Papa Johns Pizza

922 Wooster Road North, Barberton
(330) 861-0909

Recent Reviews

Derek Hannen

The worst ordering experience of any pizza store I've interacted with. I called to order a pizza and got a computer instead of a human. It couldn't place my order, so it transferred me to speak with a human. I thought it was just gonna call the store. Nope. Call center in India. After I explained my order to the call center employee he put me on hold. Their hold music is a loud obnoxious ad that loops over and over. After like 10 minutes I finally placed my order and got one pizza (it wasn't that good). In every single step of the process I could feel the filthy tendrils of a massive corporation making it harder than it had to be. I will never order from a Papa John's again.

Breesha Taylor

Idk what is but I love their dough & their sauce is great

hootie1111

Not what I expected from the commercials used to go years ago, and it was very good. Not so much now kinda bland and garlic butter was not garlic kinda confused about it all, sorry but I call em like I see em.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 3

Service: 5

Kristie Grimes

Ordered a pizza and Papa bites and they were not fully cooked still very doughy in center. Also ordered boneless wings, which were just a chicken nuggets with sauce drizzled over them, they were not even tossed in a sauce. Was nothing like the picture displayed online. was a waste of money and ended up being unable to eat any of the food

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 1

Service: 4

Bri Roberts

I ordered the heart shaped pizza, hot wings, and boneless wings. The pizza was so thin and pathetic my 9 year old and 13 year old wouldn’t even eat it. They love pizza! The traditional wings were so chewy and disgusting and there was a huge fatty piece that I couldn’t understand why it was in the wings. The only true edible part were the boneless wings, the entire meal was cold. Awful never again. I also had to cut it myself.

Food: 1

shat zee

What can u say Papa John's! Personally think is one of the best pizzas out there! Of course my favorite one. Here is the thing crust BBQ chicken. Omg it's the best! It's always I recommend calling in or ordering online before you go so you don't have the long wait. Button doing so. I had a hard time understanding the foreigner on the other side who said they spoke English but it was very broken up and very difficult to understand. Other than that it was a good experience

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 4

Treegs

I don't know what happened to Papa Johns, but not only have they gone downhill, they rolled through the city dump on the way down.I would swear I just spent $15 on a frozen, microwaved pizza. I asked for well done, but got an undercooked "pizza" that looks like a 5 year old cut it.Avoid this Papa Johns and go to somewhere else. I couldn't even finish one slice, I feel like I'm going to get sick eating this undercooked piece of wet, floppy bread. I only ate the crust.I won't even feed this to my dogs because this piece of trash masquerading as pizza doesn't deserve to come out the other end and lay on my beautiful grass.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 2

Dennis RV

Not the best service. Maybe employee was having a bad day. Pizza was not the greatest especially for what they charge. Highly doubt I will go back to this location. Marco's and Angie's are still the best in the area!

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 2

Service: 1

SCUMDOG FISHING

Great

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Michael Whitacre

I placed an online order for almost $30 and selected cash as my form of payment. I get to the restaurant to pick up my order and the unsauced wings were sauced. Rather than complain I proceeded to pay for my order with a $50 and the lady behind the counter acted like I was handing her a snake. She then directed me to a small sign on the door that says nothing over $20:is excepted. I asked her how I was supposed to know that before 20 minutes as there was nothing mentioned about that when placing my online order. She stated it was company policy and there was nothing she could do about it. I had no choice but to cancel my order. The irony of it is that I placed the same order at a different location right after and they had no problem excepting my $50.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Chris Kelly

Was a regular, never again ever! After the way the shift manager treated and verbally abused my wife on the phone over being polite about asking for them to remake a pizza that had barley any sauce, not well done as ordered not for a refund! Me thinking to myself wow whoever’s having a bad day I’m gonna go up to the store and ask! I was polite she immediately became irate with me screaming it’s 2024 customers aren’t right anymore I was stunned seriously this women doesn’t deserve to be in any type of management role

Fro

Slightly lacking in flavor on all fronts. Even the garlic dip was bland. Slightly above average price. Every few years I go back to see if anything changed. Unfortunately, the food was maybe even a bit worse than I remembered from before. Trying not to be critical with the review, just comparing to other local / chain pizza places.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 2

Service: 4

Zackary Harbaugh

If you order a stuffed crust pizza on the app you will not get what you paid for I didn't even get a stuffed crust I'm going to report them to my bank and then file a report online bc they will steal

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

B Fletcher

Ordered pizza 2 nights ago. Wanted a thin crust with pepperoni and chicken. Got a regular crust with pepperoni and bacon. Called them and they said we could get another one that night or next time. We said next time. Fast forward 2 days. We order online and then call and ask for the free one to be added. The assistant manager Josh had a nasty attitude about it and said well now it'll be longer. We said ok that's fine. Pizza came and all they did was remake the previous one. Josh got real nasty about it and tried to tell us that we can get it next time. We tell him no. We want it now. So now we have to wait another half hour to get the pizza. Will not be ordering from here again, which is a shame because we always order a lot of food and tip the drivers very well.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 3

Service: 1

Cyndee Hrycyk

Amazing! Perfect life saver for dinner! And quick!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Garlic Cheese Bread, Pizza and Bread Sticks, Pepperoni Pizza

Load More