My husband and I have been going to Tomaso's for many years and we were happy that someone was purchasing the restaurant rather than it just being closed permanently. We were told the food would be the same, same recipes and quality etc. We ordered food for Pick Up yesterday and sadly it was not at all the same. My pizza tasted like one of those premade pop in the oven pizzas you can buy at Sam's Club. The sauce did not taste the same and the cheese was way too thick and completely tasted different overall. There were six of us eating and we had all frequented Tomaso's for many years. Not one of us thought it tasted the same at all. It's a shame that someone would buy the restaurant and not continue with the food recipe or quality. I know food costs are expensive but it's more expensive to lose your clientele. Was it edible? Sure. But for these prices it better taste the same. We had high hopes but this was sad and disappointing.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 2
Service: 2
Matt Gable
Been ordering from here my whole life, it's no longer the same. Hope the new owners plan to change the name, because under the "Tomaso's" name sake, it's a lie. Dough is different, like that of a gas station pizza quality, and the signature sauce - this is not it. Unfortunately we won't be returning unless there is a campaign, and return, to the original family recipes. So very disappointed.
Food: 1
Service: 3
Matthew Rowles
Such a disappointment. I spent my childhood eating here, but moved out of town and don’t get it often. Now under new ownership, the prices have almost doubled and the pizza is terrible. When we called to confirm if the menu had changed much we were told it was the same food. It’s absolutely not! Took 35 minutes for carry out and somehow the pizza was undercooked. The sausage was definitely not the same and something had a green pepper flavor. I had a sausage and pepperoni pizza. This pizza at these prices will never last in Barberton. Such a sad situation.
Food: 1
Service: 2
Kaity Covey
My boyfriend has been coming here since he was a kid, and we had gone there pretty regularly, however it had been a minute until tonight. We always get a pizza with pepperoni and sausage and salad, the prices are CRAZY now and the sausage was like the sausage you’d get off a frozen pizza, I was really disappointed I loved there pizza… the new owners are improving the inside however I’d prefer the grape vines and the good sausage??♀️
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 4
Nicole Taylor
We received a coupon in the mail in February 2024 (valid for 90 days) for a free, large 1 topping pizza as part of a welcome to Norton package. I called to redeem the coupon & apparently the new owners that took over in November 2023 don't want to honor these coupons. How disappointing and not a good way to gain new customers. The lady I spoke to on the phone was kind and so I have nothing against her. However, the new owners don't have customer service in mind which is not good for a restaurant business.
Atmosphere: 1
Service: 1
Kenneth Rader
Excellent food, and great service,
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
brian99xt
We loved tomassos under its previous owners. Now that it's reopened, we tried it out.Give it a few months at least (it's early Feb 24 right now) pretty sure our server was the only one working and doing everything. In 45 min all we had was soft drinks, and waited probably 20 min for a refill which we had to ask for. After our meal was well gone and we were just sitting around, it was about another 45 of no acknowledgement until we had to yell for our bill from the other side of the dining room.I'm sure it's still early on in the new ownership so there are going to be rough days & bumps in the road, but give it some time for them to get things up and running in full swing to go there.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 4
Service: 1
richard sanders
Decided to give Tomasos another try seeing how there are new owners, again walked out due to not being served, also dining room felt very unwelcoming -dark, paint peeling from ceiling over a table, nothing to absorb sound, and over all just very dirty looking. Waitress said someone would be with us shortly and watched as people that came in after us were given menus, will not give this place another chance, and definitely would not recommend to anyone.
Atmosphere: 1
Service: 1
Paul Evans
Two dinners to go was $37. Portions were kid size. Food was not made correctly to order. New owner needs to make corrections immediately. Or the business will fail.
Scott Berlin
Save your money and buy a frozen pizza. The quality will be better. We were told it's new ownership, ordered a large Hawaiian pizza paid 22 dollars, what a joke. The Lady working the cash register was not pleasant. To the new owners, you ruined a decent
The quality of food has been hit or miss here over the last few months. Tonight was really good, But the price is increased dramatically... $24 for Alfredo with broccoli and cauliflower. It has priced me out of coming here as regularly as we did.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 3
Jamison Fennel
Decent place.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Meat Sauce
Kym Rohrbach ..
Amazing ambiance, food, and service!!!!!! They have the best pizza and baked spaghetti I've ever had!
