Pizza Restaurants near Barnesville

Domino's Pizza Pizza Delivery • $$
146 W Main St, Barnesville

Customers` Favorites

Deluxe Pizza

“have ordered delivery 3 times in a month from Barnesville location. So far, everything has been perfect and I'm Italian from Jersey! Yes, it's Doms so nothing like pizza in NJ/NY but I'm pleased!“

3.5 Good16 Reviews
Home Pizza Pizza Delivery • $
115 W Main St, Barnesville

Customers` Favorites

Salad

“I heard this was the same as Halloran's Home Pizza in St. C that has been out of business for a couple years.I bought two trays.I believe it is the same recipie with some minor differences.The dough is definitely thicker than St. C but tastes the same.The pizza that I bought were light on sauce but I think the sauce is the same. I will order extra next time especially with the thicker crust.The cheese seemed about the same.I'm in Columbus but grew up eating Home Pizza in St. C.Thank god these guys are here.Next time I'll see if they will sell me a gallon of sauce.“

3.1 Average17 Reviews
Pappy John's II, LLC Pizza • $
51943 OH-145, Beallsville - 10.39 miles

“A new pizza place in a small town..Stop as they where closingBut they still took the order..and was very nice about it..cars where still coming in to pick up orders..so we kinda knew it must be good pizzaWe just forgot to add cheeseYou order like subway/Chipotle's..But it was still goodAlso got a sub and garlic breadThey also have a Coffee shop that must be nice for locals to meet up.And ice cream we will try next time..We will try again but I'll not forget the cheese..“

4.8 Superb5 Reviews
Brown House Pizza Pizza • $
219 Pike St, Quaker City - 6.65 miles

Customers` Favorites

Meat Lovers Pizza
Pepperoni Pizza
Cheese Sticks
Cheese Bread
Subs

“Best pizza in guernsey county hands down. The staff is always so friendly and inviting. 10/10 recommend.Dietary restrictions: For anybody looking for an alternative to bread, they have an amazing cauliflower crust and delicious salads. The Italian salad is a favorite.“

4.5 Superb22 Reviews
Historic Beallsville Diner Diner • $
52733 Ohio Ave, Beallsville - 12.14 miles

Customers` Favorites

Fresh Cut Fries
Homemade Pie
Meat Loaf
Calzone
Pizza

“My husband and I stopped here for lunch on a whim. We love finding mom & pop diners. This one never disappoints. They have the best burgers and home cut fries.. also great pizza and delicious daily specials! We often travel the 20 mls. for lunch.“

4.4 Superb21 Reviews

Discover More Cuisines In Barnesville