order they say can’t do the deal with mac & cheese pizza because it costs more. So I tell them I’ll pay the price of the pizza that would cost more and instead of getting one of equal value I would get one of lesser value… but this business doesn’t get it, even after explaining it to them that it’s a better deal for them than me buying two lesser pizzas for the lesser cost.You guys were an awesome for a long time but the staff that’s been up there for last couple months is set on doing bare minimum effort, even when it’s at the benefit to the business. Plenty other pizza places close by, what made you the one I picked of them is long gone.Also, your pizza is ALWAYS slightly undercooked and always has been. Awesome heated in oven the next day, but the night of bringing it home… undercooked every time.
Jennifer M.
Our food was amazing! First time here...and got a deluxe & pepperoni pizzas- full of toppings, crust was delicious. Got wings- super huge & meaty...then don't forget the pepperoni knots which were equally awesome. Got packets of Ranch dressing & extra sauces with our order without asking. Completely worth the $$, will be our go to place now. Thanks for the great service!
Samuel Kline
If you would like your pizza to look and taste like cardboard 2 hours after ordering, this is the shop for you! Canned and frozen toppings, acidic flavorless sauce and low quality provolone cheese will greet you when you open the box, at a price higher than most. Please take your money elsewhere.
Andrew Eberhart
My wife and I try a new pizza place every week (and go back to the good ones). Gave D’Tutanelli’s a shot tonight. We won’t be back. Two hours until we got our pizza and a half hour longer after they called and told us it would be 45 min. Pizza and sub are just ok, not hot at all. My wife called to check on delivery time and was told she “throwing a fit” when the employee gave the phone to his boss. Do yourself a favor and drive a bit to go to Sauced or CLE Pie. You won’t be disappointed there. Pizza is too competitive of a business to settle for a place like D’Tutanelli’s.
Matt Larsen
Great pizza at a reasonable price. Better than other pizzas in the area and we always order from here.
Leslie Speigle
First time ordering from D'Turanelli's. We ordered the backyard BBQ pizza. Family thought it was one of the best pizzas ever. The staff was very friendly when we picked up the pizza. We LL be going back for sure
Shannon Mchaffie
This was a joke waited an hour and a half for pizza that looks like cardboard and barley looks cooked it was my first time trying because I read good reviews but this is awful I’ve had better frozen pizzas I’m so disappointed and I paid almost $30 for one large cheese pizza and 6 wings this is terrible! I’ve never bought a pizza home that I had to cook
Some good pizza, the sauce was tangy and a bit sweet! However the small pizza box has no signage on it, completely blank. So you can't really show off where you I'm got it from.
Reed Fabek
Great local, privately owned pizza shop. They have a broad menu with sandwiches, chicken, appetizers and more. Their breadstick seasoning is absolutely phenomenal!
Eric V
My go-to pizza place. Every time I order from here the pizzas are consistently good!
Emily Doglio
Tried last night for the first time. The cauliflower crust pizza was phenomenal. Definitely ordering from here again. The website was user friendly to order from and delivery was here in a half hour. 5⭐️
Jessica Balmert
I am literally 3.6 miles away from this place but because my address says Sheffield lake they called and cancelled my order. I have a baby and cannot pick up.. horrible customer service. You should know the area you are serving. You cannot drive 3.6 miles to deliver a 40 dollar order and we order all the time but I guess not from here.
Sadley the pizza was terrible, no sauce and burnt on top. It was like eating dough. Got this on 9/15/22. Not sure I would try again. Got the square pizza with ham. So disappointed in this pizza...
Really great pizza but they do not wear gloves
Amazing pizza but they mess up our order sometimes and do not wear gloves
This place was awesome for a long time, as of late the effort put in by staff has gone to hell though. When the daily special changed from larges to mediums sucked but understandable with the way business are hurting lately, but doesn’t make sense for how they handle the rest of their business.Wanted to use a “buy one pizza get one free” coupon tonight, after putting in the order they say can’t do the deal with mac & cheese pizza because it costs more. So I tell them I’ll pay the price of the pizza that would cost more and instead of getting one of equal value I would get one of lesser value… but this business doesn’t get it, even after explaining it to them that it’s a better deal for them than me buying two lesser pizzas for the lesser cost.You guys were an awesome for a long time but the staff that’s been up there for last couple months is set on doing bare minimum effort, even when it’s at the benefit to the business. Plenty other pizza places close by, what made you the one I picked of them is long gone.Also, your pizza is ALWAYS slightly undercooked and always has been. Awesome heated in oven the next day, but the night of bringing it home… undercooked every time.
Our food was amazing! First time here...and got a deluxe & pepperoni pizzas- full of toppings, crust was delicious. Got wings- super huge & meaty...then don't forget the pepperoni knots which were equally awesome. Got packets of Ranch dressing & extra sauces with our order without asking. Completely worth the $$, will be our go to place now. Thanks for the great service!
If you would like your pizza to look and taste like cardboard 2 hours after ordering, this is the shop for you! Canned and frozen toppings, acidic flavorless sauce and low quality provolone cheese will greet you when you open the box, at a price higher than most. Please take your money elsewhere.
My wife and I try a new pizza place every week (and go back to the good ones). Gave D’Tutanelli’s a shot tonight. We won’t be back. Two hours until we got our pizza and a half hour longer after they called and told us it would be 45 min. Pizza and sub are just ok, not hot at all. My wife called to check on delivery time and was told she “throwing a fit” when the employee gave the phone to his boss. Do yourself a favor and drive a bit to go to Sauced or CLE Pie. You won’t be disappointed there. Pizza is too competitive of a business to settle for a place like D’Tutanelli’s.
Great pizza at a reasonable price. Better than other pizzas in the area and we always order from here.
First time ordering from D'Turanelli's. We ordered the backyard BBQ pizza. Family thought it was one of the best pizzas ever. The staff was very friendly when we picked up the pizza. We LL be going back for sure
This was a joke waited an hour and a half for pizza that looks like cardboard and barley looks cooked it was my first time trying because I read good reviews but this is awful I’ve had better frozen pizzas I’m so disappointed and I paid almost $30 for one large cheese pizza and 6 wings this is terrible! I’ve never bought a pizza home that I had to cook
Restaurantji Recommends
Some good pizza, the sauce was tangy and a bit sweet! However the small pizza box has no signage on it, completely blank. So you can't really show off where you I'm got it from.
Great local, privately owned pizza shop. They have a broad menu with sandwiches, chicken, appetizers and more. Their breadstick seasoning is absolutely phenomenal!
My go-to pizza place. Every time I order from here the pizzas are consistently good!
Tried last night for the first time. The cauliflower crust pizza was phenomenal. Definitely ordering from here again. The website was user friendly to order from and delivery was here in a half hour. 5⭐️
I am literally 3.6 miles away from this place but because my address says Sheffield lake they called and cancelled my order. I have a baby and cannot pick up.. horrible customer service. You should know the area you are serving. You cannot drive 3.6 miles to deliver a 40 dollar order and we order all the time but I guess not from here.