Amanda Morris
Never again, horrible
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 1
Service: 1
Irish Girl
Best thin pizza in Akron area. I love their sauce. Wonderful family place. Thank you for cooking for us for years and years. I hope you never close up shop.
My husband and I have been going to Tomaso's for many years and we were happy that someone was purchasing the restaurant rather than it just being closed permanently. We were told the food would be the same, same recipes and quality etc. We ordered food for Pick Up yesterday and sadly it was not at all the same. My pizza tasted like one of those premade pop in the oven pizzas you can buy at Sam's Club. The sauce did not taste the same and the cheese was way too thick and completely tasted different overall. There were six of us eating and we had all frequented Tomaso's for many years. Not one of us thought it tasted the same at all. It's a shame that someone would buy the restaurant and not continue with the food recipe or quality. I know food costs are expensive but it's more expensive to lose your clientele. Was it edible? Sure. But for these prices it better taste the same. We had high hopes but this was sad and disappointing.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 2
Service: 2
Been ordering from here my whole life, it's no longer the same. Hope the new owners plan to change the name, because under the "Tomaso's" name sake, it's a lie. Dough is different, like that of a gas station pizza quality, and the signature sauce - this is not it. Unfortunately we won't be returning unless there is a campaign, and return, to the original family recipes. So very disappointed.
Food: 1
Service: 3
Such a disappointment. I spent my childhood eating here, but moved out of town and don’t get it often. Now under new ownership, the prices have almost doubled and the pizza is terrible. When we called to confirm if the menu had changed much we were told it was the same food. It’s absolutely not! Took 35 minutes for carry out and somehow the pizza was undercooked. The sausage was definitely not the same and something had a green pepper flavor. I had a sausage and pepperoni pizza. This pizza at these prices will never last in Barberton. Such a sad situation.
Food: 1
Service: 2
My boyfriend has been coming here since he was a kid, and we had gone there pretty regularly, however it had been a minute until tonight. We always get a pizza with pepperoni and sausage and salad, the prices are CRAZY now and the sausage was like the sausage you’d get off a frozen pizza, I was really disappointed I loved there pizza… the new owners are improving the inside however I’d prefer the grape vines and the good sausage??♀️
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 4
We received a coupon in the mail in February 2024 (valid for 90 days) for a free, large 1 topping pizza as part of a welcome to Norton package. I called to redeem the coupon & apparently the new owners that took over in November 2023 don't want to honor these coupons. How disappointing and not a good way to gain new customers. The lady I spoke to on the phone was kind and so I have nothing against her. However, the new owners don't have customer service in mind which is not good for a restaurant business.
Atmosphere: 1
Service: 1
Excellent food, and great service,
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
We loved tomassos under its previous owners. Now that it's reopened, we tried it out.Give it a few months at least (it's early Feb 24 right now) pretty sure our server was the only one working and doing everything. In 45 min all we had was soft drinks, and waited probably 20 min for a refill which we had to ask for. After our meal was well gone and we were just sitting around, it was about another 45 of no acknowledgement until we had to yell for our bill from the other side of the dining room.I'm sure it's still early on in the new ownership so there are going to be rough days & bumps in the road, but give it some time for them to get things up and running in full swing to go there.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 4
Service: 1
Decided to give Tomasos another try seeing how there are new owners, again walked out due to not being served, also dining room felt very unwelcoming -dark, paint peeling from ceiling over a table, nothing to absorb sound, and over all just very dirty looking. Waitress said someone would be with us shortly and watched as people that came in after us were given menus, will not give this place another chance, and definitely would not recommend to anyone.
Atmosphere: 1
Service: 1
Two dinners to go was $37. Portions were kid size. Food was not made correctly to order. New owner needs to make corrections immediately. Or the business will fail.
Save your money and buy a frozen pizza. The quality will be better. We were told it's new ownership, ordered a large Hawaiian pizza paid 22 dollars, what a joke. The Lady working the cash register was not pleasant. To the new owners, you ruined a decent
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Restaurantji Recommends
The quality of food has been hit or miss here over the last few months. Tonight was really good, But the price is increased dramatically... $24 for Alfredo with broccoli and cauliflower. It has priced me out of coming here as regularly as we did.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 3
Decent place.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Meat Sauce
Amazing ambiance, food, and service!!!!!! They have the best pizza and baked spaghetti I've ever had!
Never again, horrible
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 1
Service: 1
Best thin pizza in Akron area. I love their sauce. Wonderful family place. Thank you for cooking for us for years and years. I hope you never close up shop.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Great Pizza