I am not sure why Yelp "flagged" my original review of this location, but I have absolutely been here (more than once) and stand by my original review, listed here below including the pictures I took while on-site. Been here a few times now, as they are conveniently located near my new Wednesday golf league (at Coppertop Golf Club, just down 303). Service is pleasant, albeit on the slower side, so be aware if you are in a rush for some reason. They have what I'd call a "typical sports bar" set-up with plenty of table styles and bar seating to choose from including high tops and regular tables...we prefer the high tops. Have now had their chicken wings, a cheeseburger burger and also a dinner salad...all were pub grub style dishes of decent quality and taste. I would have preferred the wings to be a bit "wetter", but the meat was moist enough. Beers are cold, plenty to choose from on the menu...so guessing this may be a semi-regular spot for us, once we finish up on the golf course.
ManfredB44
The stromboli and fold overs are worth EVERY calorie! The wings have come a long way. Their hot cheesey bread is unique and will light you up!
Michael S.
Wow, LGBTQXYZ here, ordered a sub took 45 minutes, all staff has attitude, this place blows!!!!!
Brian P.
This place is great and they even deliver to valley city Ohio! We order pizzas salad and breadsticks and they are all very good we will continue to support them.
aaron lucas
Always a fair price. Staff always polite. I like the theme too.
Michele B.
We had a great first experience at Barley Jacks. It was a quiet Sunday afternoon and Gina was our server.I started with a simple mixed greens salad- perfect little salad, nothing unique but it was exactly what I needed. Husband had bone in wings that were perfection- crispy, plump, sauced adequately. Delicious flavorThen our sandwiches came. Y'all u was not prepared for what came next- they used their pizza dough for the sandwiches. They were HUGE! Husband loved his Cap'n Jack- it was a little like the Romanburger. Great grill flavor and meaty goodness. I really enjoyed my Cannon Ball, which is a meatball sub. The dough wasn't too thick and it was so cheesy! Both sandwiches served with fresh homemade chips. We liked the theme and overall atmosphere. They had moved around tables for social distancing and all wearing masks.Service was great and we thought the prices were a good value.I'm so glad I had this place bookmarked, we will be back for sure!
Rod Bagley
Some of the best pizza I have had in a long long time.
Cassandra Klink
Just got 2 large pizzas they are delicious! But above all the customer service was wonder. When I went i to pay the pizza still had a little time so the gentleman offered to bring it out to car since I had my son. Thank you!
Victoria Stosic
First time getting it today and I’m super impressed. Will be ordering often!
Ed H.
The Captain Jack Burger is the best. All of their food is great. The only issue we have is that the food can take a while to be cooked.
It was our 1st time here so we had to try a few things... We had wings, Cajun dry and garlic parm. Both were tasty. The veggie pizza was cheesy gooey, cooked nicely. (I felt there were too many tomatoes and not enough mushrooms). And the captain jack! The portions are worth the price. The prices are reasonable! The only issue we had was the wait to receive our food was pretty long. We will be going again.
Ashley Lutz
Great food and atmosphere. The owner is a lovely woman with a great personality. You feel right at home here
K Fizzle
The Cap'n Jack sandwich is very good. The battered mushrooms are delicous and are huge compared to most places! There Philly sandwich was also very good. A little limited on draft beer selection but they have wine and whiskey. They also have a pool table and board games.
Bubba Chiefalot22
Got the meat pizza very good very good service would recommend it
Lynn T.
If you have not tried it yet... You should. We had pizza as take out & it was good! Tonight eating at the bar... Yum! Calzone & homemade fried pickles. Not much inside, but food & service good! Clean too. Digital beer/ wine screen
I am not sure why Yelp "flagged" my original review of this location, but I have absolutely been here (more than once) and stand by my original review, listed here below including the pictures I took while on-site. Been here a few times now, as they are conveniently located near my new Wednesday golf league (at Coppertop Golf Club, just down 303). Service is pleasant, albeit on the slower side, so be aware if you are in a rush for some reason. They have what I'd call a "typical sports bar" set-up with plenty of table styles and bar seating to choose from including high tops and regular tables...we prefer the high tops. Have now had their chicken wings, a cheeseburger burger and also a dinner salad...all were pub grub style dishes of decent quality and taste. I would have preferred the wings to be a bit "wetter", but the meat was moist enough. Beers are cold, plenty to choose from on the menu...so guessing this may be a semi-regular spot for us, once we finish up on the golf course.
The stromboli and fold overs are worth EVERY calorie! The wings have come a long way. Their hot cheesey bread is unique and will light you up!
Wow, LGBTQXYZ here, ordered a sub took 45 minutes, all staff has attitude, this place blows!!!!!
This place is great and they even deliver to valley city Ohio! We order pizzas salad and breadsticks and they are all very good we will continue to support them.
Always a fair price. Staff always polite. I like the theme too.
We had a great first experience at Barley Jacks. It was a quiet Sunday afternoon and Gina was our server.I started with a simple mixed greens salad- perfect little salad, nothing unique but it was exactly what I needed. Husband had bone in wings that were perfection- crispy, plump, sauced adequately. Delicious flavorThen our sandwiches came. Y'all u was not prepared for what came next- they used their pizza dough for the sandwiches. They were HUGE! Husband loved his Cap'n Jack- it was a little like the Romanburger. Great grill flavor and meaty goodness. I really enjoyed my Cannon Ball, which is a meatball sub. The dough wasn't too thick and it was so cheesy! Both sandwiches served with fresh homemade chips. We liked the theme and overall atmosphere. They had moved around tables for social distancing and all wearing masks.Service was great and we thought the prices were a good value.I'm so glad I had this place bookmarked, we will be back for sure!
Some of the best pizza I have had in a long long time.
Just got 2 large pizzas they are delicious! But above all the customer service was wonder. When I went i to pay the pizza still had a little time so the gentleman offered to bring it out to car since I had my son. Thank you!
First time getting it today and I’m super impressed. Will be ordering often!
The Captain Jack Burger is the best. All of their food is great. The only issue we have is that the food can take a while to be cooked.
Restaurantji Recommends
It was our 1st time here so we had to try a few things... We had wings, Cajun dry and garlic parm. Both were tasty. The veggie pizza was cheesy gooey, cooked nicely. (I felt there were too many tomatoes and not enough mushrooms). And the captain jack! The portions are worth the price. The prices are reasonable! The only issue we had was the wait to receive our food was pretty long. We will be going again.
Great food and atmosphere. The owner is a lovely woman with a great personality. You feel right at home here
The Cap'n Jack sandwich is very good. The battered mushrooms are delicous and are huge compared to most places! There Philly sandwich was also very good. A little limited on draft beer selection but they have wine and whiskey. They also have a pool table and board games.
Got the meat pizza very good very good service would recommend it
If you have not tried it yet... You should. We had pizza as take out & it was good! Tonight eating at the bar... Yum! Calzone & homemade fried pickles. Not much inside, but food & service good! Clean too. Digital beer/ wine screen